Link


Social

Embed


Download

Download
Download Transcript


[00:00:01]

NINE 30.

ALL RIGHT.

GOOD MORNING.

THIS IS SUSIE CLIFTON FROM ERCOT.

WE'RE ABOUT TO GO AHEAD AND GET STARTED WITH THE, UH, TAC MEETING.

IF I COULD GET EVERYBODY IN THE ROOM TO JUST GO AHEAD AND TAKE THEIR SEATS, PLEASE, .

AND I'LL REAL QUICKLY GO THROUGH THE MEETING REMINDERS, THOSE OF YOU HERE IN THE ROOM TODAY.

UM, AS WE GET STARTED, AND YOU WOULD LIKE TO MAKE A MOTION OR, UH, COMMENT FOR DISCUSSION, PLEASE HOLD UP YOUR CARD AND JORDAN'S OVER HERE IN THE CORNER.

HE WILL ENTER YOU INTO THE CHAT, OR YOU CAN ENTER YOURSELF INTO THE CHAT IF YOU'RE LOGGED INTO THE WEBEX.

AND THEN THOSE, OF COURSE, ON THE WEBEX, YOU'LL NEED TO ENTER THE CHAT AND WAIT FOR THE CHAIR TO RECOGNIZE YOU.

AND THEN, UM, AS WE APPROACH THE BALLOTING PROCESS TODAY, AND YOU'RE ON THE WEBEX, PLEASE MAKE SURE TO UNMUTE YOURSELF AS WE APPROACH YOUR SEGMENT.

AND THEN AFTER WE BEGIN, UM, AFTER YOU CAST YOUR BALLOT, PLEASE GO BACK TO THE MUTE STATUS AND THAT WILL HELP US BE A LITTLE MORE EFFICIENT WITH THAT PROCESS.

AND THEN IF THE WEBEX ENDS FOR ANY MEETING, UH, ANY REASON, WE'LL GO AHEAD AND RESTART WITH A NEW WEBEX DETAILS IF NEEDED, AND SEND THAT TO THE LISTSERV LIKE WE DID THIS MORNING.

I DO APOLOGIZE WE HAD SOME TROUBLE WITH THAT, BUT THAT'S THE PROCESS.

IF, UH, WE CAN'T RE-LOG IN WITH THE SAME MEETING DETAILS, WE'LL SEND SOMETHING TO THE LISTSERV.

AND THE FINAL REMINDER, THERE'S A SIGN IN SHEET OUTSIDE THE MEETING ROOM DOOR, IF YOU'LL PLEASE REMEMBER IF YOU'RE HERE TODAY TO SIGN IN.

AND WITH THAT, KAITLYN, WE DO HAVE A QUORUM AND ARE READY TO GET STARTED.

GREAT.

THANKS, SUSIE.

ALRIGHT, GOOD MORNING.

UM, IT'S MAY 22ND.

THIS IS OUR REGULAR FULL MEETING FOR, FOR MAY TAC.

UM, WE HAVE A FULL AGENDA.

WE DID HAVE A TOTAL OF THREE ADDITIONAL TAC MEETINGS IN ADDITION TO THIS ONE SCHEDULED BETWEEN APRIL AND JUNE BOARD MEETINGS, UM, WITH A FOCUS ON NO GO 2 45.

SO THE PLAN FOR TODAY IS TO TAKE UP OUR, OUR FULL MAY AGENDA, HOPEFULLY WRAP THAT UP AROUND ONE, TAKE A QUICK BREAK FOR LUNCH, AND THEN RESUME TO TAKE UP, NO, GO 2 45 ON THE SCREEN AS ANTITRUST

[1. Antitrust Admonition]

TO AVOID RAISING CONCERNS ABOUT ANTITRUST LIABILITY.

PARTICIPANTS IN ERCOT ACTIVITY SHOULD REFRAIN FROM PROPOSING ANY ACTION OR MEASURE THAT WOULD EXCEED OR CUTS AUTHORITY UNDER FEDERAL OR STATE LAW.

AND THERE'S MORE INFORMATION ON THE WEBSITE.

AND I WANNA SAY THANK YOU TO SUSIE FOR THE NAME TAG.

WE WERE SUPPOSED TO HAVE A, A SPECIAL VISITOR TODAY.

MY, MY DAUGHTER IS HERE IN TOWN.

WE BRIEFLY RELOCATED FROM HOUSTON DUE TO THE STORM.

SO WE WANNA THANK EVERYBODY FOR THEIR HARD WORK, RESTORING POWER THERE.

UM, AND UNFORTUNATELY SHE WAS NOT ABLE TO JOIN, BUT SHE WOULD'VE JUST MADE A CAMEO AND LEFT.

UM, SO FOR PROXIES AND AL ALT REPS, UM, FOR PROXIES IN THE COMMERCIAL CONSUMER SEGMENT WE HAVE, NICK FEHRENBACH HAS GIVEN HIS PROXY TO RICK GARETT.

UM, IN THE RESIDENTIAL CONSUMER SEGMENT, ERIC GOFF HAS GIVEN HIS PROXY TO NAVA FOR NOER 2 45 ONLY.

UM, IN THE INDUSTRIAL CONSUMER CON SE SEGMENT, GARRETT KENT HAS GIVEN HIS PROXY TO ERIC SCHUBERT AT 2:00 PM IN THE COOPERATIVE SEGMENT.

MICHAEL WISE IS GIVING HIS PROXY TO BLAKE COLT AT 1:30 PM AND IN THE, UM, INDEPENDENT RETAIL SEGMENT, JAY HARPO IS GIVING HIS PROXY TO CHRIS HENDRICKS FROM 11:00 AM TO 12:30 PM FOR AL ALT REPS IN THE COMMERCIAL CONSUMER SEGMENT.

MARK DREYFUS HAS GIVEN HIS ALT REP TO RICK GARETT IN THE COOPERATIVE SEGMENT.

JOHN PACKARD HAS GIVEN HIS ALT REP TO LUCAS TURNER, AND IN THE IOU SEGMENT, KEITH NICKS HAS GIVEN HIS ALT REP TO STACY WHITEHURST.

AND WITH THAT, WE CAN GET STARTED.

SO OUR FIRST AGENDA ITEM

[2. Approval of TAC Meeting Minutes]

IS THE APPROVAL OF THE APRIL 15TH TECH MEETING MINUTES.

I, I DON'T BELIEVE I'M AWARE OF ANY EDITS OR COMMENTS.

SUSIE, CAN YOU CONFIRM THAT THAT IS CORRECT, CAITLYN? ALRIGHT, SO IF THERE'S NO OTHER COMMENTS, CAN WE ADD THIS TO THE COMBO BALLOT? I THINK SO, COREY, I DON'T SEE ANY YESES OR NOS.

SO, AND THEN I SEE IN THE QUEUE THAT THE PHRASE OF THE MONTH IS WORDS MATTER.

RICHARD ROSS, DO YOU WANNA ELABORATE? BOB HILTON, WOULD YOU LIKE TO ELABORATE? I WOULD JUST ASK FOR A FRIENDLY AMENDMENT ALREADY.

ALREADY.

HEY, RICHARD, HOW ABOUT THE WORD INNOVATION TO GO ALONG WITH WHAT WE'VE DONE THIS WEEK OR A DERIVATIVE THEREOF? YOU KNOW, I HATE TO BE DIFFICULT, BUT, YOU KNOW, IT'S MOUTH PHRASE OF THE MONTH.

SO

[00:05:01]

, HEY, I CALLED A QUESTION.

IT IT, OKAY, THANKS RICHARD.

IT, IT STEMS FROM AN ARGUMENT, UH, OR DEBATE THAT, UH, ONE OF THE STAFF MEMBERS AT AN RTO HAD WITH THEIR BOSS.

AND IT WAS, IT JUST EVOLVED FROM THERE.

IT'S BEEN, BEEN USED QUITE WELL THIS WEEK AT, UH, SPP MEETINGS.

AND I, I'M QUITE CONFIDENT Y YOU GUYS CAN PULL IT OFF TODAY AS WELL.

OKAY.

I THINK IT'LL COME UP A LOT IN THE AFTERNOON DISCUSSION.

UM, AND MAYBE WE CAN INNOVATE ON OUR PHRASES OF THE MONTH FOR NEXT YEAR.

SO OUR, THE GO AHEAD RICHARD, OR YOU'RE NOT OPEN TO THAT .

I WILL, I WILL PUT IT IN THE QUEUE.

OKAY.

WE'LL PUT IT ON OUR, UH, TACK GOALS SO WE CAN MOVE ON TO MEETING UPDATES.

[3. Meeting Updates]

UM, SINCE OUR LAST REGULAR TECH MEETING IN APRIL, AS I SAID, WE, WE'VE HAD A NUMBER OF EXTRA MEETINGS, BUT THE ERCOT BOARD HAD MEETINGS ON APRIL 22ND AND 23RD, AND THE PUC HAD AN OPEN MEETING ON APRIL 25TH.

UM, AND, AND ON MAY 10TH, WE HAD AN ATTACK WORKSHOP ON NORE 2 45.

JUST INDICATED THAT AS A WORKSHOP, BECAUSE IT WAS NON-VOTING AT THE APRIL 22ND AND 23RD BOARD MEETINGS, THE BOARD DID APPROVE ALL REVISION REQUESTS EXCEPT FOR NORE 2 45, WHICH WAS REMANDED HERE.

WE'RE ALL FAMILIAR WITH THAT.

AND AT THE APRIL 25TH OPEN MEETING, THE PUC APPROVED R-M-G-R-R 180.

SO NOW WE ARE ON TO OUR REVISION

[4. Review of Revision Request Summary/ERCOT Market Impact Statement/Opinions]

REQUEST SUMMARIES, UH, MARKET IMPACT STATEMENTS, AND IMM OPINIONS.

UH, WE WILL TURN IT OVER TO ANN.

ALRIGHT, WE HAVE OUR REVISION REQUEST SUMMARY FOR THIS TAC MEETING, AND THIS WAS POSTED TO THE TAC MATERIALS.

UM, FOR THE REASON FOR REVISIONS, WE HAVE FOUR THAT ARE HITTING THE STRATEGIC PLAN.

OBJECTIVE ONE THREE THAT ARE HITTING SP O2 AND THEN GENERAL ASSISTANT PROCESS IMPROVEMENTS.

WE HAVE THREE BOARD, PUC DIRECTIVE, WE HAVE TWO.

AND THEN REGULAR REGULATORY REQUIREMENTS.

WE HAVE ONE, UM, FOR IMPACTS, I WILL POINT OUT 1198 DOES HAVE A 50 TO 80 K BUDGETARY IMPACT AND 180 TO TWO 20 K STAFFING IMPACT.

THIS ONE WILL REQUIRE ONE FTE, UM, FOR ERCOT OPINIONS AND MARKET IMPACT STATEMENTS.

ERCOT DOES SUPPORT ALL REVISION REQUESTS HERE EXCEPT FOR PGR 1 0 5 AS RECOMMENDED BY ROSS.

UM, THAT ONE LATER ON IN THE AGENDA, THERE WAS A REQUEST FOR WITHDRAWAL FILED ON THAT ONE.

AND THEN THE IMM OPINIONS, THEY DO SUPPORT 11 98, 12 28, 12 30, PG ONE 13, AND NEGRA 2 58.

THEY DID FILE COMMENTS ON 1124.

AND THEN NO OPINION ON THE REMAINING REVISION REQUESTS.

I GUESS WE'LL ASK THE IMM IF THEY WANNA ADD ANYTHING.

NO, NOT AT THIS TIME.

THANKS.

OKAY, THANK YOU.

ALL RIGHT.

ANY QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS ON THIS ITEM? OKAY, WE ARE MOVING RIGHT ALONG.

I THINK WE

[5. PRS Report (Vote)]

ARE UP TO THE PRS REPORT.

DIANA, ARE YOU READY? I THINK WE, SO WE HAVE A NUMBER OF REVISION REQUESTS BEFORE US FROM PRS AND, AND MANY OF THE UNOPPOSED ITEMS HAD ABSTENTIONS.

SO I, I THINK WE'LL TAKE THIS SIDE BY SIDE AND SEE WHAT WE CAN PUT ON THE COMBO BALLOT AND WHAT WE NEED SEPARATE BALLOTS FOR.

SO, SO DIANA, LET'S DO THIS FIRST SLIDE AND THEN STOP AND, AND SEE WHAT WE CAN DO WITH FOUR N PRRS.

OKAY.

GOOD MORNING EVERYBODY.

DIANA COLEMAN WITH CPS ENERGY FOR THE MAY PRS REPORT.

FOR THE I, THE PROPOSED REVISIONS THAT DON'T HAVE ANY COST ASSOCIATED WITH THEM, WE HAVE 1220 THAT COMES TO US FROM ERCOT.

THIS IS MODIFYING THE MARKET RESTART PROCESS.

IN APRIL, PRS VOTED TO UNANIMOUSLY RECOMMEND APPROVAL AS SUBMITTED.

AND THEN EARLIER THIS MONTH, WE ENDORSED IT AND FORWARDED AN ATTACK WITH THE IA THAT WAS POSTED ON MARCH 20TH FOR 1222.

ALSO SPONSORED BY ERCOT.

THIS IS CONSISTENT WITH ERCOT CONVERSATIONS.

ON THE FINAL APPROVAL FOR THE OTHER BINDING DOCUMENT TO REQUIRE BOARD APPROVAL IN APRIL, WE VOTED UNANIMOUSLY TO RECOMMEND APPROVAL, AND THEN IN MAY, WE ENDORSED IT WITH THE MARCH 20TH IA AS WELL.

1223.

ALSO FROM ERCOT, THIS IS UPDATING THE TDSP APPLICATION FOR REGISTRATION.

IN APRIL, WE VOTED TO RECOMMEND APPROVAL, AND THEN IN MAY, WE UNANIMOUSLY ENDORSED WITH THE APRIL 5TH PRS REPORT AS REVISED BY PRS AND THE MARCH 21ST

[00:10:02]

IA, AND THEN 1228 FROM ERCOT.

THIS IS DECREASING FROM TWO TO ONE, THE NUMBER OF FIRM FUEL OBLIGATION PERIODS THAT ARE AWARDED IN A PROCUREMENT.

EARLIER THIS MONTH, WE VOTED TO UNANIMOUSLY GRANT URGENT STATUS AND THEN RECOMMENDED APPROVAL AS SUBMITTED WITH THE MAY 2ND IMPACT ANALYSIS.

OKAY, SO WE WOULD BE LOOKING TO RECOMMEND APPROVAL OF NPRR 12, 20 12, 22, 12 23, AND 1228, ALL AS RECOMMENDED BY PRS IN THE FIVE NINE PRS REPORT.

CAN WE ADD THESE TO THE COMBO BALLOT, OR DOES ANYONE WANNA PULL ONE OF THESE OFF FOR A SEPARATE BALLOT? OKAY, I THINK WE CAN ADD THESE FOUR TO THE COMBO BALLOT.

OKAY, GREAT.

NEXT UP, WE HAVE 1198.

THIS IS COMING TO US FROM EDF RENEWABLES.

THIS IS DEFINING THE EAPS AS A TYPE OF CONSTRAINT MANAGEMENT PLAN.

IN APRIL, WE VOTED TO RECOMMEND APPROVAL OF 1198 AS AMENDED BY THE MARCH 8TH LCRA COMMENTS.

THERE WERE FOUR ABSTENTIONS ON THAT VOTE.

AND THEN IN MAY, PRS VOTED TO ENDORSE WITH THE APRIL 5TH PRS REPORT AND THE APRIL 30TH IA WITH A RECOMMENDED PRIORITY OF 2025 AND A RANK OF 45 20.

AND THEN 1218 COMES TO US FROM ERCOT.

THIS IS UPDATING SECTION 14 FOR THE REC TRADING PROGRAM TO COMPLY WITH THE PUC SUBSTANTIVE RULES.

THIS WAS VOTED UNANIMOUSLY AT THE APRIL 25TH, OR EXCUSE ME, THE APRIL 5TH PRS, UM, AS AMENDED BY THE APRIL 4TH RELIANT COMMENTS.

AND THEN IN MAY, WE VOTED UNANIMOUSLY TO ENDORSE WITH THE MARCH 5TH IMPACT ANALYSIS.

OKAY, SO BOTH OF THESE HAVE A IMPACT AND HAD ABSTENTIONS, UM, NPR 1198, WE'D BE LOOKING TO RECOMMEND APPROVAL AS RECOMMENDED BY PRS IN THE FIVE NINE PRS REPORT.

DO WE NEED A SEPARATE BALLOT FOR THIS ONE? YES.

OKAY.

YES.

COREY, CAN WE TAKE IT AWAY ON 1198? ARE THERE ANY, BRIAN, DO YOU HAVE COMMENTS? YEAH, SO FOR ERCOT, THE REASON FOR MY ABSTENTION IS THAT, UH, GENERALLY WE THINK THAT SCED SOLUTIONS ARE THE PREFERRED OUTCOME.

AND THIS, UM, CONGESTION MITIGATION TOOL IS OUTSIDE OF SCED FOR THESE EAPS.

UM, THE LANGUAGE DOES TALK ABOUT TRANSPARENCY.

WE LIKE THAT.

UM, BUT IT, IT'S MORE OF A, A PHILOSOPHICAL PREFERENCE.

THANK YOU.

OKAY.

AND WE DID WANT TO NOTE THAT WE HAVE ASSOCIATED, UH, PGRR ONE 13 AND NO, 2 58 LATER IN THE ROSS REPORT.

DID WE WANT TO ADD THOSE TWO ITEMS TO THIS BALLOT? I, I, I HAVE MY COMMENTS REALLY APPLY TO EVERYTHING.

AND IF IT'S MORE ADMINISTRATIVELY EFFICIENT FOR THIS, I'D SUPPORT TAKING THEM ALL UP AT THE SAME TIME.

OKAY.

OKAY.

BECAUSE I'LL BE ABSTAINING ON ALL OF THEM.

, I SEE SOME THUMBS UPS.

SO LET'S, LET'S DO THAT.

AND NODS.

OKAY.

ALEX MILLER IN THE QUEUE.

THANK YOU.

I DID.

I APPRECIATE BRIAN'S COMMENTS.

AND I DID JUST WANNA STRESS THAT WE, UM, YOU KNOW, WERE VERY THOROUGH WITH INCLUDING ALL OF THE INPUT AND REQUESTS FOR ENSURING THAT TRANSPARENCY WAS CONSIDERED THROUGHOUT THE, THE CHANGES THAT WERE MADE AS WE CAME TO THE FINAL LANGUAGE.

UM, AND, AND THE, THE CED ISSUE, THIS IS NOT SOMETHING THAT IS DONE OUTSIDE OF SC.

IT IS A CHANGE TO THE SYSTEM CONFIGURATION.

AND THEN THAT IS WHAT GOES TO SC.

SO IT'S NOT BYPASSING SC, IT IS ALLOWING TRANSMISSION O OWNERS TO OPERATE, OPERATE THEIR GRID, CHOOSE WHAT TOPOLOGY IS GOING INTO SKID.

SO WE'RE WE, YOU KNOW, HAVE A, HAVE A, UM, JUST WANTED TO, TO CLARIFY THAT, BUT WE DO APPRECIATE AND UNDERSTAND BRIAN'S POSITION.

OKAY.

ANYONE ELSE IN THE QUEUE BEFORE WE GO TO THE VOTE? AND COREY HAS IT PULLED UP.

SO IT WOULD BE TO RECOMMEND APPROVAL OF NPR 1198 IS RECOMMENDED BY PRS IN THE FIVE NINE PRS REPORT TO RECOMMEND APPROVAL OF PIGGER ONE 13 IS RECOMMENDED BY ROSS IN THE FIVE TWO ROSS REPORT.

AND TO RECOMMEND APPROVAL OF NOER 2 58 AS RECOMMENDED BY ROSS IN THE FIVE TWO ROSS REPORT.

[00:15:01]

Q LOOKS CLEAR.

I THINK YOU CAN TAKE IT AWAY.

CORY, I WOULD LOVE TO GET A MOTION ON A SECOND.

OH, MOTION A SECOND WOULD BE GREAT.

SORRY, I READ I ALSO BEAUTIFULLY, I, I'M, YEAH, WELL, YOU KNOW, THE BABY WAS SUPPOSED TO DO THAT PART.

SO WE'RE GIVE WHO ARE WE GIVING THE MOTION TO? KEVIN HANSEN.

AND SECOND TO BLAKE.

ALL RIGHT.

OKAY.

ON THAT MOTION TO RECOMMEND APPROVAL OF 1198 AND FRIENDS, WE WILL START UP WITH THE CONSUMERS.

WITH ERIC? YES.

HUGH NA.

YES.

THANK YOU.

THANK YOU.

GARRETT.

YES, SIR.

THANK YOU, SIR.

ERIC? YES.

THANK YOU.

AND RICK FOR MARK? YES.

THANK YOU.

AND THEN RICK FOR NICK? YES.

THANK YOU.

ONTO OUR CO-OPS.

MIKE? YES.

THANKS, BLAKE.

YES.

THANK YOU, ERIC.

YES.

THANK YOU.

THANK YOU LUCAS, FOR JOHN.

I SEE HE CAME OFF MUTE.

LUCAS, BUT I DIDN'T HEAR YOUR VOTE.

I CAN TAKE YOU IN CHAT.

OH, I GOT YOU IN CHAD AS A YES.

THANK YOU, LUCAS.

ONTO OUR INDEPENDENT GENERATORS.

BRIAN? YES.

I'M SORRY.

ABSTAIN.

AND THANK YOU FOR, UH, BEARING WITH ME.

GOTCHA.

CHANGE, CHANGING, CHANGING YOUR MIND IS WHAT TAX'S ALL ABOUT.

BRIAN, I APPRECIATE I MEANT, MEANT TO SAY YES.

CA THANK YOU FOR, FOR LISTENING TO ME.

I THINK HE WAS GONNA BE A YES ON THAT.

AND, UH, ABSTAIN ON THE COMBO BALLOT.

I HAD TO, I HAD TO DO IT.

WORDS MATTER.

BRIAN CA CAITLYN YOUR VOTE ABSTAIN, PLEASE.

OKAY, THANK YOU.

BOB HILTON? YES, SIR.

THANK SIR NED? YES, SIR.

THANK YOU.

CORY AND IPMS REMI? YES.

THANK YOU.

JEREMY.

YES.

THANK YOU.

THANK YOU.

IAN? YES.

THANK YOU, CORY.

THANK YOU KEVIN.

YES, THANK YOU.

THANK YOU.

ONTO OUR I REPS.

BILL? YES.

THANK YOU.

JENNIFER.

I'M NOT SURE IF JENNIFER'S WITH US YET.

HOW ABOUT JAY? YES.

THANKS SIR.

CHRIS? YES.

THANK YOU.

UNDER IOUS, STACY FOR KEITH? YES.

THANK YOU, DAVID.

THANK YOU.

SAME.

THANK YOU IAIN FROM DAVID COLIN? YES.

THANK YOU, RICHARD.

YES.

THANK YOU.

ANDRA.

MUNIS RUSSELL? YES.

THANK YOU.

JOSE? YES.

THANK YOU, DAVID.

YES.

YES.

THANK YOU.

CORY, DID YOU CATCH THE CHANGE IN VOTE IN THE QUEUE FROM LUCAS? OH, OKAY.

WE WILL MAKE THAT AN ABSTAIN.

OKAY.

MOTION CARRIES FOR ABSTENTIONS.

OKAY.

ANY QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS HERE? ALL RIGHT, DIANA.

I THINK WE ARE BACK TO NPR 1218 REC PROGRAM CHANGES.

OKAY, SO 1218 COMES TO US FROM ERCOT.

THIS IS UPDATING THE, UH, SECTION 14 FOR THE REC TRADING PROGRAM TO BE COMPLIANT WITH THE SUBSTANTIVE RULES AT THE COMMISSION.

IN APRIL.

WE VOTED UNANIMOUSLY TO RECOMMEND APPROVAL AS AMENDED BY THE, UM, APRIL 4TH RELAYING COMMENTS.

AND THEN ON MAY 9TH, WE VOTED UNANIMOUSLY TO ENDORSE AND FORWARD THE APRIL 5TH PRS REPORT WITH THE MARCH 5TH IA.

WE ARE LOOKING FOR, UM, TO, TO RECOMME TO APPROVE NPRR 1218 IS RECOMMENDED BY THE BY PRS IN THE FIVE NINE PRS REPORT.

DO WE NEED A SEPARATE BALLOT FOR THIS ONE OR CAN WE ADD IT TO THE COMBO BALLOT BILL? I DON'T BELIEVE THIS WAS CONTROVERSIAL AT ALL.

AND WE, UM, GOT APPROVAL FROM ERCOT ON THE MODIFIED COMMENTS WE SUBMITTED.

SO I'M HOPING THIS IS A COMBO BALLOT ITEM.

I THINK THERE WERE A NUMBER OF ABSTENTIONS, SO JUST CHECKING NOT ON, NOT ON THIS ONE.

ON 1218.

NO, THIS ONE WAS UNANIMOUSLY ENDORSED.

I THOUGHT I ABSTAINED ON THIS ONE.

OKAY.

UM, LET'S ADD IT TO THE COMBO BALLOT THEN.

OKAY.

I'M NOT GONNA CALL IT A BRIAN SAMS .

[00:20:01]

OKAY.

WE WERE GOING TO TAKE THESE OUT OF ORDER KIND OF BASED ON LENGTH OF TIME THAT WE THINK THEY WILL TAKE TO DISCUSS.

SO LET'S GO FIRST TO NPR 1230.

OKAY.

SO 1230 COMES TO US FROM ERCOT.

THIS IS ESTABLISHING A SHADOW PRICE CAP FOR CONGESTION THAT IS IMPACTING AN EYE ROLL, UH, OR AN INTERCONNECTION RELIABILITY OPERATING LIMIT IN MAY.

WE VOTED TO GRANT URGENT STATUS AND THERE WERE OPPOSING VOTES ON THAT.

AND THEN WE VOTED TO RECOMMEND APPROVAL OF 1230 AS REVISED BY PRS WITH THE MAY 7TH IA.

AND THERE WERE 12 ABSTENTIONS ON THAT BOAT.

OKAY.

ANY DISCUSSION ON NPR 1230? DAVID KEY? YEAH, WE HAD SOME CONCERNS WITH, I GUESS, THE SWIFTNESS AT THIS MOVE THROUGH THE PROCESS.

UM, I THINK THERE WAS A TOTAL OF TWO DAYS GIVEN TO PRS TO REVIEW THIS.

AND ALTHOUGH IT'S NOT SOMETHING NEW, IT IS A VERY IMPACTFUL CHANGE TO PRICING THAT IS, UH, GIVEN TO US WITH VERY LITTLE NOTICE TO, TO WORK THROUGH.

UM, WE'RE, WE HAVE QUESTIONS, WE ARE HAVE SOME TIME SCHEDULED WITH TO WORK THROUGH THIS.

UM, GONNA BE ASKING FOR SOME TIME TODAY, UH, FROM THIS GROUP FOR A TABLE.

UM, REALLY THE PROCESS TO GET THIS CHANGED IS, UH, BEEN RUSHED.

WE FEEL THAT WE NEED SOME MORE TIME TO WORK ON IT.

SO WE MAKING A MOTION TO TABLE THAT.

OKAY.

I, I DON'T THINK WE NEED A MOTION TO TABLE.

I THINK IT, WE DO NEED A MOTION 'CAUSE IT'S THE FIRST TIME IT'S BEEN HERE.

OKAY.

IS THERE A SECOND TO DAVID'S MOTION? SECOND.

SECOND FROM ALICIA.

ALL RIGHT.

I SEE.

ARE YOU IN THE QUEUE OTHER THAN THE SECOND? WOULD YOU LIKE TO SPEAK? WOW.

.

WELL, I HAVE YOUR NAME FIRST AND THEN I'LL GO TO ERIC AND NED.

I'M JUST GONNA SECOND WHAT DAVID SAID, BASICALLY.

OKAY.

OKAY.

UH, I SAID THAT REVERSED.

I THINK.

SO NED, THEN ERIC, THEN BRIAN.

THANK YOU, CAITLIN.

UM, CERTAINLY APPRECIATE THAT.

THIS, UH, THIS CAME IN FORMALLY, UH, RELATIVELY RECENTLY.

I CAN REMEMBER TALKING ABOUT THIS AND I, FRANKLY, I CAN'T REMEMBER WHICH SUBCOMMITTEE IT WAS IN, UH, BACK IN THE FALL.

SO I, I KNOW THE CONCEPT HAS BEEN, UH, PERCOLATING AND HAS BEEN DISCUSSED BEFORE.

IT DOES SEEM LIKE IT'S A VERY, YOU KNOW, ELEGANT SOLUTION TO TRY TO ALLOW SCED TO RESOLVE, UH, AN, AN AN ISSUE AND AVOID EMERGENCY CONDITIONS.

SO, UM, YOU KNOW, WE'RE, WE ARE SUPPORT, UH, SUPPORTIVE OF THIS PROPOSAL.

UM, BUT UNDERSTAND THAT THERE ARE, THERE ARE FOLKS THAT WANNA UNDERSTAND THAT WANT TO HAVE A LITTLE BIT MORE TIME TO REVIEW.

AND I THINK WE CAN STILL GET TO THE JUNE BOARD EVEN WITH THAT TIME, GIVEN THAT WE HAVE ADDITIONAL, UM, ADDITIONAL AT BATS WITH TECH.

OKAY.

ERIC GUFF, IF WE WERE TO TABLE IT, UM, WE HAVE A, A FEW MEETINGS SCHEDULED.

IS THIS SOMETHING, DAVID, THAT YOU'D WANNA SEE COME UP AT ONE OF THE MEETINGS TO GET IT TO THE JUNE BOARD? OR DO YOU, WOULD YOU PREFER IT TO BE TABLED FOR LONGER THAN THAT? I THINK AT THIS POINT WE PREFER TO BE TABLED LONGER THAN THAT.

I'LL PROBABLY HAVE SOME BETTER INFORMATION AFTER WE MEET WITH ERCOT.

UM, SO I MIGHT BE ABLE TO CHANGE, BUT AT THIS POINT, UM, REALLY LOOKING FOR MORE TIME JUST TO, TO WORK ON IT AND NOT OKAY.

GIVEN THE DISCUSSION TODAY, WE'LL SEE HOW LONG IT TAKES TO GET TO, UH, TO ERCOT.

SO THEN, I GUESS MY, MY QUESTION, UM, FOR ERCOT IS IF THIS IS NOT IMPLEMENTED, HOW WOULD IT IMPACT MANAGEMENT OF THIS IRRL THIS SUMMER? YEAH, FREDDY, WHY DON'T YOU RESPOND? SO FREDDY GARCIA OPERATIONS AND, AND I GUESS TO GIVE A LITTLE BIT MORE CONTEXT ON, ON WHY THE URGENT STATUSES TO HAVE IT IN FOR, FOR SUMMER AND, AND POTENTIAL TIGHT CONDITIONS AND TO GIVE THE CONTROL ROOM ADDITIONAL TOOLS TO MANAGE THE IOL.

UM, IF WE DON'T PUT THIS IN BY THE SUMMER, WE'RE JUST GONNA CONTINUE WITH WHAT WE'VE BEEN DOING LAST SUMMER, IS DOING HDL OVERRIDES THAT, THAT'S THE ALTERNATIVE WE HAVE.

AND, AND BASED ON LAST SUMMER CONDITIONS, UH, WE PRETTY MUCH EXPECT THAT WE WILL HAVE TO DO THAT, UM, AS CONDITIONS GET TIGHT.

SO HDO OVERRIDES WILL RESULT IN AN UPLIFT, UM, WHEREAS DOING THE SHADOW PRICE CAP WOULD BE, IF PEOPLE ARE HEDGED FOR ENERGY, THEN THEY'D BE HEDGED FOR THE COST OF THE SHADOW PRICE CAP.

SO THE SHADOW

[00:25:01]

PRICE CAP IS CHANGING.

I, I CAN'T HEAR YOU.

I I WOULD JUST SAY MANY OF US HAVE NOT HEDGED FOR THE SHADOW PRICE CAP CHANGE.

OKAY.

AND THAT GOES BACK TO THE NOTICE ISSUE THAT WE ARE, YOU'RE TALKING ABOUT, WE HAVE TALKED ABOUT THIS, BUT IT WASN'T PUT FORTH UNTIL, YOU KNOW, TWO DAYS BEFORE PRS MEETING.

SO THAT'S THE CONCERN WE HAVE.

OKAY.

BRIAN SAMS YEAH, I, I AGREE TIMING IS AN ISSUE ON THIS.

UH, YOU KNOW, WE DID SEE THAT TWO DAYS BEFORE PRS, UM, MY SHOP REACHED OUT TO ERCOT, AND I REALLY DO APPRECIATE THE TIME ERCOT GAVE TO US, UM, TO JUST HELP US UNDERSTAND IT A LITTLE BIT BETTER.

UM, WE ALSO THOUGHT THAT THERE COULD BE SOME OTHER SOLUTIONS BEYOND JUST THE HDL OVERRIDE THAT FREDDIE MENTIONED, UH, INCLUDING, UM, MANAGING SOME OF THE EXISTING GTCS THAT WE ALREADY HAVE, UH, A LITTLE BIT BETTER.

UM, AND I CAN GET INTO SOME OF THE DETAILS AROUND THAT OR, OR NOT, BUT, UM, WE, WE WOULD SUPPORT JUST UNDERSTANDING THIS BETTER.

THANK YOU.

OKAY.

DID YOU WANNA GET INTO MORE DETAILS? ALL RIGHT.

SO I'M GONNA BE READING THE NOTES HERE THAT I HAVE FOR MY TRANSMISSION DESK, BUT BASICALLY THERE ARE THREE GTCS, THIS NELSON TO SHARP RIO HONDA, THE RAYMONDVILLE, RIO HONDO NORTH EDINBURGH TO LOBO GTCS THAT ARE EXISTING THAT WE'VE SEEN SUCCESSFULLY MANAGE RELIABILITY AND A LOWER LIMIT ON ANY OR ALL OF THOSE CAN HELP CONTROL THE, THE SOUTH TEXAS, UH, POWER FLOWS.

AND SO, UH, THAT'S, THAT'S ANOTHER WAY TO HELP.

GREAT.

THANK YOU.

FREDDY, DID YOU HAVE ANOTHER COMMENT? UH, I GUESS JUST TO UNDERSTAND THAT A LITTLE BIT MORE, BRIAN, THAT'S, WE'D BE ARTIFICIALLY DE-RATING THOSE GTCS TO MANAGE A DIFFERENT GTC.

IS THAT, IS THAT ESSENTIALLY WHAT I'M HEARING? I DON'T KNOW ABOUT YOUR CHARACTERIZATION OF ARTIFICIALLY, UM, BUT IT, THAT IT WOULD BE LOWERING THOSE LIMITS TO HELP WITH THE, UM, THE SOUTH TEXAS GTC.

I MEAN, JUST THINKING ABOUT THAT, IT JUST SEEMS LIKE THAT MIGHT BE SOMETHING ALSO DIFFICULT TO HEDGE AGAINST AS WELL.

UM, WHERE IF, IF WE'VE ESTABLISHED THE SHADOW PRICE CAP, WE KNOW WHAT, WHAT'S GONNA HAPPEN, WHAT, WHAT THE PRICES COULD GO TO.

I DO UNDERSTAND THAT IT, IT IS SHORT NOTICE, BUT IT, I FEEL LIKE IT'S SOMETHING THAT'S A LITTLE BIT MORE FIRM AND PREDICTABLE ONCE IT'S ESTABLISHED SMI.

UH, SO WE DO SUPPORT, UH, THE DIRECTION THIS IS GOING WHERE, UH, WE ARE TRYING TO SOLVE THE PROBLEM THROUGH SCARED.

ONE CONCERN I HAVE IS, UH, THE GRAY BOOKS THAT WAS ADDED, THAT'S A GOOD ADDITION, BUT IT SAYS IT'S EFFECTIVE FROM DECEMBER 1ST.

UM, SO THE CONCERN THAT I HAVE IS, UH, OR WE HAVE IS LIKE WE ESTABLISH A MAX SHADOW PRICE NOW, AND THEN, UH, IN THE MIDDLE OF THE SUMMER IT CHANGES.

SO CAN WE CHANGE IT TO SOMETHING LIKE, GIVE US 30 DAYS FROM AUGUST 1ST OR SOMETHING.

SO ONCE YOU ESTABLISH IT IN JUNE OR JULY, AND THEN, UM, MARKET HAS ENOUGH NOTICE IF SOMETHING NEEDS TO BE CHANGED.

AND NOTICE IS VERY IMPORTANT, AS EVERYONE HAS ALLUDED TO, UH, WITH THE NEED FOR HEDGING AND MARKETS UNITY.

THIS IS VERY, AGAIN, I THINK I, I'M, I'M AMENABLE TO THAT.

I THINK THAT WAS THE INTENT.

UM, BUT I DON'T HAVE ANY HEARTBURN WITH THAT, THAT CHANGE.

OKAY.

THANK YOU.

BOB HILTON? YEAH, I'M NOT SURE ABOUT PUSHING THIS OFF TOO FAR.

UH, FIRST OF ALL, DE-RATING THE SYSTEM DOESN'T WORK.

I MEAN, ALL THAT'S DOING IS WE'RE SUPPOSED TO BE USING THE TRANSMISSION SYSTEM TO THE EXTENT WE CAN AND, AND USING IT IN AN EFFICIENT MANNER.

I DON'T THINK DE-RATING IS DOING THAT.

I THINK THAT'S DOING THE OPPOSITE.

SO JUST WANTED TO BRING THAT OUT.

UH, THE SECOND PIECE IS I WOULD GO AHEAD AND MAKE A MOTION THAT WE TABLE THIS UNTIL WHEN IS OUR SECOND MEETING? YOU DON'T WANNA DO THAT.

I, I'M NOT SUPER OPEN TO THE JULY.

ARE YOU TALKING, WE, SO WE HAVE JUNE MEETINGS.

I WANNA GET IT TO THE NEXT BOARD MEETING.

SO WHAT I WAS LOOKING FOR, WE CAN MOVE IT TO THE NEXT ONE WE HAVE IF WOULD BE, WE HAVE A TECH MEETING, MAY 31ST, AND WE HAVE A TECH MEETING JUNE 7TH.

MM-HMM.

IF NEEDED.

AND IDEALLY WE WOULD NOT NEED THAT'S, I THOUGHT IT WAS ALREADY BE JUNE 7TH MEETING.

ALRIGHT, SO I'LL, I'D SAY LET'S TABLE IT TILL THE 31ST AND SEE WHAT WE WANT.

OKAY.

THAT IS NINE

[00:30:01]

DAYS FROM NOW.

YEAH.

SO DOES THAT GIVE SOMEBODY US TIME? GIVE YOU, THAT PUTS SOME MOVEMENT IN THERE, .

IT HELPS, BUT IT'S NOT A WHOLE LOT OF TIME.

THERE'S, OKAY.

NO, THAT'S THE ISSUE.

OKAY.

SO WE, WE HAVE THE MOTION AND TABLE ALREADY.

UM, BOB, ARE YOU WITH THAT? ARE YOU DONE WITH YOUR COMMENTS? YES.

OKAY.

UH, DAN WOODFIN.

SO AMAZINGLY WHAT BOB SAID WAS EXACTLY WHAT I WAS GONNA SAY, ALMOST ONE.

THIS IS A MORE EFFICIENT SOLUTION THAN, THAN OVERRIDES.

IT ALLOWS SCED TO DO, TO BRIAN'S POINT, WHILE IT, IT ALLOWS SCED TO DO WHAT SCDS DESIGNED TO DO AND DO IT EFFICIENTLY.

UM, IF WE CAN GO AHEAD AND TRY TO GET IT TO THE BOARD BY JUNE, THAT WOULD BE REALLY HELPFUL SO THAT WE CAN ACTUALLY HAVE IT IN PLACE FOR MOST OF THE SUMMER.

UM, AND USE, USE THE TOOLS FOR WHAT THEY'RE INTENDED TO DO.

DAN, COULD YOU WRITE THAT DOWN THAT WE AGREED YEAH.

FOR LATER TODAY.

.

OKAY.

SETH.

SETH, ARE YOU THERE? ERIC, DO YOU WANNA SPEAK WHILE WE FIND SETH? SURE.

UM, I THINK I WOULD, WOULD, UM, VOTE NO ON A GENERAL MOTION TO TABLE, BUT YES, ON A MOTION TO TABLE TO THE 31ST.

IF AT THE 31ST MEETING YOU'RE STILL NOT SATISFIED, AND THEN AT THE MEETING WITH ERCOT, UM, THEN WE CAN ALWAYS KEEP IT TABLED.

UH, WE WOULDN'T NEED A NEW MOTION TO KEEP IT TABLED, I THINK.

WOULD THAT RIGHT? I SEE COREY SHAKING HIS HEAD THAT WHAT YOU JUST SAID IS WHY WE DON'T PUT AN EXPIRATION DATE ON THE MOTION TO TABLE.

SO BY SAYING YOU'RE OKAY WITH TABLING IT TODAY.

YEAH.

BUT BECAUSE YOU'RE ON THE MAY 31ST MEETING, YOU WANT MAKE SURE THAT 1230 AGENDA IS AT LEAST LISTED ON THE AGENDA FOR A VOTE.

I THINK THAT'S SOMETHING THAT CAN WE DO THAT VERBALLY? TACK LEADERSHIP CAN AGREE TO SAY AS MUCH AS YOU MIGHT BE TRYING TO SLIM DOWN THE MOTION, THE AGENDA FOR 5 31 TO ONLY FOCUS ON NORE 2 45 THINGS LIKE THIS, THAT IF WE WANTED TO SLIDE THOSE ON AS LONG AS THEY'RE LISTED ON THE AGENDA, THEN EXACTLY WHAT YOU JUST SAID, ERIC, IF SOMEBODY WANTS TO MAKE A MOTION, THEY CAN, IF THEY WANNA LEAVE A TABLED, THEY CAN, BUT IT WOULD AT LEAST BE PROPERLY NOTICED FOR A VOTE ON MAY 31ST.

OKAY.

WE'RE, WE'RE FINE WITH HAVING THAT ON THE MAY 31ST AGENDA.

OKAY.

THANK YOU.

BUT WE'RE NOT, I'M NOT COMMITTING TO THE JUNE 7TH AGENDA.

SOUNDS GOOD.

I APPRECIATE THAT.

OKAY.

WE FOUND SETH.

SETH, DO YOU WANNA SPEAK YOUR QUESTION, PHONE ISSUE? DO WE KNOW THE SPC VALUES UNDER THIS NPRR FOR EACH ROL FREDDY? DO YOU HAVE AN ANSWER FOR THAT? OR, OR SORRY, WHAT WAS THAT MISSED THAT IT'S IN, IT'S IN THE CHAT.

I DON'T THINK YOU CAN SEE IT CAN'T.

OH, SORRY.

DO WE, DO WE KNOW THE SPC VALUES UNDER THIS NPRR FOR EACH IROL? SO, SO, UM, I DID FILE SOME COMMENTS JUST TO CLARIFY, BASED ON SOME FEEDBACK FROM PRS THAT THE SHADOW PRICE CAP INCREASE WOULD ONLY APPLY TO IOLS IF NEEDED AS NEEDED.

SO IT WOULDN'T BE FOR ALL IOLS, IT WOULD JUST BE ON A AS NEEDED BASIS.

UM, THE CALCULATED, UH, SHADOW PRICE THAT WE'RE ANTICIPATING IS IN 19,721, I THINK IS, IS WHAT WE'VE CALCULATED.

UM, BUT THAT, THAT'S WHAT WE'RE ANTICIPATING.

OKAY.

IT, THAT WOULD BE ONLY FOR THE SOUTH TEXAS EXPORT IOLS.

OKAY.

AND THE REMAINING IOLS WOULD, WOULD CONTINUE TO USE THE CURRENT, UM, UH, GENERIC TRANSMISSION, UH, PRICE CAP FOR BASE CASE CONSTRAINTS.

ALRIGHT.

DAVID KEY? YEAH, I THINK YOU, YOU JUST SAID THAT THIS IS ONLY GONNA BE FOR THE SOUTH TEXAS GTCS, BUT YOU COULD CHANGE THAT.

OR DID I MISUNDERSTAND THAT? YES, THIS LANGUAGE WOULD, WOULD GIVE US THE ABILITY TO EVALUATE IT IF WE NEED TO.

AND IT'S, THERE'S A PERIODIC EVALUATION ON AN ANNUAL BASIS AS WELL.

ON AN ANNUAL BASIS.

AND THEN HOW MUCH NOTICE WILL WE GET ONCE YOU'VE MADE THE DECISION TO CHANGE? NO, THAT LANGUAGE RIGHT THERE, WHAT RES WAS REFERRING TO EARLIER WAS A 30 DAY NOTICE PRIOR

[00:35:01]

TO BECOMING EFFECTIVE.

RIGHT.

OKAY.

THANKS.

SO YOU WILL CHANGE IT, RIGHT? UH, CAN I ASK A QUESTION? SURE, GO AHEAD.

SMI.

SO YOU WILL CHANGE IT FROM DECEMBER TO AUGUST OR ON EFFECTIVE OR WHICHEVER, WHAT WILL YOU CHANGE IT TO? I MEAN, I, I'M OKAY WITH THAT.

IF WE WANT TO DO SOME DESKTOP EDITS TO THESE COMMENTS.

I'M, I'M UNCOMFORTABLE.

WELL, WE HAVE A MOTION TO TABLE.

YEAH, WE'RE JUST TABLING IT SO IT WON'T MATTER.

WE JUST REMIND FREDDY WE ADDED THIS IN BECAUSE ON THE TIMELINE IT'S ON RIGHT NOW, IF THE BOARD APPROVES IT IN JUNE, IT WOULD GO TO THE PUC IN JULY.

THE LANGUAGE WOULD TAKE EFFECT AUGUST 1ST.

AND WE HAD SAID, WELL, IF IT TAKES EFFECT AUGUST 1ST, I CAN'T REALLY GIVE YOU 30 DAYS NOTICE TO DO SOMETHING THIS SUMMER, BECAUSE I'M ALREADY ON AUGUST 1ST.

SO WE WANTED TO SAY THE 30 DAY COUNTDOWN WOULD START SOMETIME AFTER THIS SUMMER TO M'S POINT.

IF WE JUST STARTED IMMEDIATELY ON AUGUST 1ST, WE'RE JUST SAYING WE DON'T NEED THIS GRAY BOX.

WE CAN JUST SAY YOU'LL ALWAYS GET 30 DAYS AND WE DON'T NEED ANY, WE DON'T NEED ANY SHORT-TERM RELIEF THIS SUMMER ON A TIGHTER TIMELINE THAT WE WOULD BE FINE WITH 30 DAYS WHENEVER.

SO WE CAN ULTIMATELY DO DESKTOP EDITS OR COMMENTS.

BUT FOR RIGHT NOW, CAITLIN'S RIGHT, THE MOTION IS JUST A TABLE, SO WE DON'T HAVE TO EDIT ANYTHING TODAY.

SO JUST TO CLARIFY, ONCE THIS LANGUAGE IS EFFECTIVE, WE ARE ABLE TO UPDATE THAT SHADOW PRICE CAP, AND THEN ANYTHING AFTER THAT WOULD REQUIRE 30 DAY NOTICE IF, AS IT'S DRAFTED RIGHT NOW.

OKAY.

RE'S POINT IS, IF WE PULL THIS BACK FROM DECEMBER TO BE AUGUST 1ST, THEN THAT MEANS IMMEDIATELY ON AUGUST 1ST.

THIS IS THE LANGUAGE THAT YOU'RE BOUND BY AND NOT THIS LANGUAGE ABOVE.

NO, NO, NO.

YEAH.

AND THAT'S NOT, NO, NO, NO, NO.

UH, I THINK THERE IS A POTENT, SORRY, CAITLIN, CAN I SAY, UH, I THINK THERE IS A POTENTIAL THAT PUCT WILL, UM, WAIVE THE NOTICE.

SO IT CAN GO EFFECTIVE JUNE OR JULY 1ST OR SOMETHING.

JULY 1ST.

AND SO I'M NOT SAYING YOU CAN'T CHANGE ANYTHING IMMEDIATELY.

I'M SAYING ONCE YOU CHANGE SOMETHING, DON'T CHANGE IT THE NEXT DAY OR LIKE IN A WEEK.

YEAH.

SO, SO JUST TO BE SAFE COULD SEPTEMBER 1ST.

OKAY.

UH, THEN THE SUMMER WILL BE OVER, SO YEAH.

YEAH.

SO MAYBE SOMETHING LIKE 30 DAYS AFTER THE FIRST THING.

AUGUST 2ND.

YEAH, YEAH.

SOMETHING LIKE THAT.

YEAH.

OKAY.

DAVID KEY.

YEAH, I THINK YOU'VE, I THINK RAISED ME, RAISED THE POINT THAT I WAS GONNA MAKE AND I WAS GONNA BE, UH, BASICALLY SAYING WE THINK IT'S, WE THINK IT'S AUGUST, BUT THERE COULD BE A POTENTIAL THAT THE COMMISSION COULD WANT THIS IN SOONER.

UM, SO I'M SYMPATHETIC TO THAT.

I I, I DO RECOGNIZE THE VALUE HERE, BUT I ALSO DO, UM, STILL HAVE ISSUES WITH THE, THE VERY DRASTIC CHANGE.

SO, UH, JUST BE, UM, YEAH, THE CHALLENGE STILL IS, UH, I DON'T WANNA SAY POOR PLANNING, BUT, YOU KNOW, THE LACK, THE LACK OF ABILITY TO BRING THIS IN SOONER, HAVE IT TALK THROUGH AND SAY, THIS IS A CHANGE WE'RE GONNA BE DOING.

UM, THAT THAT'S REALLY OUR ISSUE.

I THINK THE OTHER THING THAT I WANTED TO MA MAKE A, A FRIENDLY REQUEST, AND WE CAN TALK ABOUT THIS OFFLINE, BUT, UM, IN, IN ADDITION TO NOTICE, UH, THE STAKEHOLDER PROCESS IS PRETTY VALUABLE FOR ASKING QUESTIONS AND GAINING, UM, GAINING SUPPORT BEFORE WE MAKE CHANGES.

SO AS, AS PART OF THE 30 DAYS NOTICE IN THE FUTURE, MAYBE WE COULD ASK THAT, UH, THIS BE TAKEN TO, UH, A WORKING GROUP OR SUBCOMMITTEE JUST FOR REVIEW.

LIKE, HERE'S WHAT WE'RE GONNA DO AND THEN THE CHANGES THAT ARE COMING UP, GIVE, GIVE, GIVE US SOME, SOME WAY TO UNDERSTAND IT AND KINDA GIVE US A LITTLE, LITTLE HEADS UP AS THE MARKET AS A WHOLE.

I DON'T NEED IT PERSONALLY, JUST, YOU KNOW, EVERYBODY NEEDS TO HAVE THAT VISIBILITY.

SO JUST A GENERAL PRACTICE TO GO AHEAD AND, AND REVIEW THE CHANGE WITH CMWG OR SOME GROUP TO, TO GIVE EVERYONE A HEAD A HEADS UP THAT RIGHT.

MORE NOTICE, THE BETTER.

THIS IS WHAT WE'RE THINKING.

OUR, OUR ISSUE IS, IS THE, IS THE HEDGING AROUND AND BEING PREPARED AND UNDERSTANDING THESE CHANGES.

AND THEN THE MORE NOTICE WE HAVE, THE BETTER FOR EVERYBODY.

I MEAN, SURE.

OKAY.

NED, I WAS GONNA SAY PRETTY MUCH THE, THE SAME THING THAT, THAT REMI AND DAVID BROUGHT UP, WHICH IS IF THE, I DON'T WANNA PRESUME WHAT THE COMMISSION WILL DO, BUT IF THEY DO WAIVE THE 30 DAYS, THEN THEY COULD COME UP SOONER.

SO INSTEAD OF ANCHORING TO A HARD DATE, IT MIGHT BE BETTER TO, TO ANCHOR TO PUC APPROVAL.

UM, BUT I, I AGREE, IT'S, UH, IT'S A FINE BALANCE TO STRIKE.

THIS IS, I MEAN, IT'S A, IT'S A TOOL TO ENHANCE RELIABLE OPERATIONS.

IT'S A, IT'S A KNOWN ISSUE THAT WE RAN INTO LAST YEAR, SO, UM, AND WE CLEARLY ANTICIPATE THAT THAT'S GONNA CONTINUE INTO THIS YEAR.

SO IT'S A GOOD TOOL TO HAVE, UM, THEN STRIKING A, A DECENT BALANCE IS WHAT WE HAVE TO DO.

OKAY.

THANK YOU.

SETH.

IS YOUR PHONE WORKING NOW? YEAH, I THINK SO.

UM, SO I JUST HAVE A QUICK, ANOTHER QUICK QUESTION.

UM, IS THERE KIND GONNA FOLLOW THIS METHODOLOGY STRICTLY, OR IS IT STILL LIKE UP TO DISCRETION? SO IF YOU FIND THAT, UM, YOU COULD, IN FACT UNDER THIS CALCULUS THAT YOU HAVE HERE, RAISE THE SHADOW PRICE CAP, DOES THAT MEAN THAT YOU'LL DEFINITELY

[00:40:01]

DO IT? OR IS THERE DISCRETION IN ITS APPLICATION ITSELF? YEAH, I, I MEAN, I GUESS THE, THE LANGUAGE IS PRETTY CLEAR IN THE NPRR, THIS IS THE METHOD THAT WE WILL USE.

I, I DON'T KNOW IF THERE'S MUCH ROOM FOR, FOR VARIANCE THERE.

IT'S PRETTY STRICT IN THE PARAGRAPH THERE.

DAVE, DID YOU WANNA ADD? OKAY, SO IN OTHER WORDS, OH, SORRY, GO AHEAD SETH.

I WAS GONNA SAY, SO IN OTHER WORDS, WHEN YOU SEE A CONSTRAINT, AN IRL THAT UM, WOULD BE VIOLATED, BUT FOR BEING ABLE TO RAISE A SHADOW PRICE CAP, UM, YOU'RE GOING TO GO AHEAD AND DO THAT.

I THINK WE WOULD EVALUATE IT AND SEE IF, IF IT PROVIDES ANY BENEFIT TO DO SO.

UM, AND IF IT DOES, UH, GIVE SKID ADDITIONAL LEVERAGE TO MANAGE THE CONSTRAINT, I THINK WE WOULD.

OKAY.

IS THERE ANY CAP TO THIS? SO IN THEORY, IF YOU HAVE THE LOWEST LEVERAGE, UH, SHIFT FACTOR AND YOU HAVE, UH, IN YOUR, THAT THEIR OFFERING AT THE CAP, UM, YOU COULD HAVE A, WHAT, A $50,000 SHADOW PRICE CAP.

IS THERE ANY, IS THERE ANY HARD CAP ON THIS? SO THAT, THAT'S WHAT WE WERE TRYING TO DO BY REFERENCING THE FREQUENCY BIAS IS WE'RE NOT GONNA GO ALL THE WAY TO A 1% SHIFT FACTOR.

THAT WOULD BE A, A HUGE, UH, SHADOW PRICE CAP.

BUT WE'RE, WE'RE TRYING TO DRAW A LINE IN THE SAND.

THIS IS, IS THIS IS HOW MANY MEGAWATTS CORRESPONDING TO SHIFT FACTOR WE'RE WILLING TO CONSIDER FOR THAT CALCULATION.

AND IT'S ROUGHLY 900 MEGAWATTS.

SO THAT THAT, THAT GIVES SOMEWHAT OF A, A, A LIMIT.

OKAY.

I, I'LL HAVE TO THINK ABOUT THAT.

UM, SURE.

BUT I THANK YOU FOR THE RESPONSE.

AND CAITLIN, I GUESS IF I CAN JUST ADD TO THAT, EVERYTHING FREDDY SAID WAS CORRECT.

I THINK IT'S KIND OF THE, WE DO THIS SIMILAR FOR THE IRRESOLVABLE IN SCED CONCEPT.

OBVIOUSLY THAT'S THE, THE LOWERING OF SHADOW PRICE CAP, BUT THERE'S WHAT PUTS SOME GUARDRAILS AROUND THAT IS SOME SHIFT FACTOR CUTOFFS THAT, THAT DRIVE THAT.

I GUESS THE ONE THING I WANTED TO MAKE CLEAR, I THINK IT'S RELATED TO ETH QUESTION, IS AROUND JUST FUNCTIONALLY, ONCE WE CHANGE THE SHADOW PRICE CAP IN THE SYSTEM, THAT'S THE VALUE WE'RE USING.

SO THERE'S NOTHING IN THE SYSTEM THAT WOULD ALLOW IT TO SWITCH BACK AND FORTH ON, YOU KNOW, DEPENDING ON HOW WELL IT'S RESOLVING.

SO HOPEFULLY THAT'S, UH, HELPFUL AS WELL IS JUST UNDERSTANDING THE FUNCTIONALITY.

SO IT WOULD REMAIN AT THAT NUMBER AND, AND SCED WOULD USE IT UNTIL THERE WAS THE, THE NOTICE TO CHANGE IT WITH THE, THE 30 DAYS THAT, THAT WE'VE BEEN TALKING ABOUT.

OKAY.

THANK YOU.

SMI.

UM, SO IF I UNDERSTAND CORRECTLY, THERE IS IN THIS CALCULATION A SHIFT FACTOR CUTOFF, RIGHT? AND THAT'S 0.01.

SO, UH, IT MAY BE EASIER.

THERE, THERE IS A PRESENTATION POSTED TO THE VR SITE AND THAT GOES THROUGH THAT PROCESS.

YEAH, BUT THAT ONE IS BASED ON A MEGAWATT AND THERE WAS NO SHIFT FACTOR CUTOFF AT THAT.

IT, IT'S THE, AT THAT, THE, SOME OF THE HSLS FOR ALL THE UNITS FOR THE TOP SHIFT FACTORS, THE UNIT THAT WHERE YOU SUM UP TO 900 MEGAWATTS, WHAT'S THE CORRESPONDING SHIFT FACTOR? AND THAT'S YOUR SHIFT FACTOR CUTOFF.

YEAH.

SO THAT IS NOT A SHIFT FACTOR CUTOFF, RIGHT? THAT IS JUST A, WHATEVER IT COMES UP TO.

WHAT I'M SAYING IS MAYBE TO MAKE IT EASIER FOR EVERYONE AND TO, UM, ENSURE THAT THE PRICES DON'T GO LIKE HUMONGOUS HAYWIRE, MAYBE WE SHOULD PUT A SHIP FACTOR CUT OFF IN THIS CALCULATION.

I KNOW THERE IS NO SHIP FACTOR CUTOFF IN INSTEAD, BUT WHATEVER IS THE SHIP FACTOR CUTOFF, MAYBE 0.01 OR WHATEVER, SOMETHING YEAH.

THAT'S SOMETHING THAT WE CAN, WE CAN CONSIDER.

YEAH.

OTHERWISE THE CALCULATION CAN GO REALLY, REALLY HIGH.

VERY SETH.

YEAH.

DOES THIS WHOLE THING OVERRIDE THE IRRESOLVABLE THRESHOLD? SO IF YOU SEE A SHOWER PRICE CAP GET UP THERE, YOU KNOW, LIKE THIS 20 K VALUE, YOU COULD VERY EASILY ACCRUE SOME CONGESTION RENTS THAT WILL HIT THAT IRRESOLVABLE THRESHOLD FAIRLY FAST.

SO DOES THIS STILL, IS THIS STILL BEHOLDEN TO THAT? THIS IS DAVE.

I I CAN TAKE THAT ONE.

THE, I CAN GO BACK AND LOOK AT THE LANGUAGE.

I DO NOT THINK, UH, IN THE LANGUAGE TODAY, THERE'S ANYTHING

[00:45:01]

EXPLICITLY THAT WOULD SAY THAT THE IRRESOLVABLE SCED PROCESS DOES NOT APPLY.

SO, SO PERHAPS THAT'S SOMETHING AGAIN, WE CAN COME BACK AND IF THIS DOESN'T MOVE FORWARD TODAY, WE CAN, WE CAN TALK ABOUT THAT AT THE, THE NEXT TECH MEETING.

OKAY.

I'M NOT TAKING A POSITION ON THAT NECESSARILY.

I'M JUST, I'M JUST TRYING TO FIGURE IT OUT.

UM, BUT I THINK THAT THAT SHOULD BE CLARIFIED.

YEAH, FAIR ENOUGH.

AND I GUESS JUST FOR, FOR FOR CLARITY, THERE'S HOW THAT WORKS.

THERE'S A FIRST CRITERIA THAT'S SIMPLY A FUNCTION OF THE AMOUNT OF TIME IN RECENT HISTORY THAT THE CONSTRAINT HAS BEEN AT THE SHADOW PRICE CAP.

THAT'S SORT OF THE FIRST LAYER IN WHICH THERE'S A, A POTENTIAL LOWERING OF THE SHADOW PRICE CAP.

BUT, BUT EVEN UNDER THAT FIRST CRITERIA, THE NEW VALUE CAN BE ANYWHERE BETWEEN THE CURRENT CAP AND $2,000 PER MEGAWATT HOUR.

THERE IS THEN A SECOND TRIGGER RELATED TO A, A NET MARGIN CALCULATION THAT DOES LOOK AT AN ACCRUAL OF CONGESTION RENT.

AND, AND THAT'S A, A SECOND LOWERING.

AND, AND IT SOUNDS LIKE, UH, IN PARTICULAR, THAT MAY BE THE MORE CONCERNING ONE, SETH.

WELL, WELL, YOU, I MEAN, YOU'RE RIGHT.

IF, IF YOU'RE RAISING THESE SOUTH PRICE CAPS, IT MAY NEVER BE IRRESOLVABLE BECAUSE THAT'S THE WHOLE POINT.

UM, SO MAYBE IT NEVER EVEN GETS IN THROUGH THE GATE.

UM, BUT YEAH, THAT, THAT'S JUST THE THINGS I'M THINKING ABOUT IT.

IF, IF THESE, THESE I LS WOULD STILL BE SUBJECT TO THE, THAT WHOLE METHODOLOGY.

YEP.

YEAH.

I MEAN, IT CERTAINLY FEELS LIKE IT COULD DEFEAT THE POINT RIGHT.

OF WHAT WE'RE TALKING ABOUT HERE.

OKAY.

ALL RIGHT.

ANY FURTHER DISCUSSION ON 1230? SO DO WE NEED A SEPARATE BALLOT FOR THIS ONE? OKAY, GO AHEAD, COREY.

ALL RIGHT.

I'M JUST DOUBLE CHECKING WITH SUSIE.

WE, WE GOT OUR MOVER AND SECONDER RECORDED FROM THE START OF ALL THIS.

I THINK WE DID, BUT DAVID AND ALICIA? YEP.

OKAY.

ON THE MOTION TO TABLE NPR 1230, WE WILL START OFF WITH CONSUMERS.

WITH ERIC.

YES.

THANK YOU.

NARAJ? YES.

THANK YOU, GARRETT.

YES, SIR.

THANK YOU, ERIC.

YES, THANK YOU, UH, RICK FOR MARK? YES.

THANK YOU RICK FOR NICK.

YES.

THANK YOU.

ONTO OUR CO-OPS.

MIKE? YES.

THANK YOU, BLAKE.

YES.

THANK YOU, ERIC.

YES, THANK YOU.

THANK YOU LUCAS FOR JOHN? YES, THANK YOU.

THANK YOU.

ONTO OUR INDEPENDENT GENERATORS.

BRIAN? YES, OFFICIALLY.

THANK YOU.

UM, MS. AND CAITLIN.

BOB HILTON? YES, SIR.

SIR NED ABSTAIN.

OOPS.

THANK YOU FOR JUSTIFYING THE SEPARATE BALLOT ONTO THE IPMS RASHMI, UH, I HAVE A QUESTION.

SO, IS IT JUST A PLAIN TABLE OR PLAIN TABLE, OR TABLE UNTIL THE NEXT STACK MEETING? EVERY TABLE IS A TABLE UNTIL THE NEXT TAC MEETING.

SO YES, THIS IS JUST A TABLE IT.

AND THEN NOW EVERY TAC MEETING FROM HERE ON OUT HAS THE OPTION OF LISTING THIS ON THE AGENDA FOR A VOTE, IN WHICH CASE IT CAN BE TAKEN UP AT.

AND WE, THAT TIME WE GOT CONFIRMATION FROM THE CHAIR AND VICE CHAIR THAT IT'LL BE ON THE 31ST MEETING, WHICH IS WHY I VOTED YES.

THE TABLE.

OKAY.

OKAY.

YES.

OKAY.

JEREMY? YES.

THANK YOU.

THANK YOU.

IAN? YES.

THANK YOU, KEVIN.

YES, THANK YOU.

OKAY.

ONTO THE I REPS BILL? YES.

THANK YOU, JENNIFER.

WE GOT JENNIFER.

HOW ABOUT JAY? YES, THANK YOU, CHRIS.

YES, THANK YOU.

ONTO THE IOUS.

STACY FOR KEITH? YES.

THANK YOU, DAVID.

YES, THANK YOU, COLIN.

YES, THANK YOU, RICHARD.

YES, THANK YOU.

AND OUR MUNIS, RUSSELL.

YES.

THANK YOU, JOSE.

YES.

THANK YOU, DAVID.

YES.

THANK YOU, ALICIA.

YES, THANK YOU.

MOTION CARRIES ONE ABSTENTION.

THANK YOU CO.

DIANA, WE'RE GONNA MOVE BACK TO THE PRS REPORT AND MOVE ON TO 1224.

OKAY.

OKAY.

ONE MORE.

UH, 1224 COMES TO US FROM ERCOT.

THIS IS INTRODUCING A TRIGGER THAT ERCOT CAN USE TO MANUALLY RELEASE ECRS FROM SC.

ALSO REQUIRES AN ENERGY OFFER CURVE FOR THE CAPACITY ASSIGNED TO ECRS AT NO LESS THAN A THOUSAND DOLLARS PER MEGAWATT HOUR ON APRIL 5TH, PRS VOTED TO GRANT, UH, 1224 URGENT STATUS.

THERE WERE TWO OPPOSING VOTES ON THAT VOTE.

UM, ON,

[00:50:01]

LET'S SEE, WE THEN VOTED TO TABLE IT, AND THERE WERE THREE ABSTENTIONS ON THAT TABLE.

AND THEN EARLIER IN THIS MONTH, ON MAY 9TH, WE VOTED TO RECOMMEND APPROVAL OF 1224 AS AMENDED BY THE APRIL 30TH TCPA COMMENTS AS REVISED BY ERCOT.

THERE WERE FIVE OPPOSING VOTES AND SIX ABSTENTIONS ON THAT VOTE.

THANKS, DIANA.

NED IS FIRST IN THE QUEUE.

THANK YOU, CAITLIN.

UM, I FIGURED I'D PROBABLY DO A STRAW POLL AND SEE IF WE CAN, UH, PUT THIS ON THE COMBO BELT WITH THE PRS COMMENTS.

LAUGHTER IS A, IS AGREEMENT.

NO, UM, I, YOU KNOW, I I, I'M HAPPY TO WALK THROUGH SOME OF THE JOINT COMMENTERS COMMENTS, UM, ON BEHALF OF TCPA AND OTHERS, IF THAT'S, IF THAT'S HELPFUL.

UM, YOU KNOW, I THINK, I THINK WITH THIS, WE'VE REALLY GOT, UM, YOU KNOW, CASE OF, YOU KNOW, REASONABLE MINDS WILL DIFFER.

AND WE, IT'S A TOUGH PROBLEM WHERE WE'RE TRYING TO BRIDGE TWO WORLDS.

UM, WE'RE TRYING, YOU KNOW, WE WE'RE, WE'RE LOOKING AT A, A PRODUCT THAT WAS ORIGINALLY INTENDED TO GO LIVE WITH REALTIME CO OPTIMIZATION, ENDED UP GOING LIVE AHEAD OF REALTIME CO OPTIMIZATION.

UM, YOU'VE GOT A LOT OF FOLKS THAT ARE, UH, I THINK THINKING ABOUT, UH, YOU KNOW, THE EXTREME HEAT AND, UH, SCARCITY THAT WE HAD LAST SUMMER AND, AND, YOU KNOW, REACTING TO THAT.

UM, WHEREAS I THINK THE JOINT COMMENTERS LOOKED AT THIS AND SAID, WELL, WE, WELL, WE MAY NOT, UH, WE MAY NOT AGREE THAT ECRS, YOU KNOW, THE WAY THAT IT'S CURRENTLY OPERATED IS, IS A PROBLEM.

WE RECOGNIZE THAT THERE IS A CONCERN.

AND, AND SO AS A, UH, YOU KNOW, A, A STEP TOWARDS COMPROMISE THOUGHT, WELL, LET'S TRY TO ALIGN WHATEVER IS IN NPR 1224 TO WHAT WE SEE IN THE, UH, IN THE REALTIME CO REALTIME CO OPTIMIZATION ANCILLARY SERVICE DEMAND CURVES.

AND SO THAT WAS, THAT WAS REALLY THE, THE APPROACH WAS, YOU KNOW, LOOK AT WHAT'S OUT THERE AND SEE, YOU KNOW, THE, THE, THE BASELINE EFFECT IN NPR 1224 IS OUR COP PROPOSES TO RELEASE, UH, 500 MEGAWATTS OF ECRS, UH, BASED ON THE, UH, SOME, SOME PRICE QUANTITY PAIRS ON THE POWER BALANCE PENALTY CURVE.

AND SO WHEN WE LOOKED AT WHERE THAT SITS, UM, YOU KNOW, ON THE VARIOUS ANCILLARY SERVICE DEMAND CURVES, 'CAUSE REMEMBER IN REAL TIME CO-OP OPTIMIZATION, THE VALUE CHANGES, DEPENDING ON WHAT THE ANCILLARY SERVICE PLAN IS FOR THAT DAY, IT HAS TO FIT INTO THE, THAT BROADER ORDC SHAPE.

SO SOME DAYS IT'S GOING TO HAVE A, A, YOU KNOW, A LOWER STARTING POINT AND A PRETTY WIDE RANGE.

SOME DAYS IT'S A MORE NARROW RANGE.

SOME DAYS IT'S GONNA START UP AT THE CAP AND, AND COME DOWN INTO THE MIDDLE POINT.

SO, UM, IF, IF YOU CAN SCROLL DOWN A LITTLE BIT, UM, YOU KNOW, THIS WAS A, ALMOST A CRAYON EXERCISE, BUT IT WAS HELP HELPING TO, TO ILLUSTRATE THE POINT IS THAT IN THE YELLOW LINE, WHEN, YOU KNOW, YOU SEE AN APPROXIMATION OF ABOUT 500 MEGAWATTS SHORT, UH, ACROSS THE BLUE AREA, WHICH IS THE ECRS ANCILLARY SERVICE DEMAND CURVE.

AND THEN WE JUST DREW THAT UP TO THE TOP POINT AND SAID, WHERE DOES THAT, WHERE DOES THAT SIT ON THE, UH, ON THE Y AXIS WITH PRICE? AND IT'S, IT'S ACROSS VARIOUS, UH, VARIOUS PRICE POINTS.

UM, IN SOME INSTANCES, UH, FIRST TO ADMIT IT IS BELOW THE, UH, THE PRS REPORTS RECOMMENDED $1,000, UH, LEVEL, BUT IN, IN MOST INSTANCES, IT'S ACTUALLY AT OR ABOVE THAT LEVEL.

AND SO, UH, CONSIDERING THAT NPRR 1224 PROPOSES TO ALSO ALLOW ERCOT TO RELEASE ADDITIONAL ECRS CAPACITY, WE THOUGHT, YOU KNOW, THAT SEEMS LIKE IT'S A, A FAIRLY CONSERVATIVE ASSUMPTION AND IS CONSISTENT WITH WHERE THE, UH, WHERE THE MARKET'S MOVING TOWARDS IN, UH, 2026 WHEN REALTIME CO OPTIMIZATION GOES LIVE.

UM, AND THEN JUST FOR COMPARISON, UH, YOU KNOW, WE INCLUDED IN, IN THE GREEN DASH LINE IS WHERE THE PRS REPORT, UH, WOULD BE AT THE, UM, 40 MEGAWATTS OF, UM, OF, UM, UNDER GENERATION ON THE POWER BALANCE PENALTY CURVE, ROUGHLY, UH, APPROXIMATES THE THOUSAND DOLLARS PRICE POINT.

AND THEN WE COMPARE THAT TO WHAT WE'RE IN THE, UM, THE IMS, UH, MAY 15TH COMMENTS, WHICH WAS AT THE, UH, FIVE MEGAWATT, UH, POINT ON THE POWER BALANCE PENALTY CURVE.

SO THAT WAS ABOUT 250.

AND THE SECOND PRINCIPLE TO HIGHLIGHT HERE IS THAT IN REAL TIME CO OPTIMIZATION, WHEN WE DO GO SHORT ON AN ANCILLARY SERVICE, WHEN THAT IS RELEASED FOR ENERGY, THAT DOES CREATE THE NEW PRICE FLOW.

THAT IS THE OPPORTUNITY COST TO THE MARKET OF HAVING THOSE RESERVES, UH, AND THE RELIABILITY VALUE THAT COMES WITH THEM.

AND SO THAT, THAT'S THE SECOND PRINCIPLE THAT'S EMBEDDED IN HERE, IS THAT ONCE WE HAVE RELEASED IT, THAT THAT BECOMES THE, THE, THE BASELINE FOR, UH, FOR MARKET PRICING HELPS TO REFLECT THAT SCARCITY.

SO, UM, YOU KNOW, I

[00:55:01]

THINK MAYBE THE, THE CHOICE SET THERE FOR T TO CONSIDER IS, UM, YOU KNOW, IS NPR 1224 MEANT TO, UM, HA RESULT IN PRICE REVERSAL WHEN ERCOT IS RELEASING ECRS? OR IS IT MEANT TO BE A PRICE ARREST, UH, FUNCTION WHERE, YOU KNOW, IT'S, IT'S KIND OF A MIDDLE GROUND BETWEEN WHERE, UH, WHERE FOLKS HAVE, UH, SEEN, UH, SEEN THE IMPACTS OF ERCOT RESERVING THAT CAPACITY, UM, VERSUS WHERE WE WOULD REASONABLY EXPECT IT TO BE IN, UH, THE REALTIME CO-OP OPTIMIZATION WORLD.

SO, UM, THAT'S JUST A GENERAL LAYOUT.

UM, HAPPY TO TAKE QUESTIONS, BUT I ALSO DO WANT TO JUST UNDERSTANDING THAT THERE'S A LOT OF DIFFERENT, UH, THERE'S PROBABLY DIFFERENT OPINIONS ON THIS, BUT GIVEN THAT PRS DID GIVE US A REPORT, I DO WANT TO LAY OUT A MOTION FOR TAC TO ENDORSE THE PRS REPORT AND, UM, AND START FROM THERE.

AND I'M SURE WE'LL HAVE LOTS OF DISCUSSION.

AND, UM, SO THAT'S A MOTION.

THAT IS A MOTION.

IS THERE A SECOND FOR THAT MOTION TO ENDORSE THE PRS REPORT? BLAKE? OKAY.

SO WE'LL GO BACK TO THE QUEUE.

RICK, I'M GOING TO GO AHEAD AND MAKE A SUBSTITUTE MOTION IF I CAN, TO ENDORSE THE IMM COMMENTS FILED ON MAY 15TH AND MAY 17TH.

OKAY.

WELL, I THINK WE, WE'D HAVE TO MAKE A MOTION TO AMEND THAT MOTION, THE FIRST MOTION ON THE TABLE.

IS THAT CORRECT, COREY? CORRECT.

SO WE HAVE A MOTION TO ENDORSE THE PRS REPORT, AND THEN A MOTION TO AMEND THE PRS REPORT VERSION TO THE VERSION WITH THE IMM COMMENTS.

YES.

IS THERE A SECOND FOR RICK'S MOTION? OKAY, THERE'S A SECOND FROM ERIC.

SHOULD WE VOTE ON THIS MOTION TO AMEND THE MOTION BEFORE GETTING TO THE REST OF THE QUEUE? I THINK YOU SHOULD.

OKAY.

ANN THINKS WE SHOULD, BUT OH, SAID, TAKE DISCUSSION FIRST.

OKAY.

CAN WE GET THE IMMS THOUGHTS? WE CAN GET THE IMMS THOUGHTS? YES.

THIS IS, UH, JEFF MCDONALD WITH POTOMAC ECONOMICS, UH, AND IMM FOR THE ERCOT MARKET.

UM, AND I HAVE WITH ME ANDREW RUMORS, SO, UH, YOU WANT OUR THOUGHTS? I, I'D BE HAPPY TO, UM, CERTAINLY WOULD BE HAPPY TO FIELD QUESTIONS.

UM, I CAN SUMMARIZE WHAT WE PUT IN OUR COMMENTS, IF THAT'S HELPFUL, IF THAT'S A HELPFUL LAUNCHING POINT.

UM, SO REGARDING THE PROCUREMENT TRIGGER, UM, OUR POSITION IS ANY KI OR NOT PROCUREMENT TRIGGER, I'M SORRY, THE DEPLOYMENT TRIGGER.

UM, ANY DEPLOYMENT TRIGGER IS A MOVE IN THE RIGHT DIRECTION FROM NO DEPLOYMENT TRIGGER.

SO, AND EVERYONE HERE IS FAMILIAR WITH THE ANALYSIS THAT WAS, YOU KNOW, PUT OUT BY OUR GROUP, UH, LAST YEAR ON A COUPLE DIFFERENT POINTS, SO I WON'T REHASH THAT.

BUT, BUT IN OUR VIEW, UM, AND REFLECTING ON THAT ANALYSIS, WHEN WE LOOK AT THE, UH, RELIABILITY VALUE THAT, THAT ANALYSIS, UM, CALCULATED FOR THE ECRS PROCUREMENT, YOU KNOW, WE LOOKED, WE, WE SAW AVERAGE RELIABILITY VALUES OF ABOUT $16, UH, PER MEGAWATT, AND, UH, A MARGINAL RELIABILITY VALUE WHEN CONSIDERING THE ENTIRE POOL OF ECRS PROCURED AT ANY TIME OF $0.

SO THERE WAS NO MORE RELIABILITY BENEFIT TO HAVING ONE MORE, UH, MEGAWATT OF ECRS.

SO, SO DRAWING ON THAT, AND THAT'S A FUNDAMENTAL PRINCIPLE, I THINK, UH, IN SHAPING OUR POSITION IN GENERAL, IS THAT WE FELT THAT ECRS WAS OVER PROCURED BASED ON RELIABILITY VALUE AND THEREFORE, UH, SE SEQUESTERING THAT ECRS OR A LARGE PORTION OF THAT ECRS FROM BEING AVAILABLE IN THE REAL TIME ENERGY MARKET AND THE PRICE INCREASES THAT RESULTED FROM THAT SEQUESTRATION, UH, WERE ARTIFICIALLY INDUCED OR, OR UNNECESSARY, UH, ANOTHER WAY TO PUT IT OR, UH, NOT WARRANTED BASED ON THE RELIABILITY VALUE AS WE CALCULATED IT.

SO, AND THAT, THAT ALL FELL OUT OF THAT ANALYSIS FROM 2023.

SO YOU'LL SEE A LOT OF OUR, A LOT OF THE PARTICULARS, UH, OF OUR RECOMMENDATIONS OR OBSERVATIONS FALL OUT OF THAT PREMISE, UH, IN PARTICULAR AND THROUGH CONVERSATIONS WITH, UM, MARKET PARTICIPANTS, FOLKS AT, UH, UH, AT ERCOT, YOU KNOW, I, I THINK THAT PROBABLY IS A FUNDAMENTAL DIFFERENCE, AND IT'S VERY FUNDAMENTAL TO OUR POSITION.

[01:00:01]

SO IF YOU DON'T SEE THAT THERE WAS SOME LEVEL OF OVER PROCUREMENT IN 2023, THEN SOME OF OUR RECOMMENDATIONS MAY MAKE LESS SENSE TO YOU.

BUT I THINK THAT'S AN IMPORTANT BASIS, AND THAT'S WHERE WE COME FROM, UM, YOU KNOW, BASED ON OUR ANALYSIS.

SO, SO GIVEN THAT WE DO FEEL THAT, YOU KNOW, A MATERIAL PORTION OF ECRS COULD BE MADE AVAILABLE, UH, TO SCAD, UH, AND THAT THE PRICE INCREASES THAT WERE OBSERVED IN 2023 WERE THE RESULT OF NOT MAKING THOSE AVAILABLE.

UM, AND AGAIN, THEY WERE ARTIFICIAL PRICE INCREASES BECAUSE WE BELIEVE THAT, THAT THAT CAPACITY WAS ARTIFICIALLY SEQUESTERED FROM, FROM SC.

SO, HAVING SAID THAT, W WE LOOK AT ANY FORM OF DEPLOYMENT, MAKING THOSE, UH, MEGAWATTS AVAILABLE TO SCED AND, AND THEREFORE AVAILABLE TO A ECONOMIC DISPATCH AND PRICE FORMATION AS AN IMPROVEMENT IN THE STEP IN THE RIGHT DIRECTION.

YOU'LL SEE FROM OUR COMMENTS, WE, WE DO HAVE SOME COMMENTS REGARDING USING UNDER GEN AS A TRIGGER FOR SC VERSUS SOME OTHER METHOD.

AND TO BE FAIR, YOU KNOW, IN CONVERSATIONS, YOU KNOW, UH, FOR THOSE WHO HAVE BEEN AROUND A WHILE IN THE WHOLESALE ELECTRICITY SPACE, UH, MARKET DESIGN IS AN EVOLUTIONARY PROCESS.

SO IN EARLIER CONVERSATIONS WITH ERCOT THAT, YOU KNOW, WE HAD A NUMBER OF, UM, POTENTIAL, UH, DEPLOYMENT TRIGGER OPTIONS ON THE TABLE THAT WE HAD FLOATED, UH, UNDER GENERATION WAS ONE OF 'EM.

UH, I, I ACTUALLY WASN'T HERE AT THAT TIME, BUT I'VE SEEN THE OPTIONS.

UH, THERE WERE OTHERS PRESENTED AS WELL.

AND THROUGH CONVERSATIONS WITH SOME PARTICIPANTS AND INTERNAL CONVERSATIONS, WE'VE COME UP WITH SOME OTHERS.

SO, SO, YOU KNOW, PART OF, PART OF OUR CONCERN AND RECOMMENDATION IN THE DEPLOYMENT SPACE IS WE HAVE CONCERNS, YOU KNOW, DESPITE EARLIER CONVERSATIONS OF HAVING, UH, A UNDER JAN TRIGGER AS ONE OF OUR RECOMMENDATIONS, YOU KNOW, I'LL NOTE THAT HAVING UNDER JAN AS A TRIGGER BECAUSE OF THE POWER BALANCE CONSTRAINT VIOLATION PENALTY, UH, NECESSARILY INJECTS A ADMINISTRATIVE PENALTY PRICE INTO PRICE FORMATION.

AGAIN, DRAWING BACK ON, YOU KNOW, WE BELIEVE, UH, CAPACITY WAS OVER SEQUESTERED FROM THE REAL TIME MARKET, THAT CONDITION, THAT OVER GEN CONDITION IN OUR, OUR POSITION IS A FALSE CONDITION OR AN ARTIFICIAL CONDITION.

AND SO USING OR OR VIEWING A ONE OR MULTIPLE POWER BALANCE CONSTRAINT VIOLATION, PENALTY PRICES AS A, AS A REASONABLE BASIS PRICE, UH, IS, IS I, I THINK ACCEPTING AN ARTIFICIAL PRICE AS A BASIS PRICE WHEN IN FACT, OUR, OUR BIG POINT WAS WE NEED TO ELIMINATE, UH, THE ARTIFICIAL SHORTAGE CONDITION MANIFESTING ITSELF IN PRICE FORMATION.

SO, SO HAVING SAID THAT, UH, ERCOT PROPOSAL MOVES THE BALL IN THE RIGHT DIRECTION, IT IS DEFINITELY DIRECTIONALLY CORRECT, UH, YOU KNOW, FROM THE, FROM THE 2023 BASIS OF NO DEPLOYMENT TRIGGER, BUT, BUT WE DON'T LIKE THE FACT THAT IT INJECTS, UH, AT A 40 MEGAWATT UNDER JAN ABOUT A THOUSAND DOLLARS, UH, OF BASICALLY SHORTAGE PRICING, UH, INTO THE PRICE FORMATION.

SO WE, WE, WE DISAGREE WITH THAT, AND THAT IS ONE OF THE PREMISES THAT'S THE LINKAGE, I GUESS, UH, ONE LINKAGE FROM, UH, THE DEPLOYMENT TRIGGER ITSELF TO THE OFFER PRICE FLOOR, WHICH I'LL GET TO IN A SECOND.

SO THERE ARE ALTERNATIVES.

UH, I KNOW THOSE ALTERNATIVES AREN'T ON THE TABLE TODAY FOR, FOR THE, UM, DEPLOYMENT TRIGGER, BUT THERE ARE ALTERNATIVES THAT COULD INVOLVE PRICES, UM, PRECEDING A SHORTAGE CONDITION, UH, AND AN INCREASE IN PRICE PRECEDING A SHORTAGE CONDITION THAT MIGHT, UH, SIGNAL DEPLOYMENT IS WARRANTED PRIOR TO A TRUE SHORTAGE CONDITION WHERE YOU GET ADMINISTRATIVE PRICING INJECTED INTO THE PRICE FORMATION.

THAT'S ONE OPTION.

ANOTHER OPTION IS, UH, BASED ON HEADROOM, UH, AVAILABLE IN SCED.

SO AS THE HEADROOM, UH, SHRINKS BEYOND A CERTAIN LEVEL, UH, DEPLOYMENT WOULD BE TRIGGERED AT THAT POINT.

UH, SO THAT'S NOT PRICE SPECIFIC, BUT, BUT IT'S PROBABLY THE MOST DIRECT, UM, MEASURE OF WHEN FREEING UP ECRS WOULD BE ADVANTAGEOUS TO ECONOMIC DISPATCH AND SCED.

SO ON, ON THE DEPLOYMENT, THAT'S, I GUESS A SUMMARY, IF YOU COULD EVEN CALL THAT A SUMMARY.

'CAUSE THAT WAS PROBABLY LONGER THAN, UM, ANYONE ELSE'S SUMMARY.

I, I WILL GET TO, UH, THE PRICE FLOOR.

SO, AND, AND, AND I THINK THAT PRIOR DISCUSSION IS REALLY CRITICAL IN TALKING ABOUT AN OFFER PRICE FLOOR AS WELL.

SO, SO IN OUR VIEW, UH, YOU KNOW, SOME PORTION OF SCED SHOULD HAVE BEEN OPTIMIZED OR SOME PORTION OF THE ECRS THAT WAS SEQUESTERED SHOULD HAVE BEEN OPTIMIZED AND SCED, UM, PRIOR TO REACHING A SCARCITY CONDITION.

I LOOK AT AND KNOW, AND I UNDERSTAND, I ACTUALLY DO UNDERSTAND THE ARGUMENT AGAINST, OR, OR THE ARGUMENT FOR A PRICE FLOOR TO PROTECT AGAINST PRICE SUPPRESSION WITH A LARGE RELEASE OF, OF RESERVE INTO THE ECONOMIC DISPATCH.

HOWEVER,

[01:05:02]

UM, THERE ARE MECHANISMS IN PLACE RIGHT NOW THAT WOULD, UH, INJECT ADMINISTRATIVE PRICING INTO, INTO THE ENERGY PRICE FORMATION AS RESERVES, UH, SHRUNK ANYWAY.

SO YOU'VE GOT THE ORDC, UH, CURVE THAT IS ALREADY IN PLACE.

A LOT OF THE CONVERSATIONS THAT WE'VE BEEN IN HAVE BEEN SORT OF JUXTAPOSING AN RTC WORLD AGAINST, AGAINST THE CURRENT SITUATION.

I'LL SPEAK TO THE CURRENT SITUATION BECAUSE I THINK IT'S CLEAR AND I, AND I DO THINK THAT THERE'S A CERTAIN AMOUNT OF CONFUSION THAT GETS INJECTED INTO THE CONVERSATION WHEN WE START BOUNCING IN BETWEEN AN RTC WORLD AND OUR CURRENT SITUATION.

THE, THE GENERAL PRINCIPLE OF CO-OP OPTIMIZATION IS WHAT'S DRIVING, UM, I THINK EVERYBODY'S DISCUSSION ABOUT HOW DO WE USE ECRS IN THE ECONOMIC DISPATCH, BUT WITH RESPECT TO THE CURRENT SITUATION, YOU KNOW, IF, IF, IF 500 MEGAWATTS IS RELEASED, UH, INTO SC UH, WITH, YOU KNOW, X MEGAWATTS OF UNDER GEN, IT DOESN'T MATTER, 30 MEGAWATTS 10 40, YOU WOULD EXPECT THAT THAT AMOUNT OF UNDER GEN TO BE DISPATCHED ALMOST IMMEDIATELY, IF NOT IMMEDIATELY, UH, FROM THE, THE RELEASED ECRS, THE REMAINING ECRS, UH, IS STILL AVAILABLE, UH, TO BE COUNTED IN AS, AS A RESERVE AND UTILIZED IN THE OR DC CALCULATION OF WHETHER OR NOT AND TO WHAT EXTENT, UH, AN ADMINISTRATIVE PRICE SHORTAGE PRICE IS INJECTED INTO THE PRICE FORMATION IN THE ENERGY MARKET.

SO WITH THAT IN PLACE, WE DON'T SEE ANY REASON TO, NOT TO OVERUSE THE WORD, BUT TO ARTIFICIALLY OR MANUALLY FORCE A PRICE INTO THE, THE, THE SCED PRICE FORMATION THROUGH AN OFFER PRICE FLOOR BECAUSE, AND ESPECIALLY IN THE CASE WITH A, UM, UH, UNDER GEN TRIGGER, YOU'RE ALREADY, YOU'RE ALREADY ON THE PATH TO POTENTIALLY HAVING A SHORTAGE CONDITION ARISE AND, UH, BE PRICED THROUGH THE ORDC.

SO, ORDC IS ALREADY AN, AN ADMINISTRATIVE PRICE TO REFLECT SCARCITY IN ENERGY.

I THINK OVERLAYING ANOTHER ADMINISTRATIVE PRICE ON TOP OF THAT, ESPECIALLY AT A THOUSAND DOLLARS, UM, IS IN A SENSE PROTECTING, UH, SOME OF THE 12 AND A HALF BILLION DOLLARS THAT WE CALCULATED AS A OVERAGE COST, UH, FROM 2023.

SO, SO WE, WE WOULD LIKE TO SEE THAT NOT HAPPEN, UH, AND WE WOULD PREFER TO SEE NO OFFER PRICE FLOOR, UM, INJECTED INTO THE RELEASED CAPACITY.

UM, WE, WE, WE DON'T SEE A JUSTIFICATION FOR IT.

AND AGAIN, IF I, THIS IS A LITTLE BIT OF A LONG SUMMARY, BUT, BUT TO ADD A PUNCHLINE, I GUESS TO IT IS A THOUSAND DOLLARS.

HOWEVER, IT'S JUSTIFIED, UM, AND, AND IT HAS BEEN THROUGH VARIOUS DISCUSSIONS WE'VE BEEN IN, IS STILL BASED ON A, A PRICE BASIS THAT RECOGNIZES SHORTAGE AS THE CORRECT CONDITION.

AND OUR PREMISE IS SHORTAGE IS NOT THE CORRECT CONDITION.

THE ECRS SHOULD HAVE BEEN AVAILABLE TO SC PRIOR TO HITTING A SHORTAGE CONDITION.

SO A THOUSAND DOLLARS IS NOT, OR $500 IS NOT THE RIGHT PRICE BASIS BECAUSE IT EMBODIES A SHORTAGE CONDITION THAT WE FEEL SHOULD NOT HAVE HAPPENED.

SO HOW, HOW WAS THAT FOR A SUMMARY CONCISE? GREAT.

DO YOU WANT TO, UH, MENTION THE SAVINGS NUMBERS OR SAY THAT FAST? YEAH.

OKAY.

THANK YOU SMI.

SO, UH, THANK YOU JEFF AND THANK YOU ACOR FOR ALL THE ANALYSIS AND DISCUSSION ON IT.

UM, I CAN SEE WHERE IMM IS COMING FROM.

UM, THEY ARE EXPECTED TO ARGUE FOR WHAT'S THEORETICALLY THE CORRECT MOST EFFICIENT MARKET OUTCOME.

AND FROM THEIR PERSPECTIVE OR FROM THE MOST EFFICIENT MARKET OUTCOME, IT CAN BE, UM, ARGUED THAT CONSERVATIVE OPERATION DOESN'T PROVIDE ANY ADDITIONAL RELIABILITY VALUE AND THERE IS NO, UH, COST THAT NEEDS TO BE ADDED AND NO PRICE FLOOR NEEDS TO BE ADDED.

AND, UH, A PRICE FLOOR, UH, COULD BE REMOVED BECAUSE THE ORDC IS REFLECTING THE SCARCITY.

BUT WE ALL KNOW THAT IS THE MOST EFFICIENT MARKET IS NOT WHERE WE ARE AT THIS POINT RIGHT NOW.

REGULATORS HAVE ALREADY DECIDED TO GO WITH THE CONSERVATIVE OPERATION, AND IF THE CONSERVATIVE OPERATION IS GOING FORWARD, WE ALREADY KNOW THAT THAT IS DRIVING OUT VALUE OUT OF THE, OR DC RESERVES.

IT'S NOT PRICING ANYTHING RIGHT NOW.

AND IF YOU, IF REGULATORS

[01:10:01]

NEED THIS CONSERVATIVE OPERATION, THEN THOSE RESERVES NEEDS TO BE VALUED APPROPRIATELY.

AND, UM, I WOULD REALLY ENCOURAGE PEOPLE TO LOOK AT THE, UH, SLIDES PROVIDED AT THE END OF TCPA COMMENTS TO SEE WHAT IS THE RELIABILITY VALUE THAT WE CAN SEE FROM THE CURRENTLY APPROVED A SDC.

UM, THAT IS THE VALUE THAT YOU SEE IN RTC RIGHT NOW, IF WE GO IN IMPLEMENTING RTC RIGHT NOW, UH, ANYONE WHO HAS FOLLOWED RTC TASK FORCE DISCUSSION WOULD KNOW THAT THERE'S LOT OF THINGS THAT SHOW THAT CURRENTLY APPROVED A SDC ITSELF IS NOT VALUING THE RESERVES APPROPRIATELY.

AND WHAT TCPA PROPOSED IS JUST PUTTING IT AT THE LEVEL THAT WE ALL AGREED AND THE PUCT APPROVED, UH, BASED ON THE RDC.

SO REMOVING THE OFF FLOOR, EVEN THOUGH THAT IS THEORETICALLY THE MOST EFFICIENT RESULT, MAY NOT BE WHAT THE REALITY WE ARE IN RIGHT NOW.

AND THAT IS SIGNIFICANTLY WILL UNDERVALUE THIS RESERVES.

UM, I KNOW THAT ACCORD, WHEN THE PRESENTED, UH, THE DIFFERENT APPROACHES FOR ADDRESSING THIS, UM, ECRS RELEASE, THERE WERE MANY OPTIONS THAT WERE PRESENTED.

AND ONE OF THE OPTION WAS TO HAVE A STANDING DEPLOYMENT OF, UM, ECRS AT A PRICE FLOOR.

AND IF I REMEMBER CORRECTLY, THERE WAS DESIRE TO ENSURE THAT ECRS IS STILL PROVIDING VALUE.

SO IT NEEDS TO BE AT A, A LEVEL PRICE LEVEL WHERE IT DOESN'T GET DEPLETED OR IT GET, DOESN'T GET USED UP FIRST SO THAT THE REST OF THE RESOURCES CAN GO AWAY.

UH, JEFF IS CORRECT THAT IT, THE, EVEN IF IT GETS USED UP FIRST, THERE MAY BE OTHER RESOURCES STANDING BY, BUT THAT DOESN'T PREVENT IT FROM THE OTHER RESOURCES FROM GOING OFFLINE OR NOT BEING AVAILABLE.

SO IF YOU REALLY WANT THE RESERVES TO BE, UM, AVAILABLE, YOU NEED TO HAVE IT EITHER, UH, PRESERVED OR BEHIND, UH, SOME PRICE, UH, LEVEL.

SO I WOULD LIKE TO, UM, MAYBE HEAR FROM ERCOT, UH, ABOUT, UM, THE CONCERNS WITH HAVING, UH, RELEASING IT EARLIER OR HAVING NO PRICE FLOOR OR, UH, THE VALUE THAT, UH, ELCOT SEES, IF THAT'S OKAY.

OKAY.

THAT'S FINE.

AND I, I HAVE SOME MORE AFTER THAT.

MAYBE .

ALRIGHT, GO AHEAD JEFF.

YEAH, SO, UH, MAYBE, UH, SO I, SO I HAVE SOME COMMENTS.

MAYBE BEFORE I DO THAT, I'D LIKE TO GET CLARIFICATION.

SO I, AS I READ THE MAY 17TH IMM COMMENTS, JEFF, I, I THINK THAT YOU ALL, YOU ALL JUST REMOVED THE, THE OFFER FLOOR CONCEPT ALTOGETHER.

IT IT, AM I UNDERSTANDING THAT RIGHT? THAT'S CORRECT.

OKAY.

OKAY.

SO, SO, UM, AND, AND, AND MAYBE BEFORE I, UM, GO TOO FAR, I, I WANT TO REMIND EVERYONE THAT THERE ARE SORT OF THREE PARALLEL EFFORTS GOING ON RIGHT NOW.

SO WE HAVE THIS, UH, PUC ANCILLARY SERVICES STUDY, UH, WHERE WE ARE WORKING, UH, WITH, UH, THE IMM, AND WE'RE LOOKING AT ARE THERE, UH, THINGS THAT WE NEED TO CHANGE IN THE METHODOLOGY ON HOW WE CALCULATE ANCILLARY SERVICES, WHAT, WHAT ANCILLARY SERVICES WE HAVE, THOSE SORTS OF THINGS OR OTHER FUNDAMENTAL CHANGES THAT WE NEED TO MAKE.

AND SO THAT IS A, A, A PARALLEL EFFORT THAT, UH, WE'RE WORKING ON.

AND, UH, I THINK WE HAVE TO FILE SOMETHING AT THE COMMISSION BY SEPTEMBER 1ST.

UM, ANOTHER PARALLEL EFFORT IS THE 2025 ANCILLARY SERVICES METHODOLOGY, WHICH WE HAVE ALREADY INTERNALLY STARTED WORKING ON.

AND, AND I THINK THAT WE WILL START TAKING THAT TO WORKING GROUPS, UH, ROUGHLY JULY, I, I, I BELIEVE.

UM, AND, AND SO AGAIN, THAT'S LOOKING AT THE 2025, UH, AS METHODOLOGY, WHICH, WHICH I THINK WILL BE, I THINK, SIMILAR TO WHAT YOU'VE SEEN IN, IN THE PAST.

UH, SO I DON'T EXPECT ANY OF THE, ANY OF THE CHANGES THAT, THAT MAY OR MAY NOT COME OUT OF THE PUC AS STUDY.

I I, I DON'T THINK THAT, THAT THOSE WOULD MAKE THEIR WAY INTO THE 2025 AS METHODOLOGY.

THERE MAY BE SOME THINGS ALONG THE EDGES, BUT NO SIGNIFICANT CHANGES.

UM, AND THEN THE, THE THIRD PARALLEL EFFORT IS THIS NPRR AS WELL AS A FOLLOW-UP NPRR THAT, THAT WE,

[01:15:01]

UM, CURRENTLY HAVE IN, UH, DRAFT INTERNALLY.

UH, AND THE IDEA BEHIND THESE, UH, TWO, NPRS 1224 AND, AND THE FOLLOW UP ONE, UH, IS TO ADDRESS WHAT WE WERE ASKED TO DO COMING OUT OF, UH, LAST YEAR'S THAT OR, BUT THE 2024 AS METHODOLOGY, WHICH WAS TO REVISIT ECRS.

UM, AND, UH, AND SO THERE'S THIS NPRR, WHICH WAS, UH, AN ATTEMPT TO GET A, AN ADDITIONAL MANUAL TRIGGER FOR RELEASING ECRS EARLY.

UH, WE HAVE A, AS I MENTIONED, A FOLLOW-UP NPRR, WHICH IS A STANDING DEPLOYMENT NPRR WITH, WITH, UH, YOU KNOW, OBVIOUSLY YOU'D HAVE TO HAVE AN OFFER FLOOR WITH THAT.

UM, AND SO WE ARE WORKING ON THAT.

UH, AGAIN, AS, AS A FOLLOW UP, WE'RE SOMEWHAT WAITING TO SEE WHAT HAPPENS WITH 1224 BEFORE WE POST THAT NPRR.

UH, BUT ANYWAY, SO JUST, JUST WANTED TO MAKE SURE EVERYONE WAS ON THE SAME PAGE.

UM, SO THAT, THAT SAID, UH, SO WE HAVE IN, IN THE CONTEXT OF ALL OF THOSE, UH, WE, WE HAVE HAD SOME REALLY PRODUCTIVE CONVERSATIONS WITH THE IMM.

I THINK WE BOTH UNDERSTAND EACH OTHER BETTER.

I, I, I HOPE THE IMM WOULD AGREE WITH THAT.

UH, I DON'T WANNA PUT WORDS IN THEIR MOUTH, BUT, UM, BUT, UH, SO WE'VE HAD SOME REALLY GOOD CONVERSATIONS.

UM, I, I THINK WE, WE STILL, TH THERE'S STILL A, A GAP IN, IN WHERE WE'RE AT.

TH THERE'S STILL, UM, AS WAS STATED, THERE'S SOME FUNDAMENTAL DIFFERENCES IN HOW WE VIEW THE RELIABILITY VALUE OF ECRS.

AND I THINK WE, WE DO SEE THAT THERE IS A BENEFIT TO THE SYSTEM FOR HOLDING BACK 10 MINUTE RESERVES FOR VARIOUS RELIABILITY EVENTS.

AND I THINK WE'RE, WE'RE STILL WORKING THROUGH THAT.

UM, BUT, UM, YOU, YOU KNOW, I THINK THAT THAT'S WHERE OUR, OUR DIFFERENCES AND, AND I THINK THAT'S WHY YOU SEE US, UM, YOU KNOW, COMING AT THIS, UH, WITH, WITH DIFFERENT VIEWPOINTS ON, UH, ON, ON HOW TO DO, UH, THIS, UM, THE, THE OFFER FLOOR.

UH, I, I, I PERSONALLY THINK THAT, THAT THE DIFFERENCES MAY BE MORE OF A QUANTITY ISSUE IN, IN, UH, HOW MUCH WE BUY.

UH, I, I THINK AT THE END OF THE DAY, I, I HOPE EVERYONE SEES THAT THERE IS VALUE, SOME VALUE IN SOME AMOUNT OF 10 MINUTE RESERVES.

UM, AND, AND SO I, I PERSONALLY THINK IT'S PROBABLY MORE OF A QUANTITY ISSUE.

UH, SO WE'RE, WE'RE GONNA CONTINUE THAT DISCUSSION AS PART OF THAT PUC AS STUDY, UM, AND WE'LL CONTINUE TO WORK ON THAT.

UM, BUT WE THINK THAT THE PRINCIPLE OF THE FLOOR, WE, WE NEED TO DO THAT CORRECTLY, UM, REGARDLESS OF THE QUANTITY, AND THEN WE CAN CONTINUE TO WORK ON WHAT IS THE RIGHT METHODOLOGY FOR DETERMINING THE QUANTITY.

UH, SO ALL, ALL OF THAT TO SAY, UH, WE, WE FILED 12 12 24 WITHOUT A, UH, AN OFFER FLOOR.

UH, WE ARE OKAY WITH 1224 MOVING FORWARD WITHOUT AN OFFER FLOOR, WHICH I, I THINK IS THE, I, I THINK WOULD BE THE MAY 17TH COMMENTS.

I, I, SO I, I WOULD SAY WE ARE NOT OPPOSED TO THE LANGUAGE.

I, I HAVE SOME FUNDAMENTAL DISAGREEMENTS IN SOME OF THE, THE PREAMBLE, UH, YOU KNOW, WORDS THAT, THAT WERE IN, IN THE COMMENTS THAT THE IMM FILED.

BUT, UM, YOU KNOW, I DON'T, I DON'T THINK THAT'S ANY SURPRISE TO THE IMMI, I THINK, YOU KNOW, WE'RE, WE'RE CONTINUING TO HAVE THOSE DISCUSSIONS.

UM, UH, BUT WE DO THINK THAT, UH, IF THERE IS AN OFFER FLOOR THAT IT NEEDS TO APPROPRIATELY VALUE HAVING THAT 10 MINUTE RESERVE PRODUCT THAT THE ECRS, UH, AND, AND, UM, AND SO WE WOULDN'T WANT THAT TO BE LOW.

SO WITH THAT SAID, WE ARE ALSO OKAY WITH THE PRS VERSION.

SO IF STAKEHOLDERS FEEL LIKE THEY WANT 1224 TO GO THROUGH WITH AN OFFER FLOOR, THEN WE ARE OKAY WITH WHAT HAS BEEN PROPOSED IN, UH, AND, UH, APPROVED IN THE PRS VERSION.

SO I HOPE, HOPE THAT HELPS.

REMI, YOU SAID YOU HAD, YEAH, MORE COMMENTS, , UH, SO THANK YOU JEFF AND I, I THINK, UH, IT'S, UM, GOOD TO HEAR YOU SAY THAT WE NEED TO APPROPRIATELY VALUE THE RESERVES.

AND, UM, UH, CAN WE SCROLL DOWN A LITTLE BIT ON THIS COMMENT? UH, THIS IS THE TCPA COMMENT, RIGHT? UH, THE TC.

SO, UH, I WOULD ENCOURAGE EVERYONE TO LOOK AT THE TCPA COMMENTS TO THE LAST SLIDE, WHICH SHOWS THAT, UM, WITH THAT A SDC CURVE, UM, THOUSAND IS A VERY REASONABLY LOW VALUE COMPARED TO ALL OF THE, UM, TIMES AT WHICH 500 MEGAWATTS OF EASY R IS RELEASED AND WHAT THAT PRICE CORRESPONDS TO.

UH, THAT BEING SAID, I CAN SEE, UH, THE CONCERNS THAT CONSUMERS HAVE, UH, ABOUT, UM,

[01:20:03]

HIGH PRICES GOING.

I WOULD SAY THAT, UH, TO CONSUMERS, WE NEED TO HAVE A BALANCE, UH, IN VALUING THE RESERVES THAT WE ARE PROCURING.

AND, UM, GETTING THE RIGHT LEVEL OF RESERVES IS, UH, IS IMPORTANT, BUT SENDING THE RIGHT PRICE SIGNAL IS ALSO IMPORTANT.

UH, SO IN, UM, IN THE SPIRIT OF, UH, COMPROMISE, CAN YOU SEE, LIKE I CAN, YOU CAN SEE LIKE 500 IS THE LOWEST, LOWEST VALUE IN, IN, IN THOSE.

SO I COULD, UM, I, I COULD SEE US REACHING A COMPROMISE FOR MAYBE A $500 FLOOR, BUT I WOULD REALLY ENCOURAGE TAC TO LOOK AT, UM, GIVE THAT AN OPTION.

SO, UM, CONSIDER THE THOUSAND DOLLARS FLOOR AND SEE WHERE THAT GOES, AND SEE WHERE THE MARKET CAN GET TO BEFORE WE COMPLETELY IGNORE THE PRICE ROAD, BECAUSE VALUING THOSE RESULTS RESERVES IS REALLY CRITICAL.

UM, SO IF I COULD MAKE A FRIENDLY AMENDMENT, I DON'T KNOW WHAT'S THE, UH, RIGHT NOW WE ARE TALKING ABOUT THE, YEAH, WE, WE HAVE TWO, WE HAD AN INITIAL MOTION, UM, TO APPROVE BASED ON THE PRS MOTION, AND THEN A MOTION TO AMEND THE MOTION BASED ON IMM COMMENTS.

I THINK WE SHOULD TRY TO KEEP THIS DISCUSSION RIGHT NOW TO THAT MOTION BEFORE WE START COMPROMISING WHEN WE HAVEN'T TAKEN THAT VOTE YET.

OKAY.

SO IF WE COULD GO THROUGH THIS QUEUE AND KEEP COMMENTS RELEVANT TO YEAH.

THIS MOTION, AND THEN IF NECESSARY, GET TO, OKAY.

SO I CAN COME BACK AND MAKE THAT THOSE COMMENTS FRIENDLY AMENDMENT AFTER WE GET THROUGH THIS MAYBE.

OKAY.

ANDREW, THANK YOU.

WELL, I DON'T WANT TO PREVENT YOU FROM MAKING A MOTION, BUT I THINK IT WOULD BE AN AMENDMENT ON TOP OF AN AMENDMENT.

SO I DON'T KNOW WHERE ROBERT'S RULES IS ON THAT.

I DON'T THINK YOU GET TO MAKE ENDLESS AMENDMENTS TO AMENDMENTS.

I THINK WE NEED, YOU SAID IT CORRECTLY, WE NEED TO RESOLVE THIS ONE FIRST.

OKAY.

AND ONCE THIS IS RESOLVED AND WE'RE BACK TO A MAIN MOTION, WE CAN GO RIGHT BACK INTO THE MOTION TO AMEND THE MOTION CYCLE AGAIN.

BUT WE NEED TO ADDRESS THIS ONE FIRST.

YES.

SO WE ALREADY DECIDED TO GO THROUGH THIS QUEUE, BUT IF WE COULD LIMIT COMMENTS IN THIS QUEUE, UM, GO GOING THROUGH JOHN RUSS HUBBARD, AND MAYBE ENDING THERE IF WE COULD LIMIT THE, THE COMMENTS IN, IN THIS CURRENT QUEUE TO THIS MOTION TO AMEND THE FIRST MOTION.

ANDREW, ANDREW REERS.

IMM.

I MIGHT NOT HAVE FOLLOWED ALL OF THE AMENDMENT LOGIC, BUT I DO WANT TO JUST RESPOND TO SOME OF THE FRAMING AS FAR AS HOW THE, UH, A SDC IS BEING USED AS A REFERENCE POINT FOR A 500 MEGAWATT RELEASE OF ECRS.

UH, A 500 MEGAWATT RELEASE OF ECRS, GIVEN THE WAY SC CURRENTLY OPERATES, ISN'T REALLY ANALOGOUS TO A 500 MEGAWATT SHORTAGE OF ECRS UNDER RTC.

SO IF YOU RELEASE 500 MEGAWATTS OF ECRS IN THE CURRENT PARADIGM, ONLY SOME OF THAT ENERGY IS GOING TO BE DISPATCHED.

IF WE USE THE 40 MEGAWATTS OF UNDER GEN EXAMPLE, PERHAPS 40 MEGAWATTS OF THAT ECRS CAPACITY WILL BE GIVEN BASE POINTS, AND THE OTHER 460 MEGAWATTS OF IT WOULD STILL BE IN RESERVE.

SO IF WE WANT TO COMPARE THIS TO AN RTC SITUATION, YOU WOULD AWARD THAT OTHER 460 MEGAWATTS BACK TO ECRS, AND THEREFORE YOU'RE ONLY GOING SHORT BY 40 MEGAWATTS.

AND SO I JUST WANNA STATE THAT KIND OF PEGGING THE OFFER FLOOR BASED ON A 500 MEGAWATTS SHORTAGE GIVEN, UH, CRUDELY DRAWN MIGHT BE TOO CRUEL OF A COMMENT, BUT BASED ON THESE A SDC CURVES, WHERE THEN THE OTHER COMMENT WOULD BE, THERE'S STILL SOME DISAGREEMENT ABOUT WHAT THE SHAPE OF THE CURVES SHOULD BE IN THE FIRST PLACE, UH, THAT WOULD LOWER THE BASE POINT THAT PEOPLE ARE USING TO MAKE THEIR ASSUMPTIONS ABOUT WHAT THE OFF FLOOR SHOULD BE.

UH, GRANTED, ONCE YOU RELEASE 500 MEGAWATTS OF ECRS, ALL OF IT COULD EVENTUALLY BE DISPATCHED.

AND SO THESE ARE INHERENT LIMITATIONS OF THE CURRENT SC VERSUS RTC SC, AND IT'S HARD FOR ME TO TELL BASED ON THOSE FIGURES WHAT 40 MEGAWATTS OF AN ECRS RELEASE WOULD BE, BUT IT'S A LOT LOWER THAN WHAT IT WOULD BE FOR 500 MEGAWATTS.

THANK YOU.

BILL BARNES, MAD CHAIR.

I'D LIKE TO HOLD MY COMMENTS AFTER THE VOTE IN THE MOTION.

THANK YOU.

YOU'RE THE BEST.

OKAY.

BLAKE.

BLAKE, HOLE, L-C-R-A-A.

A LOT OF MY POINTS HAVE BEEN MADE

[01:25:01]

BY OTHERS, SO I'LL, I'LL TRY TO KEEP IT SHORT, BUT MY INTERPRETATION OF THIS NPRR IS MEANT TO ADDRESS PRICE, PRICE FORMATION CONCERNS, UM, AND WE'VE BEEN TOLD THAT WE SHOULD PUSH IT THROUGH BECAUSE IT IS DIRECTIONALLY RIGHT.

UH, WHAT WE HAVEN'T BEEN GIVEN IS CONTEXT TO HOW MUCH OF A PRICE IMPACT THIS WOULD'VE HAD LAST SUMMER.

AND, YOU KNOW, I THINK THAT'S THE REASON FOR SOME OF THE DIVIDE WE'RE SEEING HERE.

UH, MY PERSONAL OPINION IS THIS GROUP SHOULD BE MORE CONCERNED ABOUT DESTINATION THAN DIRECTION, ESPECIALLY IN TERMS OF PRICE FORMATION.

THE JEFF AND JEFF HAVE ALREADY KIND OF LAID OUT THE FOUNDATION OF THE ISSUE HERE.

UM, THERE'S A DISAGREEMENT ABOUT ECRS PLAN SIZE, UM, YOU KNOW, LCRA IS VIEWING THIS NPR THROUGH THE LENS THAT THE PLAN IS RIGHT SIZED BASED ON A RE-REVIEW OF THE PLAN BY ERCOT.

UM, SO I THINK WHEN YOU LOOK AT IT LIKE THAT, THESE RESERVES HAVE VALUE, WHICH REMI HAS POINTED OUT, AND JEFF HAS POINTED OUT.

AND WHAT THIS GROUP SHOULD BE LOOKING TOWARDS IS GUIDANCE ON WHAT THAT VALUE IS.

AND I THINK WHAT WE CAN DO TO WALK DOWN THAT PATH IS TO LOOK AT WHAT WOULD HAPPEN UNDER THE MECHANISMS OF THIS NPRR AT A 40 MEGAWATT UNDER GEN PENALTY ON THE CURVE, THERE IS A TRADE OFF FOR ERCOT TO SUBSTITUTE RESERVES FOR ENERGY.

AND WHAT DOES THAT TRADE OFF VALUE? IT'S $1,000.

THE PRICE AT THAT TIMEFRAME FOR THOSE THREE SC INTERVALS WILL BE AT LEAST $1,000.

SO, IN MY MIND, THAT GIVES US DIRECTION TOWARDS WHAT A DESTINATION FOR A PROPER PRICE SHOULD BE FOR THE ECRS RELEASE.

AND I WOULD URGE THOSE, UH, THAT IN THIS VOTE TO AT LEAST CONSIDER THAT, UM, WHEN THEY ARE MAKING THEIR DECISION.

THANK YOU.

THANK YOU, ERIC.

YES.

I'M, I'M GONNA STEP BACK AND TAKE A BIGGER PICTURE VIEW ON THIS.

UM, PROCURING MORE ANCILLARY SERVICES IN SHOULDER MONTHS, ECRS, MAYBE LONG-TERM DRRS MAKES SENSE.

IF YOU WANNA RUN THE SYSTEM CONSERVATIVELY, THERE'S A LOT.

YOU, YOU HAVE UNUSUAL WEATHER.

WE HAVE MORE VARIABILITY AND OUTPUT, UH, OF GENERATION BECAUSE OF THE INCREASING PENETRATION AND RENEWABLE.

SO IT MAKES SENSE TO INCREASE THE PROCUREMENT FROM A RELIABILITY POINT OF VIEW.

IF ERCOT IS BEING ASKED TO RUN THE SYSTEM MORE CONSERVATIVELY DURING THE SUMMER, IT IS A REDUNDANT REQUEST.

AND WHAT DO I MEAN IS THAT FOR THE LAST TWO DECADES, THIS ENERGY ONLY MARKET HAS RUN ON THE IDEA THAT SCARCITY PRICING AND SENSE COMMITMENT AND COMMITMENT IS INCENTED BY CONTRACTING BILATERALLY.

OKAY? SO EVERYONE PRETTY MUCH FIGURES, IF YOU'RE IN MID-AUGUST AND YOU'RE HITTING RECORD HIGHS AND YOUR RECORD HIGHS EVERY SINGLE DAY, THAT EVERY UNIT, EVERY RESOURCE IS GONNA BE AVAILABLE TO THE DEGREE IT CAN.

NO ONE SITTING BACK AND SAYING, I DON'T THINK SO.

SO THE PROCUREMENT OF THE EXTRA PROCUREMENTS ARE REDUNDANT IN THAT REGARD.

AND IT'S, SO, AND THIS IS BECOMING SO BECAUSE OF YURI, THE KNOWLEDGE OF THE RISK OF RELIABILITY INCIDENTS DURING SUMMER SO HIGH THAT IT'S ON THE TV.

AND MY KIDS SAY ONCE IN A WHILE, HEY, DAD, THEY'RE TALKING ABOUT ERCOT AGAIN ON THE TV, RIGHT? UM, SO IT SEEMS TO ME THAT THE IMM HAS IT RIGHT IN THE SENSE THAT THE OVER PROCUREMENT IS ESSENTIALLY ARTIFICIALLY RESTRICTING THE ABILITY OF THE MARKET PARTICIPANTS TO BILATERALLY CONTRACT AT A, AT A, AT A, AT A MORE EQUITABLE PRICE AND INVOLVING RELIABILITY, MARKET RISK, ET CETERA.

AND SO THE THOUSAND DOLLARS IS AN ARTIFICIAL CONSTRUCT DURING THE HEIGHT OF SUMMER, WHICH I ASSUME IS THE, THE LARGEST PART OF THE COST ASSOCIATED WITH THE, UM, UM, COST OVERRUNS THAT THEY TALK ABOUT.

SO WE DEFINITELY SUPPORT THE I'S COMMENTS AS PART OF THIS PROCESS BECAUSE IT REFLECTS THE REALITY OF HOW THE MARKET WORKS.

NOT JUST RELIABILITY, BUT ALSO HOW THE MARKET WORKS AS WELL.

THANK YOU.

THANK YOU.

AND I DO HAVE A UPDATE AND A HISTORY LESSON.

WE HAVE ALLOWED TWO MOTIONS TO AMEND BEFORE THE LAST TIME WAS IN 2013 ON NPRR 5 68, WHICH IMPLEMENTED THE ORDC.

SO REMI OUTTA FAIRNESS, IF, IF YOU WANTED TO MAKE A SECOND MOTION TO AMEND, SO CAN I JUST, WOULD IT BE AMENDING THEIR MOTION OR WOULD IT BE AMENDING? YOU'D BE AMENDING THE SEC, THE SECOND MOTION TO AMEND.

WE'D HAVE TO, TO TAKE A VOTE ON THAT.

AND THEN THE VOTE ON THE FIRST MOTION TO, I JUST, YEAH, WE GO BACK.

I JUST WAIT, WAIT FOR THIS

[01:30:01]

TO GO THROUGH AND THEN I'LL, THAT'S WHAT CORY WOULD PREFER, BUT A TERRIBLE, UM, RIGHT NOW WE'RE ON A SUPPLEMENTAL MOTION TO AMEND THE MAIN MOTION.

THERE'S NO RULES TO MAKE A SUPPLEMENTAL ON THE SUPPLEMENTAL.

WE NEED TO TAKE IT UP A, A MISTAKE THAT WAS MADE IN 2013 BEFORE I WAS HERE.

I'M, IT'S REGRETTABLE.

I'M SO SORRY.

WE WOULD NOT HAVE THE ORDC BUT FOR TWO MOTIONS TO AMEND.

NO, YOU WOULD, YOU WOULD HAVE THOUGH, BECAUSE ALL YOU NEED TO DO, YOU WOULD HAVE IT.

NO MOTION HERE SUCCEEDS UNLESS TWO THIRDS OF YOU WANT IT.

SO IF YOU GUYS LIKE SMIS IDEA OF, I'D LIKE TO GO BACK TO THE PRS REPORT AND TALK ABOUT DESKTOP EDITS TO CHANGE THE THOUSAND VOTE NO ON THIS SO THAT YOU DO NOT TURN THE MAIN MOTION INTO THE IMM COMMENTS.

SO IF THAT'S A ROUTE Y'ALL WANT TO GO, YOU CAN DO THAT.

YOU DON'T HAVE TO TRY TO AMEND THE AMEND THE AMEND ADDRESS THIS.

AND IF THAT'S WHAT TWO THIRDS OF Y'ALL WANT, THAT'S WHAT WILL HAPPEN.

YOU DON'T, YOU DON'T HAVE TO PLAY A PROCEDURAL GAME OF WHOSE MOTION GETS PUT ON THE TABLET FIRST.

IT'S JUST WHATEVER TWO THIRDS OF Y'ALL WANT IS WHAT THE ACTION OF TACK WILL BE.

I'M SO SORRY FOR THAT.

COREY, LET'S GO TO NED .

ALRIGHT, UM, I'M GONNA TRY TO BE QUICK.

UH, FIRST OF ALL, I, I DO WANNA SAY, UM, YOU KNOW, I REALLY APPRECIATE THE I'S ENGAGEMENT ON THIS.

I, I, WHEN I STARTED OFF SAYING, YOU KNOW, REASONABLE MINDS MAY DIFFER, WHAT I WAS GETTING AT IS I REALLY APPRECIATE THE, THE ENGAGEMENT Y'ALL HAVE HAD.

I ECHO JEFF'S COMMENTS THAT THE MORE WE'VE TALKED, I THINK THE MORE WE'VE UNDERSTOOD WHERE EACH OTHER COMING FROM, AND THAT'S, UH, YOU KNOW, THAT'S VALUABLE.

I THINK THAT'S WHAT THAT, WHAT TAX SHOULD BE TRYING TO FOCUS ON DOING AS WE WORK THROUGH SOME OF THESE REALLY COMPLICATED ISSUES.

SO, UM, WHILE, WHILE WE MAY NOT, WE MAY NOT AGREE ON THE RIGHT OUTCOME, I THINK WE'VE HAD A, A GOOD DIALOGUE IN THE PROCESS.

SO, UM, FIRST OF ALL, WANTED TO SAY THAT, UM, AND I THINK I'LL ECHO WHAT, UH, WHAT BLAKE HAD SAID ABOUT, YOU KNOW, JOINT COMMENTERS.

LOOK AT THIS NOT FROM, YOU KNOW, NOT FROM THE WAY THAT, YOU KNOW, SOMEONE WOULD ARGUE THE WORLD OUGHT TO BE.

WE TAKE IT AS, AS A GIVEN.

SO IF ERCOT OPERATIONAL PREFERENCES ARE WHAT THEY'RE, BLESS YOU, , UH, IF, IF ERCOT OPERATIONAL PREFERENCES ARE WHAT THEY ARE, THE MARKET NEEDS TO REFLECT THAT.

AND THAT'S, THAT'S THE FUNDAMENTAL PRINCIPLE THAT, THAT WE'RE GETTING AT.

WE'RE WE'RE, WE'RE TAKING THAT AS A, AS A GIVEN AT ANY GIVEN POINT IN TIME AND JUST SAYING WE DON'T WANT THOSE TO BE DISCONNECTED.

UM, WE'VE SEEN HOW THAT PLAYS OUT IN THE PAST.

THAT'S, UH, THAT THAT'S GIVEN US A LOT, LOT OF, UH, NIGHTMARES ABOUT RUCKS IN, IN RECENT YEARS.

AND, UM, SO THAT'S, THAT'S THE OVERARCHING PRINCIPLE THAT WE'VE, WE'VE, UM, TRIED TO EMBODY IN THAT AS WELL AS, YOU KNOW, THE TRYING TO BRIDGE TWO WORLDS CONCEPT.

UM, AND I I WILL SAY NO, NO OFFENSE TAKEN ON THE, ON THE CR DRAWING, I WILL BE THE FIRST TO ADMIT MY LIMITATIONS.

, THAT'S, UH, THAT'S, UH, THAT'S DEFINITELY ONE OF 'EM.

UM, BUT REALLY THAT WAS JUST MEANT TO BE A, YOU KNOW, A HELPFUL REPRESENTATION OF, OF THE PRINCIPLE THAT WE WERE TRYING TO, TO REFLECT.

UM, I DO THINK ONE OF THE THINGS THAT'S COME OUT OF OUR, UH, OUR CONVERSATIONS HAS BEEN, UM, REALLY THAT DIFFERENCE OF, OF PERSPECTIVE ON WHAT THE VALUE OF RESERVES ARE UNDER THE CURRENT OEDC FRAMEWORK VERSUS THE ANCILLARY SERVICE DE ANCILLARY SERVICES DEMAND CURVES UNDER REALTIME CO OPTIMIZATION.

AND THE BIG DIFFERENCE THERE IS, WHAT I THINK JEFF WAS GETTING AT, IS THAT THERE ARE DIFFERENT QUALITIES OF RESERVES.

THE ODC TODAY DOESN'T CARE IF YOU'RE A BATTERY THAT ONLY HAS FIVE MINUTES.

STATE OF CHARGE LEFT, DOESN'T MATTER IF IT'S A CONTROLLABLE LOAD RESOURCE, IF IT'S A GAS, UH, QUICK START GAS PLANT THAT HAS FIRM FUEL OR ONSITE FUEL OR, YOU KNOW, A SLOW MOVING RESOURCE BASE, LOAD RESOURCE THAT, YOU KNOW, HAS LSL TO HSL BUT IS PROBABLY NOT GONNA GET THERE IN THE NEXT 30 MINUTES.

DESPITE THAT, THAT'S THE, THE FRAMEWORK OF THE ORDC, THE ANCILLARY SERVICE DEMAND CURVES PIVOT.

AND THEY SAY, NO, WE HAVE A VERY SPECIFIC RANK ORDER IN OUR PREFERENCE FOR RESERVES.

AND GENERALLY SPEAKING, THE FASTER THE BETTER.

AND, UM, YOU KNOW, WE WANT THOSE FASTER RESERVES AND WE'RE GONNA VALUE THOSE APPROPRIATELY.

AND SO THAT'S, THAT I THINK IS ONE OF THE BIG DIFFERENCES IN, IN THE WAY THAT WE'VE, WE'VE VIEWED THIS.

SO, UM, ANYWAY, WITH, WITHOUT, UH, JUMPING THE GUN, UM, ON, ON RASHMI'S COMMENTS, I, I, I WOULD NOT ACCEPT A FRIENDLY AMENDMENT.

I DO THINK THAT THE, THE PRINCIPLE BASIS THAT WE'VE LAID OUT IS THAT THE PRS REPORT IS MOST CLOSELY LINKED TO THE ANCILLARY SERVICE DEMAND CURVES.

AND I THINK WE SHOULD BE, UH, VOTING ON THAT FIRST AND FOREMOST.

AND WITH THAT, I WILL, UH, OKAY.

GET OUTTA THE WAY.

BOB HILTON.

YEAH, REAL QUICKLY, I LIKE TO BOIL THINGS DOWN.

UH, REALLY IT COMES DOWN TO TWO THINGS.

THEN I GOT ANOTHER COMMENT AFTER THAT IN THE I'S POSITION AND, AND DOWN HERE WITH THE, THE CONSUMERS, THE STARTING PLACE IS THERE'S TOO MUCH BEING BOUGHT AND THEREFORE THERE'S NO VALUE ON THOSE RESERVES WHENEVER THEY'RE RELEASED.

ERCOT IS NOT IN THAT CAMP NORM.

AND SO THEY'RE, THEY VALUE THOSE, THEY BUY THEM, THEY SEE VALUE IN THEM.

ALL THE JOINT COMMENTER'S COMMENTS ARE DOING IS PLACING THAT VALUE ON THEM.

AND THAT'S WHAT WE'RE DOING WITH THOSE COMMENTS.

NOW, THERE'S ONE THING THAT WAS SAID BY THE IMM

[01:35:01]

THAT SAID THAT, WELL, WHEN THEY'RE RELEASED, UH, YOU WOULDN'T EXPECT ALL OF THAT 500 TO BE, TO BE DEPLOYED.

YOU CAN'T SAY THAT BECAUSE YOU DON'T KNOW WHAT THE OFFER CURVE'S GONNA BE FOR WHAT THEY'RE PUTTING IN.

I'M OUT THERE, I'M SETTING, I'M GETTING A, A CAPACITY PAYMENT FOR ECRS.

NO, I'M GONNA GET RELU REDO, YOU KNOW, GET POTENTIALLY DEPLOYED.

I MAY ADJUST MY OFFER CURVE FROM BEHAVIORAL CHANGES THAT WOULD MAKE SURE THAT WHENEVER I GOT DEPLOYED ON ECRS, I GOT DISPATCHED.

AND THAT'S WHAT WE'RE WORRIED ABOUT WITH SOME OF THE PRICE REVERSAL ISSUES.

'CAUSE WHERE THAT COMES FROM, 'CAUSE WE'VE SEEN IT IN THE PAST.

JOHN, JOHN RUSS HUBBARD WITH TIC, UH, I THINK WE APPRECIATE ALL THE COMMENTS THAT HAVE BEEN MADE.

IT'S BEEN A HELPFUL DIALOGUE.

UH, WE CONTINUE TO SUPPORT THE I'S APPROACH.

UM, AND I THINK IT'S, IT'S NOTABLE ERCOT FILED THE NPRR WITH NO PRICE FLOOR.

SO WHILE ERCOT MIGHT HAVE SOME VALUE IN KEEPING THESE RESERVES AND VALUING THESE RESERVES WITHOUT ADDITIONAL STUDY AND FIGURING OUT EXACTLY WHAT TYPE OF A FLOOR IS APPROPRIATE, I I, I THINK THAT TAKES MORE STUDY.

AND SO TODAY, MOVING FORWARD WITHOUT A FLOOR MAKES THE MOST SENSE ON A TEMPORARY BASIS.

IT'S ONLY GONNA BE AROUND FOR A YEAR.

AND YOU HEARD THAT ERCOT IS WORKING ON A SUBSEQUENT NPRR THAT WILL HOPEFULLY HAVE MORE OF AN ANALYSIS, UM, TO JUSTIFY, POTENTIALLY JUSTIFY A FLOOR.

BUT AT THIS POINT, TODAY, A, A FLOOR DOESN'T MAKE SENSE.

THANK YOU.

OKAY, THANKS JOHN.

MY INITIAL THOUGHT WAS TO TRY TO WRAP UP WHERE, WHERE THAT QUEUE ENDED WITH JOHN, BUT YEAH, LET'S, I WAS JUST THE, THE COUPLE IN THERE, BUT LET'S TRY TO, I WAS ACTUALLY HIM TO CALL THE QUESTION IN CASE WE GOT THAT FAR.

SO I, I THINK WE, AT THIS POINT, I'M READY TO CALL THE QUESTION ERIC AND REMI, DID YOU, YOU YOU WANT TO VOTE TO CALL THE QUESTION OR CAN WE SKIP THAT VOTE AND JUST, I THINK JOHN HUBBARD PRETTY MUCH COVERED WHAT I WAS GONNA SAY, SO, OKAY.

YEAH, I, I'D REALLY JUST LIKE TO VOTE.

OKAY.

YEAH, GO AHEAD.

OKAY, COREY, WHAT ARE WE VOTING ON? OKAY, SO RIGHT NOW THIS IS THE MOTION TO AMEND THE MAIN MOTION TO BE APPROVAL OF 1224 WITH THE FIVE 17 IMM COMMENTS THAT REMOVED THE OFFER FLOOR.

SO THIS IS JUST A VOTE TO DECIDE WHAT VOTE Y'ALL WANT TO TAKE NEXT.

SO NED'S ORIGINAL MOTION WAS AS P AS FROM PRS WITH A THOUSAND DOLLARS PRICE FLOOR.

WE HAVE A MOTION TO AMEND THAT MOTION TO INSTEAD BE WITH THE IMM COMMENTS, WHICH WOULD REMOVE THAT PRICE FLOOR.

THIS IS JUST TO DECIDE WHAT THE MAIN MOTION WILL BE.

SO YOU'RE JUST VOTING ON WHETHER YOU WANT TO CHANGE THE MAIN MOTION TO BE WITH THE IMM COMMENTS.

SO IF THIS SUCCEEDS, WE'LL THEN TAKE A VOTE AS AMENDED BY THE IM COMMENTS.

IF THIS FAILS, WE'LL BE BACK TO NED'S MAIN MOTION, WHICH IS JUST THE AS SENT BY PRS.

YEAH.

SO THIS IS NOT A UP OR DOWN VOTE ON EITHER.

CORRECT.

THIS IS JUST A PROCEDURAL VOTE TO DECIDE WHICH MAIN MOTION Y'ALL WOULD PREFER TO TAKE UP.

SO, GREAT.

SO ON THIS MOTION TO AMEND THE MOTION TO BE WITH THE MAY 17TH IMM COMMENTS, WE WILL START UP WITH ERIC.

YES.

CONSUMERS.

WITH ERIC.

THANK YOU.

NARAJ.

YES.

THANK YOU, GARRETT.

YES, SIR.

THANK YOU, ERIC.

YES, THANK YOU.

THANK YOU, UH, RICK FOR MARK? YES, THANK YOU.

AND THEN RICK FOR NICK? YES.

THANK YOU.

ONTO OUR CO-OPS.

MIKE? NO THANK YOU, BLAKE.

NO, THANK YOU ERIC.

NO, THANK YOU LUCAS.

FOR JOHN? NO, THANK YOU.

ONTO OUR INDEPENDENT GENERATORS.

BRIAN? NO, THANK YOU, CAITLIN.

NO, THANK YOU.

BOB.

NO SIR.

THANK YOU, SIR.

NED? NO, THANK YOU.

CO HERE ONTO THE IPMS. RASHMI? NO, THANK YOU, JEREMY.

NO, THANK YOU.

THANK YOU, IAN.

NO, THANK YOU.

CO.

THANK YOU KEVIN.

NO, THANK YOU.

THANK YOU.

ONTO OUR IRES.

BILL.

YES, THANK YOU, JENNIFER.

YES, THANK YOU.

UH, JAY, WE'RE RIGHT AT THE WINDOW, SO I DON'T IF YOU'RE, IF YOU'RE STILL HERE.

OTHERWISE HIS PROXY GOES TO CHRIS.

YOU WITH US, JAY? OKAY.

PUT YOU ON THE SPOT.

CHRIS, HOW ABOUT CHRIS OR J? YES.

OKAY.

AND THEN CHRIS FOR YOURSELF? YES.

THANK YOU.

ANDRE.

IOUS.

STACEY FOR KEITH.

UPSETTING.

OKAY.

THANK YOU.

DAVID ABSTAIN.

THANK YOU, COLIN.

NO, THANK YOU RICHARD.

UH, NO THANK YOU.

ANDRA MUNI IS RUSSELL.

NO THANK YOU JOSE.

NO, THANK YOU DAVID.

NO, THANK YOU.

AND ALICIA? NO.

OKAY.

MOTION TO AMEND.

THE MOTION FAILS WITH 64% AGAINST IT TO ABSTENTIONS.

SO NOW WE ARE BACK TO THE MAIN MOTION.

[01:40:02]

OKAY.

CAN WE VOTE ON THIS MOTION OR DO WE NEED TO TAKE RESUME AND BILL'S COMMENTS? YOU HAVE TO VOTE ON THIS.

WE HAVE TO VOTE THIS MOTION.

WE CAN VOTE ON THIS MOTION.

WE CAN, MY COMMENTS ARE RIGHT FOR DISCUSSION.

NOW DISCUSS IF POSSIBLE WE'RE GONNA, WE CAN'T AMEND THIS THOUGH.

OKAY.

GO AHEAD.

BILL.

CAN'T AMEND THIS.

WE CANNOT.

NO.

A MOTION TO AMEND AN ORDER.

NOW THAT YOU'RE BACK TO THE MAIN MOTION, I DON'T THINK YOU COULD MAKE THE SAME MOTION TO AMEND.

YEAH, YOU CAN.

YEAH.

MOTION.

WE WOULD, THAT WOULD JUST BE FILIBUSTERING.

BUT IF YOU WANTED TO TRY TO, NED ALREADY SHOT DOWN FRIENDLY DESKTOP EDITS.

SO THIS WOULD BE, ONE COULD ALSO SAY, IF YOU DON'T AMEND THIS VOTING NO ON THIS WOULD THEN CLEAR THE BOARD.

YOU'RE BACK TO NO MAIN MOTION.

SOMEONE CAN MAKE A MOTION TO A RECOMMEND APPROVAL OF THE PRS REPORT WITH DESKTOP EDIT.

SO WE'RE BACK TO TWO THIRDS CAN GET IT DONE, WHATEVER YOU GUYS GUYS WANT.

OKAY.

YEAH.

MY MOTION WAS TO DO A FRIENDLY AMENDMENT FOR HIS TWO 500, BUT HE ALREADY DECLINED IT, SO, OKAY.

I'LL MAKE A, IF THIS FAILS, I'LL MAKE A MOTION FOR 500.

OKAY.

BILL, DID YOU HAVE A COMMENT OR I WOULD LIKE DISCUSSION ITEM.

I WOULD LIKE TO MAKE A MOTION TO AMEND.

OKAY.

WHAT IS THE MOTION TO AMEND ON AN ATTEMPT AT A COMPROMISE? UH, AMEND THE PRS REPORT.

THE OFFER FLOOR TO $500.

IS THERE A SECOND? AND SO THIS IS NOT A UP OR DOWN ON 500.

COREY, DO YOU WANNA DO YOUR WHOLE SPIEL AGAIN? IT'S JUST ANOTHER MOTION TO AMEND THE MOTION THAT WE'D BE VOTING ON.

CORRECT.

THIS WOULD BE, AND I CAN PULL IT UP.

THIS WOULD BE TO TAKE THE PRS REPORT AND MAKE A BUNCH OF DESKTOP EDITS TO TURN ALL OF THESE THOUSANDS INTO 500 INSTEAD.

AND THAT WOULD BE THE, THE MOVER AND SECONDERS WISH THAT THE MAIN MOTION BECOME PRS REPORT AS REVISED BY TAC, WHERE THE TAC REVISIONS WOULD BE LOWERING ALL OF THESE THOUSANDS TO 500.

BUT IF YOU SUPPORT THE THOUSAND VOTING TO SAY, I DON'T WANNA AMEND IT DOES NOT NECESSARILY CONFLICT WITH LATER.

IF THE THOUSAND FAILS, SAY YOU GOT IT EXACTLY RIGHT.

FIVE.

YEAH, WE STILL WOULDN'T BE VOTING ON THE LANGUAGE ITSELF.

WE BE VOTING ON, WE'RE STILL ON THE THOUSAND.

THE MAIN MOTION THAT YOU WANT TAKE.

OKAY.

OKAY.

CAN YOU CLARIFY AGAIN? SO IF THIS ONE FAILS, YOU CAN STILL PUT A $500.

YES, IT'S A DIFFERENT MOTION.

'CAUSE THIS IS NOT A SUBSTANTIVE MOTION.

THIS IS JUST A MOTION TO AMEND THAT.

NO, IF THIS, IF THIS MOTION FAILS, WE'RE BACK TO NED'S WHERE THERE IS NO DESKTOP EDIT.

YES.

IT'S JUST CLEAN.

AND THEN AFTER THAT, IF THAT FAILS, WE COULD STILL MAKE THE DESKTOP EDIT.

THAT'S NOT THE SAME MOTION AS THIS.

'CAUSE THIS IS NOT A SUBSTANTIVE MOTION.

THIS IS JUST A MOTION TO AMEND THE MOTION.

ACTUALLY, CAN I JUST ASK A POINT OF ORDER JUST TO MAKE SURE WE'RE ALL ON THE SAME PAGE.

IF A, IF THE MOTION TO AMEND AT 500 FAILS, WOULD ANOTHER EVEN MAIN MOTION FOR 500 BE AN ORDER LATER? IT WOULD BE ALLOWED, RIGHT? BECAUSE THIS IS NOT A SUBSTANTIVE MOTION, CORRECT? IT'S, YEAH.

IT, THIS IS A SUBSTANTIVE, THIS IS A SUBSTITUTE MOTION THAT SOMEONE'S MAKING.

SO YEAH, IN THE SPIRIT OF IT, YOU'D HAVE, YOU'D PROBABLY HAVE TO LOOK TO THE GROUP TO DECIDE IF ENOUGH HEARTS AND MINDS HAD CHANGED IN THE COURSE OF IT.

BUT I THINK ON THE TECHNICALITY BASIS, BECAUSE THIS ISN'T A MAIN MOTION, IT WOULD BE ALLOWABLE.

OKAY.

ONLY IF ONLY IF NEDS FAILS.

SO, SO IT WILL BE ALLOWED ANOTHER $500.

YES.

OKAY, THANKS.

BECAUSE THIS IS NOT A SUBSTANTIVE MOTION.

IT'S JUST A MOTION TO CHANGE THE MOTION.

RIGHT.

BUT, BUT IN SPIRIT OF IT, IF, IF TWO THIRDS OF YOU DON'T WANT TO AMEND THE MOTION TO BE THIS, THEN SOMEBODY MAKING A MOTION AND SECOND FIVE MINUTES FROM NOW, IT, THE SPIRIT OF IT IS WHY IN BETWEEN THAT WE WOULD VOTE ON NED'S MOTION.

SO THAT CHANGES THE CIRCUMSTANCES.

YES.

OKAY.

LET'S, LET'S VOTE ON THIS, PLEASE.

COULD WE DISCUSS THE MOTION? SO I DON'T WANT TO BELABOR THIS ANY LONGER THAN I HAVE TO, BUT I DO WANT TO SAY THAT WE APPRECIATE THAT THERE IS A MOTION TO HAVE AN EARLIER TRIGGER.

THANK YOU.

BUT IT'S NOT A, IT'S NOT A MOTION FOR EARLIER TRIGGER YET.

IT'S A MOTION TO CHANGE THE MOTION TO ONE WITH AN EARLIER TRIGGER.

WELL, IT, IT, IT INCLUDES AN EARLIER TRIGGER IN THE LANGUAGE.

ALL OF IT DOES SO FAR.

GO FOR IT.

OKAY.

SO AGAIN, WE'RE JUST MAKING A MOTION TO AMEND THE MOTION TO DECIDE WHAT MAIN MOTION YOU GUYS WOULD LIKE TO VOTE ON.

SO INSTEAD OF THE IMM COMMENTS, NOW WE'RE BACK TO THE PRS REPORT WITH LOWERING THE FLOOR FROM A THOUSAND TO 500, AS THOSE WOULD BE DESKTOP EDITS BY T.

SO IF YOU WANTED THAT TO BE YOUR MAIN MOTION VOTE YES ON THIS.

IF YOU'D LIKE TO GO BACK TO NED'S VERSION, VOTE NO ON THIS.

ALRIGHT,

[01:45:01]

WE WILL START UP WITH THE CONSUMERS.

WITH ERIC.

NO Q NOT BARRAGE.

NO.

THANK YOU GARRETT.

NO, SIR.

THANKS SIR.

ERIC? NO, THANK YOU.

THANK YOU RICK FOR MARK.

NO, THANK YOU RICK.

FOR NICK.

NO THANK YOU.

ONTO THE CO-OPS.

MIKE? NO THANK YOU BLAKE.

NO, THANK YOU ERIC.

NO, THANK YOU LUCAS.

FOR JOHN.

NO, THANK YOU ONTO THE INDEPENDENT GENERATORS.

BRIAN, COME BACK TO ME.

CAITLIN.

NO, THANK YOU.

BOB.

NO SIR.

THANK YOU, NED.

NO, THANK YOU.

COREY.

THANK YOU.

ONTO THE IPMS RUSH.

ME.

NO, THANK YOU JEREMY.

NO, THANK YOU.

IAN.

NO, THANK YOU.

COREY.

THANK YOU KEVIN.

NO, THANK YOU.

THANK YOU.

ONTO THE I REPS.

BILL.

WE GOT THIS GUYS.

YES.

.

JENNIFER? YES.

ENTHUSIASTIC? YES.

OH YES.

CHRISTOPHER J YES.

AND CHRIS? YES.

THANK YOU.

ONTO THE IOUS STACEY FOR KEITH ABSTAIN.

THANK YOU.

DAVID ABSTAIN.

THANK YOU, COLIN.

YES.

THANK RICHARD.

UM, YES, THANK YOU.

ONTO THE MUNIS RUSSELL.

YES.

THANK YOU JOSE.

YES.

THANK YOU, DAVID.

YES, THANK YOU ALICIA.

YES.

THANK YOU BRIAN.

NO MOTION FAILS ABOUT TWO THIRDS AGAINST TWO ABSTENTIONS.

SO NOW, SO NOW WE ARE BACK TO NED'S ORIGINAL MOTION.

CORRECT.

ALRIGHT.

ON WHICH I HOPE WE CAN VOTE.

WE WILL.

I SEE NOBODY IN THE QUEUE.

YES.

YOU MAY MAKE ONE COMMENT.

IT'S A COMIC RELIEF COMMENT.

COREY, IF I, NEXT TIME I WATCH A TIME TRAVEL MOVIE OR INCEPTION, I, I, I WANT YOU TO BE THERE.

'CAUSE I THINK YOU'LL YOU'D BE AN EXCELLENT CO-PILOT FOR THAT.

FAIR ENOUGH.

DON'T INTERACT WITH YOUR PARENTS.

I, I WAS ALSO TOLD WE'VE DONE THE DOUBLE AMENDMENTS MULTIPLE TIMES.

COREY, WE'RE GONNA FIND AN INSTANCE OF ONE WHEN YOU WERE HERE.

I I, I THINK THE DOUBLE AMENDMENT IS ALLOWED, BUT THIS MIGHT BE A LITTLE BIT CLEANER.

OKAY.

LET'S VOTE ON NEXT MOTION BEFORE.

I LOVE COREY KICKS US ALL OUT.

YEAH, I, I'VE DONE THE RESEARCH AND COULDN'T FIND, UH, ANYTHING THAT EXPRESSLY ALLOWED.

SO THERE'S SIMULTANEOUS RESEARCH HAPPENING DURING .

I THINK I AGREE WITH ANN, BUT I LIKE THE CLEANNESS OF THIS.

I THINK.

ANYWAY, WE'RE, LOOK, I'M LOOKING FORWARD TO VOTING RIGHT NOW.

YEAH.

UM, ALL RIGHT.

BACK TO NED'S MOTION WITH THE PRS REPORT AS SENT.

UH, WE WILL START UP WITH THE CONSUMERS, WITH ERIC.

NO THANK YOU.

NO BARRAGE.

NO THANK YOU GARRETT.

NO SIR.

THANK SIR.

ERIC? NO, THANK YOU.

THANK YOU RICK FOR MARK.

NO, THANK YOU RICK.

FOR NICK.

NO, THANK YOU.

ONTO THE CO-OPS.

MIKE? YES.

THANK YOU, BLAKE.

YES.

THANK YOU ERIC.

YES.

THANK YOU LUCAS FOR JOHN? YES.

THANK YOU.

INDEPENDENT GENERATORS.

BRIAN? YES.

THANK YOU, CAITLIN.

YES, THANK YOU, BOB.

YES SIR.

THANK SIR NED? YES.

THANK YOU, SIR.

THANK YOU.

ON THE IPMS RASHMI.

YES.

THANK YOU, JEREMY.

YES.

YES.

THANK YOU.

THANK YOU.

IAN.

YES.

THANK YOU KEVIN.

YES, THANK YOU.

THANK YOU.

ON THE I REPS BILL.

NO, THANK YOU, JENNIFER.

NO, THANK YOU.

CHRISTOPHER J NO.

AND THEN CHRIS.

NO THANK YOU ON THE IOUS, STACY FOR KEITH TEXTING.

THANK YOU, DAVID.

YES, THANK YOU, COLIN.

YES, THANK YOU RICHARD.

YES.

THANK YOU.

ONTO THE MUNIS RUSSELL.

NO, THANK YOU.

JOSE ABSTAIN.

OKAY.

AND DAVID ABSTAIN.

THANK YOU.

AND ALICIA ABSTAIN.

THANK YOU.

MOTION FAILS.

58% IN FAVOR.

42 AGAINST FOR ABSTENTIONS.

SO NOW WE HAVE NO MOTIONS ON THE TABLE.

IF NO SUBSEQUENT MOTION IS MADE ON 1224, IT'LL BE DEEMED REJECTED.

5 0 1, BOB, IAN, REMI, BOB, GO FIRST.

YEAH.

OKAY.

COULD, COULD WE GO BACK TO THE JOINT COMMENTERS? UH, OR, OR WELL, THE PO UH, YEAH,

[01:50:01]

EITHER WAY.

THE JOINT COMMENTERS COMMENTS, RIGHT.

JUST REAL QUICKLY AND THEN GO BACK TO THE, THAT EXACTLY.

THE SDC CURVES.

AND FROM LOOKING AT THAT, YOU KNOW, WE THOUGHT WE HAD PUT SOMETHING IN THERE THAT WAS CLOSE, AND NOW WE'VE KIND OF HIT BOTH, BOTH OF THE BOOKENDS.

AND IF YOU NOTICE ON THE SECOND ONE DOWN ON THE LEFT, IT HITS, WHICH IS A MORE CONSERVATIVE NUMBER THAN THE THOUSAND DOLLARS.

A LITTLE LESS CONSERVATIVE, OF COURSE, THAN THE 500.

SO I'D MAKE A MOTION THAT WE SET IT THE FLOOR AT $750 GOING ONCE.

OKAY.

IS THERE A SECOND FOR BOB'S MOTION AT SEVEN 50? REMI SECOND.

IAN, DID YOU WANNA MAKE A COMMENT STILL? OKAY.

ARE YOU ABANDONING THE MOTION? ALL RIGHT.

SO THE MOTION NOW IS THE PRS REPORT AS REVISED BY DESKTOP EDITS THAT BOB JUST MADE TO SET THE FLOOR AT SEVEN 50.

NED.

SO STICKING WITH THE, THE PRINCIPLE THAT THAT, YOU KNOW, WAS EMBODIED IN THE JOINT COMMENTS AND TRYING TO LINK TO THE, THE ANCILLARY SERVICE DEMAND CURVES, I, IT SEEMS LIKE THE FURTHER YOU GO DOWN THAT CURVE, THE MORE IT BECOMES, YOU KNOW, A RISK THAT ERCOT RELEASES MORE THAN THE 500 MEGAWATT BLOCK.

AND THEN YOU, YOU, YOU DO GET OUTSIDE OF THAT.

UM, YOU DO RUN INTO, UM, UNDERVALUING THAT RELEASE AGAIN.

SO, UM, BOB, I, I WONDER IF YOU WOULD BE WILLING TO ACCEPT A FRIENDLY AMENDMENT TO LIMIT THE RELEASE TO 500 MEGAWATTS.

OKAY.

THAT'D BE FINE.

OKAY.

AND RECIPE'S NODDING TOO.

SO COREY IS GOING THROUGH, SO THAT'S THE LIMIT, THE RELEASE TO 500 MEGAWATTS.

ALRIGHT, DAN WOODFIN.

YEAH.

SO NOW YOU GOT ME WAIT, UH, PAYING ATTENTION BECAUSE WE ARE NEUTRAL ON A LOT OF THIS, BUT WE CAN'T LIMIT WHEN WE CAN RELEASE OUR RESERVES FROM RELIABILITY PERSPECTIVE.

THAT'S NOT, UH, 'CAUSE ULTIMATELY THAT'S WHY WE BUY THEM AND WE NEED TO BE ABLE TO RELEASE THEM AT THE APPROPRIATE TIME.

SO SAY IT'S A FREQUENCY EVENT, WE CAN'T LIMIT WHAT WE WOULD, UH, RELEASE CLARIFICATION, THEN IT WOULD NOT BE LIMITS ON ERCOT ABILITY TO RELEASE IT UNDER ANY CIRCUMSTANCES.

IT WOULD BE MANUAL RELEASE FOR THE, UNDER THE UNDER GEN FRAMEWORK THAT'S CONTEMPLATED IN NPR 1224.

ESSENTIALLY IT'S RELEASING FOR YEAH.

MARKET DAMPENING.

OKAY.

IKA, DID YOU WANNA ADD? SO I'VE RAISED MY HAND A BIT TOO EARLY.

SO, UH, LOOK AT THE LANGUAGE THE WAY IT'S WRITTEN RIGHT NOW.

SO WE WOULD RELEASE IT IN UP TO BLOCKS OF 500.

I THINK WHAT YOU JUST SAID IS UNDER THE UNDER GEN CONCEPT, YOU WANT US TO RELEASE ONLY 500 MEGAWATTS.

UH, I HAD READ IT AS, AS THAT WAS THE, SORRY, I SHOULD SPEAK INTO THE MIC.

I HAD READ IT AS, UH, AND THIS MAY HAVE BEEN BASED ON ONE OF THE EARLY PRESENTATIONS, SO IT COULD BE MM-HMM.

MISUNDERSTANDING ON MY PART.

BUT I HAD READ IT AS ERCOT WILL RELEASE 500 MEGAWATT BLOCK AND THEN COULD BE INCREMENTAL TO THAT.

CORRECT? CORRECT.

CORRECT.

THAT IS WHAT THE LANGUAGE HERE SAYS.

SO MAYBE YOU MAY WANT TO TELL US HOW, HOW ARE YOU LOOKING FOR US TO AMEND THE THOUGHT THAT YOU JUST YEAH, MAYBE NO MORE THAN WOULD BE THE RIGHT LANGUAGE.

I THINK YOU JUST STRIKE THE LAST SENTENCE ON FIVE TO GET WHERE YOU WANT TO GET.

I, I THINK THE QUESTION TO SOME EXTENT COMES TO OH YEAH.

AND THAT WHAT HAPPENS IF ANOTHER TWO INTERVALS OF 40 MEGAWATT UNDER GEN HAPPENS? IS THAT ANOTHER TRIGGER FOR MORE DEPLOYMENTS? IS THAT THE SITUATION YOU'RE REFERRING TO? THAT'S THE LAST SENTENCE.

YEAH.

YEAH, I THINK THAT'S, THAT'S, THAT'S PROBABLY RIGHT.

YEAH.

'CAUSE IF THERE, IF YOU HAVE ANOTHER SECOND ROUND OF THAT, THEN YOU GET ERCOT RELEASING MORE AND SO THEN YOU'VE GONE BEYOND THE 500 MEGAWATT BLOCK.

THAT'S, AND THAT'S, YOU KNOW, THAT'S WHERE OUR INITIAL FOCUS WAS.

BUT IF YOU, IF THEY END UP SAY RELEASING A THOUSAND MEGAWATTS, WELL THEN YOU'RE FURTHER UP THAT CURVE AND, AND WE'VE GOTTEN FURTHER AND FURTHER AWAY FROM, YOU KNOW, THE, THE MIDDLE GROUND BETWEEN TWO WORLDS THAT WE'VE BEEN TRYING TO, TO FORGE A BRIDGE THROUGH.

UM, SO

[01:55:04]

BILL, I'M JUST MAKING IT KNOWN TO TAC MEMBERS THAT I FEEL LIKE EVERYONE DESERVES A SECOND CHANCE.

SO IF THIS VOTE HAPPENS TO FAIL, UH, I WILL BE MAKING A MOTION TO, UH, SET THE FLOOR AT 500 AGAIN.

THANKS.

I SECOND THAT.

BOB HILTON.

I JUST WANNA ASK, 'CAUSE SINCE DAN SAID SOMETHING ABOUT, UH, THE RELEASE ISSUE BASED ON WHAT WE JUST TALKED ABOUT, DO Y'ALL STILL HAVE AN ISSUE WITH THAT? IF YOU DO, THEN I'LL CHANGE THAT, BUT, UH, I JUST WANNA MAKE SURE LANGUAGE, WHAT LANGUAGE DO YOU WANT? MAYBE THAT MIGHT HELP LESS SENTENCE.

SO I THINK THE, BECAUSE WORDS MATTER.

YEAH.

BECAUSE WORDS MATTER.

YES.

YEAH.

DELETION OF THE LAST SENTENCE.

UH, IT , THAT'S A, THAT'S A GOOD CLARIFICATION.

YES.

WORDS DO MATTER.

I THINK DELETION OF THE LAST SENTENCE ADDRESSES THAT.

UM, AND THAT WOULD NOT PRECLUDE ERCOT FROM RELEASING OR DEPLOYING ECRS FOR ANY OF THE OTHER, OTHER PURPOSES.

IT WOULD ONLY BE IN THIS MANUAL RELEASE CONSTRUCT.

SORRY, THIS IS THE DANGER OF DESKTOP EDITS, GUYS.

YEP.

UM, , POINTED OUT THAT ALSO THE, UH, THAT SENTENCE, YEAH.

STARTING WITH FOLLOWING WOULD ALSO BE STRUCK TO BE IN LINE WITH THAT.

SO NED, YOU'RE PROPOSING TO REMOVE THE HIGHLIGHTED SENTENCE AND THE LAST SENTENCE? YES.

THAT HIGHLIGHTED SENTENCE.

AND THE LAST SENTENCE WOULD BE, WOULD BE STRUCK, I GUESS.

THANK YOU FOR COMING ON THIS JOURNEY WITH ME GUYS.

OKAY.

UH, NIKA, DID YOU HAVE ANY THOUGHTS ON THAT OR CAUGHT FEEDBACK? CAN I THROW ONE MORE SCENARIO AT YOU, ? SO RIGHT NOW IT SAYS 40 FOR AT LEAST 10 MINUTES.

SAY YOU STRIKE BOTH THOSE STATEMENTS OUT.

WE RELEASE ECRS 500 MEGAWATTS UP TO PER THIS BLOCK.

AFTER 30 MINUTES, WE HAVE ANOTHER ROUND OF ALARMING THAT WE HAVE A 10 MINUTE WE VIOLATED UNDER JEN PER THE STATEMENT FOR 10 MINUTES.

ARE WE, ARE WE, HOW SHOULD WE READ THIS LANGUAGE? SO IF I'M FOLLOWING CORRECTLY, IT'S, YOU'VE HAD ONE TRIGGER, YOU RELEASED THINGS NORMALIZE, AND THEN YOU HAVE IT HAPPEN AGAIN, THEN YOU WOULD DO THIS.

YEAH.

HAVE YOU, HAVE YOU RESTORED YOUR ANDROGEN SCENARIO SINCE THEN? MAY NOT HAVE, I'M STILL THINKING YOU'RE IN THE AFTERNOON.

YOU, YOU'VE STILL NOT YET PASSED THE EVENT FULLY.

HOW WOULD ERCOT LIKE , LEMME PUT IT BACK.

WHAT IS WHAT? BECAUSE ULTIMATELY THIS COMES DOWN TO ERCOT OPERATIONAL PREFERENCES, RIGHT? WE'RE TRYING TO ALIGN THE MARKET OUTCOME WITH WHAT, WITH WHAT Y'ALL WOULD, WOULD DO.

AND WOULD IT MAKE SENSE TO HAVE A SECOND STEP THAT THAT GOES FURTHER UP THE A SDC? BECAUSE THAT'S, THAT'S WHERE, YOU KNOW, THINKING ON THE FLY, I WOULD THINK WOULD THE APPROPRIATE NEXT STEP WOULD BE, UM, AND, UH, GO AHEAD RUSSELL FRANKLIN, WHILE THEY'RE WORKING ON THAT.

NO, I WAS JUST GONNA SAY THAT I THINK THAT WE WERE WILLING TO, UH, SUPPORT THE $750 FLOOR, BUT WITH THESE CHANGES NOW, I, I THINK THAT I, I CAN'T SUPPORT IT WITH, UH, TRYING TO TO LIMIT THE 500 MEGAWATTS OR TWO 500 MEGAWATTS.

SO, UM, DIDN'T WANT US TO GO TOO FAR DOWN THIS PATH SAYING, HEY, I THINK THAT WE WOULD BE WILLING TO HAVE A FRIENDLY COMPROMISE.

BUT NOW WITH WHERE WE'RE AT, I THINK THAT I CAN'T, UM, AGREE TO WHERE WE'RE GOING.

THAT'S IT.

OKAY.

WE'RE, WE'RE WORKING ON LANGUAGE.

CAN, CAN I SAY SOMETHING? I, BOB, I THINK BOB, I THINK THERE IS SOME CONCERN WITH THE LIMITING TO 500.

SO MAYBE WE SHOULD UH, NOT ADD THAT, BUT OKAY.

GIMME

[02:00:01]

A MINUTE.

OKAY.

, IF YOU WANT TO KEEP IT SIMPLE.

YEAH, I AGREE WITH YOU.

OKAY.

SO THE FRIENDLY AMENDMENT HAS BEEN UNACCEPTED.

IT APPEARS TO BE GETTING OVERLY COMPLICATED.

WE THOUGHT IT WAS MORE SIMPLE THAN THAT.

IT DOES APPEAR TO BE COMPLICATED.

IT APPEARS TO BE A LITTLE MORE COMPLICATED.

OKAY.

FRIENDLY AMENDMENT.

IT'S JUST SEVEN 50 AND NO LIMIT.

OKAY.

CAN WE VOTE ON THE MOTION? SO NOW IT'S JUST THE SEVEN 50 FLOOR.

YES.

OKAY.

NO OTHER CHANGES.

OKAY.

WE ALL GOOD? YES.

DO YOU WANNA TELL US WHAT THE MOTION IS? SO THIS IS THE MOTION TO RECOMMEND APPROVAL OF THE MAY PRS REPORT THAT STILL HAS THE OFFER FLOOR, BUT WITH DESKTOP EDITS TO LOWER IT FROM A THOUSAND TO SEVEN 50.

NO OTHER CHANGES.

NO OTHER CHANGES.

OKAY.

LET'S GO.

COOL.

WE'LL START UP WITH THE CONSUMERS.

WITH ERIC? NOPE.

THANK YOU.

NARAJ.

HELLO.

THANK YOU GARRETT.

NO SIR.

THANK YOU ERIC.

NO, THANK YOU.

THANK YOU RICK FOR MARK.

NO THANK YOU RICK.

FOR NICK.

NO, THANK YOU.

ONTO THE CO-OPS.

MIKE? YES.

THANK YOU BLAKE? YES, THANK YOU ERIC.

YES, THANK YOU LUCAS.

FOR JOHN? YES.

THANK YOU.

ONTO THE INDEPENDENT GENERATORS.

BRIAN? YES, THANK YOU CAITLIN.

YES, THANK YOU BOB.

YES SIR.

THANKS SIR.

NED, I'LL GIVE HER A RELUCTANT.

YES.

ALRIGHT, THANKS SIR.

ONTO THE IPM.

MS. RASHMI? YES.

THANK YOU JEREMY.

YES, THANK YOU.

THANK YOU.

IAN? YES, THANK YOU.

YOU KEVIN? YES, THANK YOU.

THANK YOU.

ONTO THE IRES BILL.

NO, THANK YOU JENNIFER.

NO, THANK YOU.

CHRISTOPHER J? NO THANK YOU CHRIS.

NO THANK YOU.

ONTO THE IOUS.

STACEY FOR KEITH? YES, THANK YOU DAVID.

YES, THANK YOU COLIN.

YES, THANK YOU RICHARD.

YES, THANK YOU.

ONTO THE MUNIS RUSSELL.

YES, THANK YOU JOSE.

YES, THANK YOU DAVID.

YES, THANK YOU ALICIA.

YES, THANK YOU.

MOTION CARRIES 67% IN FAVOR.

THANK YOU.

COREY, CAN YOU LET THEM KNOW THAT WE'LL EMAIL THEM.

OKAY.

SO FOR NO VOTES WE ARE GOING, ANN WILL EMAIL YOU ON THE, THE REASONS FOR NO VOTES, BUT THOSE ARE NOW INCLUDED AS PART OF THE TECH REPORT.

OKAY.

CHRIS, HOW DO I MEAN FOR THE KIND OF, HOW DO THE IMM COMMENTS GET TO THE BOARD? YOU CAN REFILE THEM TO THE BOARD.

SO THIS TAC REPORT WILL GO TO THE BOARD AND THE IMM CAN FILE COMMENTS AGAIN.

OKAY.

ARE YOU GOOD ANDREW? YOUR CARD UP? NO.

OH, DO YOU HAVE STEVEN'S CARD UP? OKAY.

OKAY, SO WE ARE FINISHED WITH THE PRS REPORT.

DO YOU WANNA TAKE A QUICK BREAK? 10 MINUTES THERE.

LUNCH IS HERE, BUT I WOULD RECOMMEND WE NOT DO LUNCH UNTIL WE ARE READY FOR 2 45.

BUT I'M OPEN TO A 10 MINUTE BREAK IF THAT'S WHAT PEOPLE NEED.

OKAY, LET'S DO, LET'S DO A 10.

I CAN'T STOP YOU FROM EATING BUT , BUT WE'RE GONNA START IN 10 MINUTES.

PLEASE.

PLEASE EAT BRIAN.

UM, 11.

SO WE'LL RESUME AT 1145.

ALRIGHT, IF EVERYBODY CAN TAKE YOUR SEAT.

WE'RE GONNA GET STARTED.

GONNA MOVE BACK TO ITEM SIX ON

[6. Revision Requests Tabled at TAC (Possible Vote)]

THE AGENDA REVISION REQUEST TABLED AT TAC.

[02:05:06]

WE HAVE THREE ITEMS THAT ARE STILL TABLED AT TAC.

IT'S OBDR OH FOUR SIX OBDR OH FIVE ONE AND ER 1 0 5.

I BELIEVE THE TWO O BRR CAN REMAIN TABLED AND NO ACTION IS NEEDED ON THOSE.

AND ON ER 1 0 5, UH, RAINBOW HAS SUBMITTED A REQUEST FOR WITHDRAWAL.

SO I BELIEVE ALL THREE OF THESE CAN, UH, BE ADDRESSED ON THE COMMON BALLOT, CORRECT CORY? THANKS TO THAT.

UH, CORRECT.

OH, THE OBDS WILL STAY TABLED THE WAY THEY ARE, BUT THEN YES, IF NO ONE OBJECTS PICKER, 1 0 5 WOULD TAKE A VOTE FROM TAC TO APPROVE THE WITHDRAWAL.

SINCE IT, SINCE AN ACTION WAS TAKEN AT ROSS, THE SUBMITTER NO LONGER HAS THE LUXURY OF JUST PULLING DOWN AND WITHDRAWING IT.

SO IF TAC IS AMENABLE TO ALLOWING P 1 0 5 TO BE WITHDRAWN, YES, WE WOULD THROW THAT ON THE COMBO BALLOT.

SO ANY DISCUSSION ON P 1 0 5 OR ANY OF THE OTHER ITEMS SUPPORTED GOING ON THE COMBO? OKAY, WE'LL PUT THOSE ON THE COMBO BALLOT.

OKAY, MOVING ON TO THE

[7. RMS Report]

RMS REPORT.

JOHN SCHATZ, I'M HERE FOR THE SAKE OF BREVITY.

UH, LET'S GO AHEAD AND JUST SKIP TO SLIDE NUMBER FOUR PLEASE AND I'LL GET OUTTA Y'ALL'S WAY.

ALRIGHT, SO, UM, TEXAS SET 5.0 IS BEING IMPLEMENTED IN NOVEMBER OF THIS YEAR.

FLIGHT 0 9 2 4 IS THE FLIGHT TEST FOR TEXAS SET 5.0.

EVERY LSE MUST TEST AND CERTIFY FOR TEXAS SET 5.0.

THE APPLICATION DEADLINE IS JULY 3RD.

SIGNUP DEADLINE IS JULY 31ST AND THEN YOU CAN SEE THE, THE DATES FOR TESTING.

IF THERE'S ANY QUESTIONS, UH, CERTAINLY CONTACT YOUR ERCOT ACCOUNT MANAGER.

AND WE ARE IN THE PROCESS OF PLANNING A BASICALLY A MARKET INFORMATION SESSION, UH, REGARDING HOW TO REGISTER, UH, FOR, FOR FLIGHT TESTING, HOW TO USE FLIGHT TRACK.

A LOT OF ENTITIES HAVEN'T TESTED WITH ERCOT PROBABLY SINCE 4.0.

UM, SO THIS MAY BE NEW TO A LOT OF PEOPLE.

SO, UH, MORE COMMUNICATIONS WILL BE COMING.

UH, IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS, UH, YOU KNOW, SPEAK UP NOW OR JUST, UH, EMAIL ME OR DEBBIE MCKEEVER WOULD CERTAINLY, UH, ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS YOU MAY HAVE.

THAT'S IT FOR THE RMS UPDATE.

ANY QUESTIONS FOR JOHN? OKAY, THANK YOU JOHN, FOR THE BRIEF UPDATE.

GONNA MOVE

[8. ROS Report (Vote)]

ON TO AGENDA ITEM EIGHT ROS REPORT.

KATIE, BELIEVE YOU WAS SEAN, THAT WAS, THAT WAS QUICK.

I'M NOT SURE I CAN BEAT THAT AND I'M TAKING MY SEAT, BUT I'M GONNA NOTE WHY I'M TAKING MY SEAT BECAUSE I'M GONNA LET COREY STAY IN THE SPOTLIGHT 'CAUSE I THINK HE DESERVES IT AFTER RUNNING ALL THOSE BALLOTS.

SO WE APPRECIATE YOU.

THANK YOU, THANK YOU.

I DUNNO WHAT THE LAUGH WAS FOR BRIAN, YOU CAN TELL ME LATER.

BUT, UM, SO WE'VE GOT TWO, UM, RSS HERE THAT ARE ASSOCIATED WITH NPR 1198.

WE TRIED TO DO THESE AS A COMBO BALLOT AT ROSS, BUT THERE WERE DIFFERENT FOLKS ABSTAINING ON THESE.

UM, WE ALREADY TALKED ABOUT 1198, SO I'M NOT SURE I NEED TO GO THROUGH THESE.

UM, AND THEN WE CAN TAKE THAT VOTE UP IN JUST A SECOND.

ALRIGHT, SO LET'S TALK ABOUT SOME RECENT ROCK, ROCK ROSS ACTIONS, IF I CAN SPEAK TODAY.

SO, PRS FORMALLY REFERRED 1221 OVER TO US.

WE'D ALREADY REFERRED THAT TO OWG AND THEY'D HAD ONE DISCUSSION.

WE'VE NOW HAD, UM, TWO DISCUSSIONS ON THESE ITEMS. I BELIEVE ENCORE FILED SOME COMMENTS AND THEN, UM, WE HAVE NOER 2 63.

THAT ONE'S OVER AT, UH, P-D-C-W-G, AND THEN 1006.

UM, THE IMPORTANCE OF THIS ONE, THIS ONE'S BEEN OUT HERE QUITE A WHILE, UM, BUT THERE IT WAS RECOMMENDED APPROVAL.

SO WE WILL BRING THESE BACK FOR, UM, WELL, THE NOER AND THE PIGGER WILL BRING THAT BACK FOR, FOR IA REVIEW.

AND THEN, UM, SO AS WE USUALLY DO EACH MONTH, WE, WE NOTE SOME OF THE REVISION REQUESTS THAT ARE STILL WITH US AND WHERE THOSE ARE CURRENTLY BEING DISCUSSED, SO PEOPLE KNOW WHERE TO, UM, CHIME IN.

SECOND PAGE IS JUST MORE OF THE SAME.

OUR LIST IS GETTING SHORTER IF YOU WANNA NOTE THAT.

AND THEN OUR NEXT MEETING, UM, IS IN PERSON ON JUNE 6TH.

SO PLEASE SHOW UP, PLEASE, UM, HELP US MOVE QUICKLY THROUGH THAT AGENDA.

UM, I DID GET NOTED FOR, I THINK I SET A RECORD FOR COMPLETING

[02:10:01]

ROSS IN ABOUT AN HOUR AND 15 MINUTES.

NOT SAYING THAT I DON'T ALLOW PEOPLE TO MAKE COMMENTS, BUT WE WERE TRYING TO MAKE SURE NOBODY MISSED THE PUC HEARING.

AND WITH THAT, UM, I THINK WE'RE READY TO, UH, FIGURE OUT HOW WE WANT TO PROCEED WITH PICKER ONE 13 AND NO, 2 58.

THANK YOU, KATIE.

I THINK THE EARLIER STANDALONE BALLOT ON NPRR 1198 INCLUDED THOSE TWO ITEMS. UH, SO IF THERE'S NOT ANY OTHER DISCUSSION OR QUESTIONS FOR KATIE, WE'LL MOVE ON TO

[9. WMS Report]

THE NEXT ITEM.

OKAY.

AGENDA ITEM NINE.

UH, WMS REPORT, ERIC? OKAY.

GOOD MORNING TACK.

ERIC BLAKEY WITH PERELLIS CO-OP CHAIR OF WMS, UH, HOPE TO BE BRIEF.

WE HAD A WEBEX ONLY MEETING ON MAY THE FIRST.

WE HAD A COUPLE OF ERCOT ITEMS UPDATES ON, UH, SETTLEMENT STABILITY REPORT AND THE ANNUAL UNREGISTERED DG REPORT HAD AN UPDATE ON FIRM FUEL SUPPLY AND WANTED TO RAISE JUST THIS ONE.

UH, WE HAVE ONE TAX ASSIGNMENT, WHICH I'M VERY PROUD OF.

WE STARTED WITH 15, UH, JIM AND I WHEN WE CAME ON BOARD, AND WE'RE DOWN TO ONE, SO I DON'T WANT TO JINX IT BY ANY MEANS.

BUT I DO WANT TO JUST RAISE THIS TO THE TAX ATTENTION THAT WE ARE AWARE THAT WE HAVE THIS ASSIGNMENT AND THAT, UH, IT HAS TO DO WITH REVIEW, IT IMPACTS OF EXISTING AND PROPOSED EPA REGULATIONS.

UH, WE'RE, WE'RE AWARE THAT THERE'S BEEN A RECENT EPA, UH, RULING, UH, RULE MAKING THAT HAS COME OUT.

AND I KNOW THERE'S SEVERAL THAT HAVE, UH, IN FACT, THE STATE OF TEXAS HAS FILED AN APPEAL TO THAT.

UH, WE'RE, WE'RE WATCHING THAT.

UH, WE WILL DO ANYTHING THAT TAC DIRECTS US TO DO.

IF YOU'D LIKE US TO, TO DO ANYTHING MORE, UH, PLEASE LET US KNOW.

YOU CAN CONTACT US OFFLINE.

WE'LL BE HAPPY TO, UH, TO FOLLOW THE DIRECTIONS OF, OF TAC ON THIS ISSUE.

NEXT SLIDE.

THESE ARE, ARE TABLED, UH, REQUEST AND STATUS.

UH, AN UPDATE ON 11.

CAN'T READ MY WRITING.

1190 IS THE, UH, HIGH DISPATCH LIMIT OVERRIDE PROVISION FOR INCREASED NO A LOAD COST.

AND THAT WAS ENDORSED AND SENT TO PRS AND NPR 1216.

UH, IMPLEMENTATION OF EMERGENCY PRICING WAS ENDORSED, UH, WITH THE ERCOT COMMENTS AND VCMR OH THREE NINE, UH, RELATED TO THE EMERGENCY PRICING WAS RECOMMENDED FOR APPROVAL.

AND THEN JUST A QUICK UPDATE.

WE'D VOTED TO APPROVE, UH, SOME NEW CO-CHAIRS, UH, AND A CHAIR OF DSWG.

JUST WANTED TO PROVIDE AN, UH, UPDATED LIST OF OUR CURRENT WORKING GROUP LEADERSHIP.

WE'RE VERY PROUD TO HAVE ALL THESE SPOTS FILLED AGAIN, UH, WITH VERY GOOD LEADERSHIP, AND WE'RE VERY THANKFUL FOR THEM FOR, FOR THEIR INVOLVEMENT.

SO I THINK THAT'S IT.

WE HAVE OUR NEXT MEETING ON JUNE THE FIFTH, AND YOU'RE WELCOME TO ATTEND AND BE HAPPY TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS.

ANY QUESTIONS FOR ERIC? OKAY.

THANK YOU, ERIC.

MOVE ON

[10. Large Flexible Load Task Force (LFLTF) Report]

TO AGENDA ITEM 10, LARGE FLEXIBLE LOAD TASK FORCE REPORT.

UH, DO WE HAVE BILL BLEVINS ONLINE? YEAH, THIS IS BILL.

UM, JUST A, A REAL QUICK UPDATE.

SO, UH, AT THE LAST TASK FORCE, UH, WE COVERED, UH, SOME CHANGES THAT WE'RE MAKING TO, UH, THE ORIGINAL PROPOSED RULES.

UM, AT A HIGH LEVEL, THE JUNE 3RD MEETING, WE'RE TARGETING TRYING TO SHOW THE LANGUAGE, UH, WITH THE ADJUSTMENTS, UH, IN MORE DETAIL.

AND I THINK THAT WE'LL BE FOCUSED ON THAT.

HOPEFULLY WE CAN GET THOSE RULES MOVING FORWARD.

UH, NOW THAT WE'VE KIND OF, UH, ADDRESSED SOME OF THE MORE CONFRONTATIONAL ITEMS, SO WE'RE HOPEFUL THAT WE CAN GET THIS LANGUAGE OUT, GET IT REVIEWED, AND GET IT START, STARTED MOVING THROUGH THE STAKEHOLDER PROCESS.

THAT'LL BE THE SCOPE OF THE NEXT MEETING.

OKAY, THANK YOU, BILL.

ANYBODY HAVE ANY QUESTIONS FOR BILL ON THE L-F-L-T-F REPORT? OKAY, UH, AGENDA ITEM

[11. RTC+B Task Force Report (Vote)]

11, RTC PLUS B TASK FORCE REPORT.

MATT, GO AHEAD.

GOOD AFTERNOON, TACK, UH, ABOUT FIVE OR 10 MINUTES.

I DO HAVE ONE ENDORSEMENT REQUEST AT THE END OF THE PRESENTATION.

SO ONE THING I WANTED

[02:15:01]

TO SHARE IS A PERSPECTIVE OF WHERE WE'RE AT IN THE, THE PROCESS OF IMPLEMENTING RTC PLUS B.

UH, AS YOU'VE SEEN MANY OF YOU MAY HAVE SEEN, UH, AT THE BOARD MEETINGS, WE'RE STARTING TO PRESENT SCHEDULES.

NOW, WE DON'T HAVE THE FINAL SCHEDULE AT THIS POINT, BUT WE ARE STARTING TO TRIANGULATE INTO WHAT DOES IT MEAN TO GET THIS SEQUENCE DEVELOPED.

AND SO JP HASS BEEN PROVIDING THIS TO THE BOARD, UH, TECHNOLOGY AND SECURITY GROUP.

AND THE KEY PIECE HERE IS DOWN AT THE BOTTOM, YOU SEE THE DEVELOP AND PUBLISH EXTERNAL SPECS, WHICH ERCOT IS IN THE PROCESS OF DOING AND HAVING WORKSHOPS ABOUT.

AND THEN WE'RE PIVOTING INTO THE MARKET PARTICIPANT SYSTEM UPDATES AND ULTIMATELY MARKET TRIALS.

THE QUESTION MARK HAS BEEN, WHEN DO MARKET TRIALS START AND WHAT DOES THAT LOOK LIKE? AND SO WE DON'T HAVE A DATE, BUT WHAT WE ARE TRACKING TOWARDS IS THAT MAY, 2025, YOU'LL SEE THE FIVE SLASH 25 THAT, UH, OUR VENDOR HAS COME IN WITH A FEBRUARY MARCH DELIVERY DATE.

SO OUR LAST DROP OF CODE IS IN EARLY 2025, WHICH MEANS WE COULD BE POSITIONED FOR MARKET TRIALS AS EARLY AS MAY.

SO IF YOU LOOK AT MARKET TRIALS BEGINNING IN MAY, WHAT DOES THAT LOOK LIKE? HOW DO WE UNFOLD THAT? AND THIS IS KIND OF FIRST CUT AT WHAT WE BELIEVE THE SEQUENCE LOOKS LIKE.

UM, THE FIRST PIECE IS CONNECTIVITY, KIND OF LIKE MOAT TESTING THAT YOU DO.

WHEN WE WENT LIVE WITH ECRS, IT WAS CONNECT, CAN I SUBMIT FOR THIS NEW AS, UM, PRODUCT.

AND SO WE HAVE A TWO MONTH SHAKEOUT ON MARKET SUBMISSION ITEMS. BUT IN PARALLEL TO THAT IS ALSO NEW TELEMETRY POINTS.

UH, THE WAY RTC HAS BEEN DESIGNED, UH, IS IT'S ALMOST GONNA BE AN OVERLAY OF TELEMETRY TO WHERE INSTEAD OF FOLLOWING AN UPDATED SET, YOU'RE GONNA, INSTEAD OF AN UPDATED DESIRED BASE POINT, YOU'LL NOW FOLLOW A SET POINT THAT INCLUDES THE REGULATION SIGNAL.

SO WE'RE TALKING ABOUT WHAT IT LOOKS LIKE TO CO-MINGLE THOSE TELEMETRIES TOGETHER AND BE ABLE TO PROGRESS THROUGH A SERIES OF TESTS OVER A FOUR TO FIVE MONTH PERIOD, AND ULTIMATELY GET TO THE TWO MONTH LOAD FREQUENCY CONTROL TEST WHERE WE'D BE RUNNING SC IN OUR CONTROL ROOM AND THE QUES IN THEIR CONTROL ROOM.

AND THEN FOLLOWING TELEMETRY SIGNALS FOR YOUR FLEET TO FOLLOW THE REGULATION SIGNALS, UH, TO ENSURE THAT WE HAVE A STABLE, UM, TUNE SYSTEM FOR GO LIVE FOR RTC.

UH, AND THEN PARALLEL TO THAT, WE'LL HAVE A COUPLE OF DAY HEAD MARKETS JUST TO, YOU KNOW, SHAKE OUT HOW THE REWARDS LOOK AND WITH THE AS DEMAND CURVES IN THAT ULTIMATELY LEADING TO A GO LIVE.

AND SO, AGAIN, WE'LL DO PROBABLY WHAT WE DID FOR NOTAL BEFORE THAT WORKED WELL, WHICH WAS KIND OF A ONE MONTH BEFORE RING THE BELL 30 DAY NOTICE.

THIS IS WHEN WE'RE GONNA GO LIVE AT MIDNIGHT ON DATE X, AND THEN THAT WOULD BE THE CUTOVER.

SO JUST WANTED TO START THIS CONVERSATION.

SO THIS IS EARLY ON AT R-T-C-B-T-F, BUT WE'RE JUST STARTING TO PEEL AWAY THE DETAILS OF WHAT THAT MIGHT LOOK LIKE SO THE MARKET PARTICIPANTS CAN BE READY.

UH, IN TERMS OF WHY I NEED TODAY IS, AGAIN, WE'RE WORKING THROUGH THE ISSUES LIST.

THESE ARE THE IMPLEMENTATION ISSUES THAT WE NEED TO TACKLE, UH, AND GET THROUGH.

SO THE THINGS THAT WE'VE MOVED UP A LITTLE EARLIER TO THE LEFT ARE SHADED AND BLUE.

THAT WAS THE IDEA OF SOME OF THESE MARKET TRIALS DISCUSSIONS.

UH, AND THEN THE NICE PART IS SOMETHING WENT GREEN ON THIS.

AND SO AS WE BUILD MOMENTUM AND START TO DEAL WITH THREE OR FOUR THINGS AT A TIME, WE'LL GO GREEN.

BUT THAT R CAPACITY SHORT IS WHAT WAS APPROVED AT THE LAST TAC.

AND FOR THIS TAC MEETING, WE WANTED TO TALK ABOUT THE VERIFIABLE COST, MANUAL CHANGE.

AND, UM, WHAT I DID DO, THIS IS SILLY, BUT IT HELPS ME, THIS SPREADSHEET NOW HAS A COMPLETED TASK, UH, WORKSHEET BEHIND IT.

SO THAT WAY WE'LL ALWAYS HAVE A LOG OF WHAT'S TO DO, HOW DID WE RESOLVE IT, WHAT'S THE NEXT STEP TO GET IT OUT OF THE WAY? SO THIS IS KIND OF A ALL IN ONE SHOP FOR THAT.

IN TERMS OF THE PRIOR MEETING, UH, THE ONE THAT WE'RE GONNA TEE UP FOR THE VOTE IS THIS, UH, ISSUE FOR THERE IS THE ONLINE HYDRO RESOURCES.

UH, YOU KNOW, TODAY THEY'RE PROTECTED BY A HASSLE AND RTC, THE IDEA OF YOU DON'T HAVE A HASSLE THAT'S PROTECTING IT.

AND IT'S OPEN TO THE ENERGY OFFER CURVE.

AND THE CO-OP OPTIMIZATION OF AS THIS WAS PICKED UP EARLY ON BACK IN TPT, I'M SORRY, WOO, BACK IN RT.

THE RT, WOW, THERE'S A HARD BLANK.

R-T-C-T-F, THANK YOU TOO MANY, UH, ACRONYMS. AND SO THE, THE STACK PICKED UP ON IT AND SAID, WHAT'S GONNA HAPPEN IF WE'RE SITTING ON A DAM? WE'VE BEEN AWARDED RESPONSIVE RESERVE AND SCED PRICES HIT A POINT WHERE THE MITIGATED OFFER CAP STARTS TO KICK IN FOR THOSE, UH, UNITS.

THEY'D START DRAINING THE WATER OUT UNCONTROLLABLY.

AND SO THE IDEA WAS LET'S GET THIS MITIGATED OFFER CAP SET TO A HIGHER LEVEL.

SO IT'S REALLY THE QUEASY THAT'S SETTING THOSE OFFER PRICES ON ENERGY WITH AS AND CO-OP OPTIMIZATION SO THAT IT'S NOT DISPATCHING IN A WAY THAT WASN'T DESIGNED.

AND SO THE PROPOSAL THAT WE HAD, UM, THAT ERCOT BROUGHT FORWARD AND EVERYONE HAS BEEN, UM, UNANIMOUS ON, IS THE IDEA OF SEEKING ENDORSEMENT OF THIS CONCEPT.

SO GIVEN THAT HYDRO RESOURCES OPERATE IN SYNCHRONOUS CONDENSER MOTOR NOT DISPATCHED BY SCED, ERCOT PROPOSES THE MITIGATED OFFER CAP FOR ALL HYDRO RESOURCES TO BE SET TO THE REALTIME SYSTEM-WIDE OFFER CAP.

THIS WILL BE DONE IN A PROTOCOL AND VERIFIABLE COST MANUAL CHANGE BY SETTING THE, UM, O AND M VALUE TO THE MARK MITIGATED OFFER CAP TO THE REALTIME OFFER CAP, AND

[02:20:01]

SETTING THE HEAT RATE TO ZERO.

AND SO FOR THE GROUP, THAT WAS SOMETHING WE WANTED TO SEEK ENDORSEMENT ON TODAY TO SEE IF THE GROUP AGREES WITH THAT, TO THEN MEMORIALIZE IT AND MOVE IT ON WITH THE NPRS AND BOB HILTON.

YEAH, FIRST I'D SEE IS ANYONE HAVE A PROBLEM WITH THIS GOING ON THE COMBO BALLOT? YEAH, THAT WAS THE FIRST THING.

THE SECOND THING IS JUST A QUICK QUESTION FOR YOU.

UH, I'M CURIOUS ON ARE YOU GETTING AN ACCEPTABLE AMOUNT OF INVOLVEMENT IN THE TECHNICAL WORKSHOPS AT THIS POINT, OR IS THERE YES, I'M A LITTLE JEALOUS ACTUALLY.

UH, I THINK THEY HAD, WE'RE CURING I THINK 70 TO 80 ON OURS FOR THE R-T-C-B-T-F ON THOSE, IT'S SOME OF Y'ALL PLUS THE VENDORS AND OTHER IT FOLKS.

SO I'VE SEEN AS HIGH AS 150 ON THOSE.

THAT'S GREAT.

I JUST WANTED TO MAKE SURE OF THAT.

YEAH, SO THESE TWO WORKSHOPS THAT WE HAVE HERE, THOSE ONE TO FOUR, BACK ON APRIL 18TH AND MAY 6TH, UH, WENT ALMOST THE FULL THREE HOURS WITH 150 PEOPLE ONLINE.

GREAT.

THANK YOU.

ALL RIGHT.

SO IF THAT GOES TO THE COMBO BALLOT, I WILL SAY, UH, I'VE BEEN REACHING OUT TO THE NEXT TASK FORCE MEETING IS THE SAME DAY, UM, AS THE TEXAS SENATE, UM, BUSINESS AND COMMERCE COMMITTEE, THEY'LL BE LOOKING AT THE MARKET DESIGN.

SO I WAS GONNA MOVE OUR MEETING OVER TO FRIDAY IS PROBABLY A WEBEX ONLY, SO DIDN'T WANT TO DECOUPLE THOSE.

AND THAT'S IT.

ARE THERE ANY QUESTIONS? LET'S SEE.

BRIAN SAMS. BRIAN SAMS OKAY, BACK TO THE SLIDE WHERE YOU'VE GOT ALL THE, THE KIND OF OPEN ITEMS YOU'VE GOT ISSUE 18, I I, I GUESS I WANNA FLAG THAT THAT'S NOT SOMETHING YOU'RE EXPECTING LIKE TAC TO VOTE ON, RIGHT? UM, YOU'RE, THERE'S JUST DISCUSSION HAPPENING.

I'M STILL UNCLEAR ABOUT HOW UM, OR IF THE RTC CURVES, THE ANCILLARY SERVICE DEMAND CURVES WILL BE REFORMED TO REFLECT ORCO OPERATIONAL PREFERENCES.

YEAH, SO WHAT WAS ASKED AT THE LAST MEETING WAS, AGAIN, WHAT WE'VE BEEN DOING IS WE CARVED THAT OUT IS THE SHAPE OF THE ORDC CURVE IS DEFINITELY A PUC ISSUE.

IF THERE IS A SLICING AND DICING OF THEM, THOSE COULD BE AN NPR, BUT WOULD BE AFTER GO LIVE.

THERE'S THIS SPOT IN THE MIDDLE IS ERCOT IS BEING ASKED FOR MORE ANALYSIS.

AND SO THAT'S WHAT, THAT WOULD BE BROUGHT TO THE NEXT WORKSHOP WITH SOME FEEDBACK FROM OPERATIONS ON WHETHER OR NOT THERE'S ANY ISSUES WITH THE CURVES.

THAT WAS THE SPECIFIC ASK FROM SHAMS AT THE LAST TASK FORCE.

AND THAT I, I'M CONFUSED ABOUT YOUR COMMENT ON AFTER GO LIVE.

I MEAN, IF THEY MADE A, A POLICY CHOICE TO CHANGE THE SHAPE OF THE CURVES THAT COULD BE DONE BEFORE GO LIVE COULD BE DONE BEFORE.

THANK YOU.

SORRY.

THERE'S THOSE TWO ISSUES.

AND I COULD GO BACK TO THE OLD TAX SLIDES THAT SHOWED, THERE'S THE TWO THINGS.

ONE WAS THE SHAPE OF THE RDC CURVE UPON APPROVAL, WE COULD GET IT LIVE IN A MONTH.

OKAY, THANK YOU.

BUT THEN THERE'S THE SLICING OF THE CURVES TO SAY, LET'S COMMINGLE THE AS TO GO FROM RESPONSIVE TO REG AND ECRS AND THEN PUT THEM IN DIFFERENT SLOTS.

JUST GENERALLY, DO YOU HAVE ANY UPDATE ON KIND OF WHERE THAT DISCUSSION IS, IF AT ALL, UM, WITH THE COMMISSION? OH, NO, I DO NOT.

THANK YOU.

OKAY, QS, CLEAR.

APPRECIATE IT.

MATT.

WE'LL GO AHEAD AND PUT THE ENDORSEMENT OF THE ED OFFER CAPS FOR HYDRO FOR RTC ON THE COMBO BALLOT.

OKAY.

[12. Credit Finance Sub Group (CFSG) Report]

NEXT ITEM IS ITEM 12, CREDIT FINANCE SUBGROUP REPORT.

BRENDAN SAGER, CAN YOU HEAR ME BRENDAN HERE? YEAH, WE CAN HEAR YOU.

OKAY, GREAT.

UM, THANK YOU.

SO I GOT A LITTLE BIT OF GROUND COVER TODAY BECAUSE JUST THE TIMING OF THE MEETINGS.

I HAVE TO GO OVER TWO OF OUR MEETINGS.

UH, WE LOOKED AT OPERATIONAL NPRS WITHOUT, UH, CREDIT IMPACTS, UM, LOOKED AT, UH, NPR 1215, WHICH I'LL DISCUSS.

UH, WE'RE STILL LOOKING AT OUR EAL CHANGE REPO PROPOSALS.

THERE WAS, UH, WE FINISHED OUR DISCUSSION ON THE INDEPENDENT AMOUNT POSTING REQUIREMENT.

UM, TALK ABOUT NPR 1215 CLARIFICATIONS TO DAM AND ENERGY ONLY OFFER CALCULATION.

UH, I DID A FORWARD ADJUSTMENT FACTOR HISTORICAL ANALYSIS.

UH, E THREE, THE CONSULTANT GROUP ON THE PCM, UH, CAME AND GAVE A PRESENTATION TO US, UH, OR CUT TREASURY ALSO DISCUSSED, UH, ISSUES AROUND, UH, COLLATERAL HOLDS, WHICH ARE BECOMING, UH, AN INVOICE HOLDS THAT ARE BECOMING A LITTLE BIT MORE FREQUENT, AND THEY'LL TALK MORE TO US ABOUT IT ALONG WITH OUR REGULAR CREDIT EXPOSURE UPDATES.

NEXT SLIDE, PLEASE.

UH, SO IN ON THE INDEPENDENT AMOUNTS, UH, THIS WAS AS A RESULT OF NPR 1165, WHICH IMPLEMENTED APRIL 1ST.

ALL COUNTERPARTIES REQUIRED TO POST IA, UH, ERCOT INFORMED US BACK IN APRIL THAT FOUR COUNTERPARTIES WERE TERMINATED AFTER NOT POSTING OR CHOOSE TO NOT POST.

UH, THE REQUIREMENT FOR CR ONLY IS 500 K MULTI-MARKET 200 K.

UH, RAMSEY CRIPE CAME IN FROM SE ENERGY AND PRESENTED CONCERNS OVER THE ADDED COST OF THIS AND POTENTIAL LIQUIDITY CONSTRAINTS

[02:25:01]

FOR SMALLER MARKET PARTICIPANTS.

AND IT, THIS COULD ALSO REDUCE HEDGING IN THE MARKET.

UH, ERCOT RESPONDED THAT, UM, EXEMPTIONS COULDN'T BE GRANTED FOR LEGAL AND REGULATORY REASONS, AS WELL AS CONCERNS OPERATIONAL CONCERNS AROUND MANAGING SORT OF, UH, ONE-OFFS.

NEXT SLIDE, PLEASE.

UH, SO WE TALKED ABOUT THE NPR 1215 CLARIFICATION, THE DAY AHEAD MARKET DAM ENERGY ONLY OFFER CALCULATION.

THIS, FRANKLY IS JUST A CLERICAL KIND OF CLEANUP OF THE LANGUAGE.

UM, THERE WERE TWO CLARIFICATION EDITS AND THE ABSOLUTE VALUE OF NEGATIVE PRICES USED TO INCREASE THE EXPOSURE WHEN PRICES ARE NEGATIVE.

UH, A REFERENCE TO IN THE PROTOCOL PARAGRAPH REFERENCE WAS RESOLVED IN IT, AND IT INCLUDED THE INCORPORATION OF THE ASBUILT VALUE OF E TWO USED IN THE CALCULATION OF CREDIT EXPOSURE FOR DAM OFFERS.

UH, AND WE VOTED TO ENDORSE THIS AS AMENDED BY ERCOT COMMENTS APRIL 12TH.

NEXT SLIDE.

LEE, HOLD ON A SECOND.

BRENDAN, BOB, DID YOU HAVE A QUESTION ON THIS SLIDE? OUR PREVIOUS ONE AT THE END? OKAY.

UH, OKAY.

UH, FORWARD ADJUSTMENT FACTOR HISTORICAL ANALYSIS.

JUST SO FOR CONTEXT, UM, THE WAY THE COLLATERAL OBLIGATION IS CALCULATED IS INVOICES TIMES A FORWARD ADJUSTMENT FACTOR SUBJECT TO A LOOKBACK.

UH, SO, UH, ERCOT PROVIDED DATA AROUND THE, UH, HISTORICAL DATA ON THE HISTORICAL, OR EXCUSE ME, THE, UH, FORWARD ADJUSTMENT FACTORS FOR RA AND DA.

WE'RE JUST LOOKING AT RA SINCE THEIR, UH, CORRELATION, UH, OR OF COEFFICIENCY.

COEFFICIENCY OF CORRELATION IS 0.87.

UH, THIS, THE RFA IS ALSO MORE PROMINENT IN THE EAL CALCULATION, THAT'S ESTIMATE AGGREGATE LIABILITY, UH, WHICH IS APPLIED TO A REAL TIME INVOICE AMOUNT IN THE LOOKBACK PERIOD.

UM, AND WE TALKED ABOUT FIXING, FIXING THESE AMOUNTS AT MAXIMUM VALUES TO GIVE CERTAINTY AROUND, YOU KNOW, UH, COLLATERAL, UH, POSTINGS, AND THEN MIN VALUES, WHICH KIND OF HAIRCUT THE INVOICE EXPOSURE AND COULD POTENTIALLY POSE SOME CREDIT RISK.

UH, AND THESE ARE STRAIGHTFORWARD OF, OF ALL THE THINGS WE'RE CONSIDERING, THESE ARE PRETTY STRAIGHTFORWARD TO IMPLEMENT IF WE DECIDE TO MOVE AHEAD.

UH, NEXT SLIDE PLEASE.

ACTUALLY, BOB, GO AHEAD.

YEAH, ACTUALLY I, YEAH, IT IS ON THIS PIECE.

I, I WANT TO ASK YOU A QUESTION ON WHAT IF THIS, ONE OF THE THINGS THAT'S BEEN BROUGHT TO, UM, TO MY ATTENTION, AND I'M CURIOUS IF THIS IS PART OF THE REASON THE GROUP IS LOOKING AT THIS, IS WE'RE UNDERSTANDING THAT THERE'S A PRETTY HIGH OVERCOLLATERALIZATION OF LARGE FLEXIBLE LOADS THAT ARE PRICE SENSITIVE AND FROM WHAT THEIR INVOICE HISTORY IS AND WHAT THEIR COLLATERAL IS, THERE'S A BIG GAP IN THERE.

WOULD THIS HELP TAKE CARE OF THAT PROBLEM? UH, YEAH.

SO, UM, THAT IS, WE'RE LOOKING AT THIS KIND OF TWO WAYS.

ONE, THE, THE MAIN THING WE WANT TO PREVENT IS UNDER COLLATERALIZATION.

THAT IS WHEN RIGHT INSTANCES WHERE THE AGGREGATE INVOICE AMOUNT IS NOT SUPPORTED BY THE APPROPRIATE AMOUNT OF COLLATERAL.

THE OTHER PART WE'RE LOOKING AT IS OVERCOLLATERALIZATION.

UM, AND, UH, I'LL, I'LL GET INTO THAT A LITTLE BIT, UH, FURTHER IN THIS PRESENTATION.

BUT, UM, YES, THAT IS A HIGH PRIORITY AND, AND WE'RE LOOKING AT THAT.

OKAY.

ALRIGHT.

THANK YOU BRENDAN.

YEP.

UH, NEXT SLIDE PLEASE.

OKAY.

SO THIS IS JUST SOME OF THE HIGHLIGHTS OF THE DATA OF THE FORWARD ADJUSTMENT FACTOR SUMMARY AND JUST, AND BASICALLY THE WAY THIS WORKS IS YOU HAVE THREE WEEKS OF FORWARD PRICES AT ERCOT NORTH HUB OVER, THERE'S A RATIO OF THAT TO A RATIO OF, I THINK, TWO WEEKS OF, UH, ERCOT NORTH HUB SETTLEMENT PRICES.

SO BASICALLY, YOU KNOW, IF THE FORWARDS ARE HIGHER, IT'S GONNA BE GREATER THAN ONE IF THEY'RE LOWER, AND IT'S GONNA BE LESS THAN ONE.

SO YOU CAN SEE, UM, IN GENERAL, UH, THE FORWARD ADJUSTMENT FACTOR IS UNDER TWO 90% OF THE TIME, 2.5 95% OF THE TIME, 3 2 5 97 POINT OF THE TIME.

AND 5 2 5 90 9% OF THE TIME, THE HIGHEST WAS DURING URI OF 10.61, AND THE LOWEST WAS, UM, 0.1.

AND WE LOOKED AT, AND THERE'S A 2200 VALUES THAT WE'VE LOOKED AT.

UM, SO HERE YOU CAN KIND OF SEE WHERE IT SETTLES OUT.

SO MOST OF THE TIME, BASICALLY YOU'RE LOOKING AT YOUR INVOICE EXPOSURE, BUT WHEN FORWARDS POP, UM, YOU CAN GET A, UH, YOU KNOW, A VERY HIGH COLLATERAL REQUIREMENT THAT IS BEYOND YOUR INVOICE AMOUNT.

AND THEN GIVEN THE MAX FUNCTION IN THE LOOKBACK, IT THAT GO WILL GO AGAINST, YOU KNOW, 40 DAYS OF INVOICE HISTORY.

UH, NEXT SLIDE PLEASE.

OKAY.

UM, SO THIS IS PROBABLY, WE, WE, WE HAVEN'T COME TO ANY CONCLUSIONS ON THIS, BUT, UM, WE WE'RE, AGAIN, LOOKING AT A MAX VALUE 'CAUSE IT WAS BROUGHT UP SEVERAL TIMES THAT, YOU KNOW, IF WE,

[02:30:01]

IF WE IMPOSE A MAXIMUM VALUE, UM, THEN THAT WILL JUST GIVE MORE CERTAINTY AROUND WHAT'S THE WORST CASE THAT ANY ORGANIZATION WOULD HAVE TO POST TO THE MARKET.

UM, AND WE ALSO CONSIDERED, UM, LUCK MAKING THE MINIMUM AMOUNT OF THE FAF AT ONE, UH, TO JUST BASICALLY REFLECT, WE DON'T WANT TO CUT, UM, INVOICE EXPOSURE.

HOWEVER, WE WOULD ONLY DO THAT IF WE CHANGE THE LOOKBACK VALUE.

SO IF WE DON'T CHANGE THE LOOKBACK, WE'LL JUST LEAVE IT ALONE AS FAR AS THAT GOES.

AND, UH, AND, AND AGAIN, YOU KNOW, THESE WOULD BE PRETTY STRAIGHTFORWARD IMPLEMENTATIONS VERSUS, YOU KNOW, MORE, UH, FULSOME CHANGES TO THE, UH, ALGORITHM THAT WE'RE LOOKING AT.

AND WE'LL LOOK AT NOW.

NEXT SLIDE, PLEASE.

OH, UH, YEAH, THAT'S RIGHT.

AND PCM STOPPED BY, UM, I OR E THREE, FOLLOWED BY ON THEIR, UH, PERFORMANCE COLLATERAL, UH, MANAGEMENT, UM, PRESENTATION THAT THEY GAVE APRIL 17TH TO THE ERCOT STAKEHOLDER WORKSHOP.

SO, UH, BACKGROUND ON THIS IS, UH, POST YURI SENATE BILL THREE PASSED A BOLSTER FINANCIAL, UH, STABILITY ON THE GRID IN JANUARY, 2023.

PUC PROPOSED A NOVEL PERFORMANCE CREDIT MECHANISM, OR PCM.

THE PCM CONSTRUCT WOULD PROVIDE ADDITIONAL REVENUE STREAM TO GENERATORS THAT COMMIT IN ADVANCE TO BEING AVAILABLE TO PROVIDE POWER DURING HOURS OF HIGHEST RELI RELIABILITY RISK.

UH, AND HB 1500 ADDED ADDITIONAL GUARDRAILS SUCH THAT THE COST OF THE PCM CANNOT EXCEED $1 BILLION A YEAR.

NEXT SLIDE, PLEASE.

CAN WE PAUSE THERE? I JUST HAD A YES, ABSOLUTELY.

SORRY, GO AHEAD, ERIC.

UM, HEY, I JUST WANNA, SINCE YOU MENTIONED A GUARDRAIL IN PARTICULAR, I DON'T WANNA BREAK OUT INTO A PCM WORKSHOP IN THIS TAX MEETING, BUT I THINK THERE'S ALSO A SPECIFIC CREDIT GUARDRAIL AROUND, UM, SECURED COLLATERAL THAT ENSURES AGAINST NON-PERFORMANCE AND NON-PAYMENT.

AND IF Y'ALL ARE GONNA BE TALKING ABOUT ANY GUARDRAIL, I'D LIKE TO MAKE SURE THAT'S THE ONE YOU TALK ABOUT OF, OF, OF NON NON-PAYMENT.

YEAH, THERE'S A GUARDRAIL THAT SAYS, UM, THAT OTHER PARTICIPANTS ARE PROTECTED AGAINST NON-PERFORMANCE OR NON-PAYMENT, WHICH I THINK IS THE, THE, THE COLLATERAL GUARDRAIL.

I JUST WANNA MAKE SURE, SINCE YOU MENTIONED A GUARDRAIL, THAT THAT ONE'S ON YOUR LIST.

OKAY.

YEAH, I'LL, UH, I'LL, I'LL REACH OUT TO YOU AFTER THIS AND YOU CAN, WE CAN DIG IN A LITTLE BIT ON THAT, UH, OR FEEL FREE TO COME TO THE MEETING AND SHARE YOUR THOUGHTS.

UM, IAN, THANK YOU.

UM, YES, ERIC, THAT WAS DISCUSSED ERCOT LEGAL, MADE SURE AS WE WERE, AS THE GROUP WAS DISCUSSING HOW THIS COULD BE, UM, REDUCED, ELIMINATED, ET CETERA.

UM, THAT WAS BROUGHT UP BY ERCOT LEGAL.

AND SO THE, THE GROUP IS TRYING TO FIGURE OUT HOW BEST TO MOVE FORWARD.

UM, I DO WANNA SAY, UM, AS A TAC MEMBER TO THIS GROUP, THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR, UM, DIVING INTO THIS.

I HAD ASKED THEM TO, UM, AND REALLY APPRECIATE ALL THE LIGHT THEY'VE SHED ON, UM, THIS PART OF IT THAT I THINK WAS OVERLOOKED BY A LOT OF US, INCLUDING MYSELF.

YEAH.

THANK YOU.

I APPRECIATE IT.

IT IS OUR PLEASURE.

NEXT SLIDE, PLEASE.

OKAY.

SO THE E THREE'S PROPOSAL IS SUBSTANTIALLY DIFFERENT FROM, UH, HOW WE DO THIS NOW.

UM, TO CALCULATE COLLATERAL OBLIGATIONS, THEY'RE STRUCTURED AS PREPAYMENTS OF FUTURE COSTS WITH PROPOSED SETTLEMENTS AND TRUE UP AT DIFFERENT POINTS IN TIME.

COLLATERAL OBLIGATION IS EXPECTED PERFORMANCE CREDIT, PRICE TIMES THE EXPECTED REQUIREMENT MINUS THE FORWARD MARKET PROCUREMENT.

UM, YOU KNOW, AND, AND YOU COULD SEE THESE DETAILS, IT'S, IT'S A LOT OF, UM, EXTRAPOLATED VALUES, EXPECTED VALUES, WHERE THE WAY WE DO THINGS NOW IS WITH INVOICES BASICALLY, AND AGGREGATING THE INVOICES AND BUILD AND UNBUILD AMOUNTS.

UM, SO DURING YURI COLLATERAL POSTED TO ERCOT ROSE TO NEARLY 20 BILLION FROM A MORE TYPICAL THREE TO 4 BILLION, AND SOME ARE 2023, IT WAS AROUND EIGHT TO 10.

UH, AND KEEP IN MIND, YOU KNOW, THAT'S WHEN THE OFFER CAP, UH, DECLINED, YOU KNOW, AFTER URI AND BEFORE THE SUMMER OF 2023.

UH, SO THERE'S SOME UNCERTAINTY AROUND CONFLICTS BETWEEN HB 1500 GUARDRAIL, COST CAPS, AND THE CURRENT MESSAGE, WHICH FAR EXCEED THAT.

UM, AND WE ALSO VOICE CONCERNS ABOUT WHAT I DISCUSSED USING THEIR ALGORITHMIC APPROACH VERSUS, YOU KNOW, ACTUAL INVOICES AND, AND REAL DATA.

UM, SO THAT IS THAT, UH, NEXT SLIDE PLEASE.

SO, SWINGING BACK TO THE EAL CHANGES IN ANALYSIS, UM, THIS IS, AGAIN, THIS ESTIMATE AGGREGATE LIABILITY THAT, UH, IS A NUMBER THAT CALCULATES IT, UM, TENDS TO, UH, LEAD TO A COLLATERAL POSTING REQUIREMENT.

UH, MEMBERS, WE, THE WAY WE, IT'S DAY AHEAD IN REAL

[02:35:01]

TIME EXPOSURES ARE LOOKED AT SEPARATELY, AND THERE'S SOME DISCUSSION ABOUT MAYBE COMBINING THESE, UM, AS ONE IS KIND OF A, POTENTIALLY A HEDGE FOR ANOTHER.

UH, WE'RE LOOKING, AGAIN, WE'RE EVALUATING THE LOOK BACK PERIOD, WHETHER IT'S MAYBE TOO LONG, UM, THAT THAT LOOKBACK PERIOD TO THE QUESTIONER'S EARLIER POINT IS REALLY, I THINK, SUBSTANTIALLY DRIVES THE OVERCOLLATERALIZATION VERSUS, UM, THE FORWARD ADJUSTMENT FACTOR.

BUT THE FORWARD ADJUSTMENT FACTORS ALSO CAN, AND THEY'RE DESIGNED TO DO THIS, YOU KNOW, AS PRICES RISE TO LEAD TO A SUDDEN, UH, UH, COLLATERAL REQUIREMENT.

SO WE'LL CONTINUE TO LOOK AT THESE.

AND THE ERCOT CREDIT TEAM TO THEIR, UH, IMMENSE CREDIT, UM, HAS DONE A LOT OF WORK AROUND THIS.

THEY'VE BASICALLY, YOU KNOW, TAKEN THESE ALGORITHMS AND JUST RERUN, UM, THE CREDIT ENGINES TO, UH, ACCOMMODATE THIS ANALYSIS GOING BACK FOR QUITE A PERIOD OF TIME.

NEXT SLIDE, PLEASE.

UM, OKAY.

SO THIS IS OUR SCENARIO FOR THIS, I THINK IS THE LAST ONE THAT WE'VE, THAT WE'RE LOOKING AT, GOING BACK, I DON'T KNOW, AT LEAST SIX MONTHS.

UM, SO THE KEY TO LATER ITERATIONS INCLUDES THE NETTING OF DAY AHEAD IN REAL TIME, WHERE A FAF MULTIPLIER IS APPLIED TO THE MAX VALUE AT THE LOOKBACK PERIOD CALCULATION INCLUDES UNBUILD LIABILITY LAST 14 DAYS, REALTIME STATEMENT AVERAGE PLUS LAST 14 DAYS, DAY AHEAD, UH, INITIAL STATEMENT BASED ON REALTIME INITIAL OPERATING DAY TIMES THE M TWO FACTOR.

AND THIS SCENARIO ACTUALLY RESULTED IN THE HIGHEST COLLATERAL REQUIREMENT OF ALL PREVIOUS SCENARIOS.

SO, UM, MAYBE NEXT TIME I'LL KIND OF SUM IT ALL UP, BUT WE'RE PROBABLY NOT TOO KEEN ON, UH, INCREASING THE COST TO THE MARKET.

UM, SO WE'LL CONTINUE TO LOOK AT THIS AND, UH, YOU KNOW, I'LL COME BACK AND REPORT, UM, NEXT SLIDE, PLEASE.

UH, THE, UH, YEAH, WE CAN GO TO THE NEXT SLIDE.

I KIND OF COVERED THAT.

OKAY.

UH, THE NPRS I'M NOT GONNA READ ALL THESE.

THESE WERE ALL, UM, CONSIDERED OPERATIONAL WITHOUT ANY CREDIT IMPACTS.

NEXT SLIDE PLEASE.

SO, THE MONTHLY HIGHLIGHTS FROM MARCH TO APRIL INCREASED TPE INCREASE FROM 1.37 BILLION TO 1.52 IN FROM MARCH TO APRIL.

THIS WAS DUE TO HIGHER FORWARD ADJUSTMENT FACTORS AND REAL TIME DATA AHEAD PRICES, UH, UH, WE'RE LOOKING AT DISCRETIONARY COLLATERAL, WHICH IS THE EXCESS COLLATERAL PEOPLE POST, UM, OVER THEIR REQUIREMENTS.

UH, AND IT IS REQUIRED TO GET ACCESS TO THE, UH, DAY AHEAD MARKET.

SO AVERAGE DECRE DISCRETIONARY COLLATERAL DECREASED FROM 4.43 BILLION IN MARCH 24 TO FOUR POINT 10 BILLION IN APRIL 24.

AND AS I NOTED BEFORE, FOUR COUNTERPARTIES DEFAULTED FOR NOT POSTING THE INDEPENDENT AMOUNT.

THEY DID NOT HAVE ANY ACTIVITY IN THE MARKET AND DIDN'T WANNA POST.

NEXT SLIDE, PLEASE.

SO THIS IS, YOU KNOW, KIND OF REFLECTING THE SEASONAL PATTERN, UM, UH, OF THE INDIVIDUAL COLLATERAL TYPES.

UNSECURED CREDIT IS NO LONGER A FACTOR IN THE MARKET AFTER OCTOBER.

UM, MOST OF THIS IS LETTERS OF CREDIT AND SOME CASH AND, UH, SMALL AMOUNTS OF SURETY BONDS.

UM, NEXT SLIDE, PLEASE.

UH, THIS IS HOW THAT, WHAT I JUST, JUST DESCRIBED LOOKS IN A PICTURE.

SO, YOU KNOW, THE ACTUAL REQUIREMENT IS THE DARK BLUE, GRAY AND PURPLE, AND THE, UH, COLLATERAL POSTED IN EXCESS OF THE REQUIREMENT IS THE LIGHT BLUE.

SO, AND AGAIN, YOU NEED AT LEAST SOME OF THAT TO GET ACCESS TO THE DAY AHEAD.

NEXT SLIDE, PLEASE.

UH, WE HAD DISCUSSED, UM, EARLIER ERCOT RAISED THE, UH, TOTAL AMOUNTS PER ISSUER, THE, THE CREDIT LIMITS BASICALLY FOR, UH, LETTERS OF CREDIT.

'CAUSE WE WERE RUNNING INTO A LOT OF, UH, OVERAGES AND, UH, SO I THINK THERE WERE, I THINK LIKE A, MAYBE A DOZEN AT ITS PEAK, AND NOW IT'S JUST ONE WITH LLOYD'S, BUT OTHERS ARE GETTING CLOSER.

NEXT SLIDE, PLEASE.

I THINK THAT'S THE END.

YES.

ANY QUESTIONS, BRENDAN, MAYBE NOT TO COVER RIGHT NOW, BUT I, I'D LIKE TO GET A BETTER UNDERSTANDING OF THE PCM DISCUSSIONS THAT ARE HAPPENING AT, AT THAT GROUP.

AND, AND MAYBE I MISSED A TAC DIRECTION OR, OR ASK THERE, BUT I, I THINK FOR THE FUTURE IT WOULD BE GOOD IF WE KNEW AT TAC WHAT WAS HAPPENING THERE REGARDING PCM DISCUSSIONS.

YEAH, IAN KIND OF, UH, HASTILY SENT OUT AN EMAIL TO US ALL TO LET US KNOW THAT THAT WORKSHOP HAPPENED.

AND, YOU KNOW, THEY'RE TALKING ABOUT, YOU KNOW, 12 TO $20 BILLION.

AND SO YEAH, THERE'S, THERE'S A LOT OF DIGGING IN WE'RE GONNA HAVE TO DO ON THAT.

AND, UH, E THREE AND OR CO LEADERSHIP HAS BEEN VERY HELPFUL, UM, IN, UH, HELPING US OUT.

SO WE'LL DEFINITELY HAVE MORE ON THAT FOR NEXT TIME.

UH, AUSTIN, I THINK IAN WANTED TO DIRECTLY RESPOND TO, TO THAT TOPIC, SO WE MIGHT LET HIM GO FIRST.

BRENDAN, UH, OKAY, GO AHEAD.

UM,

[02:40:01]

NO, I, I REALLY APPRECIATE THE GROUP TAKING THAT ON AND, UM, HAVING AS IN DEPTH AND AS WELL ATTENDED DISCUSSIONS FROM E THREE AND AIRCRAFT AS THEY HAVE, UH, AFTER A PCM WORKSHOP, UH, I WAS QUITE SURPRISED THAT THE AMOUNT OF COLLATERAL BEING DISCUSSED WAS BEING DISCUSSED, UM, SO NONCHALANTLY AND HAD CONCERNS THAT IF THIS WASN'T WELL UNDERSTOOD BY OUR SMES AND CREDIT, THAT IT COULD DERAIL ALL OF PCM AT A LATER DATE AFTER A LOT OF WORK WAS PUT IN.

SO I HAD IMMEDIATELY EMAILED, UH, THE LEADERSHIP ASKING THEM TO DISCUSS IT IN HOPES THAT EVERYONE COULD GET A BETTER UNDERSTANDING OF THIS, AND THEN THAT COULD INFORM ANY COMMENTS THEY HAD TO THE COMMISSION.

UM, SO IT WAS MORE OF JUST A REQUEST THAT THEY, THEY DISCUSS IT OPEN, GET A LITTLE LIGHT ON EVERYTHING, SO EVERYONE HAD A BETTER CHANCE TO, UH, IDENTIFY ISSUES THAT THEY SAW NEEDED TO BE IDENTIFIED IN THEIR COMMENTS TO THE COMMISSION.

OKAY.

I THINK, YEAH, ONE, ONE THING I WOULD ADD TO THAT TOO IS LIKE, JUST BASED THE WAY THE METHODOLOGY WORKS, AND I DON'T WANT TO SPEAK FOR IT AS AN EXPERT OR, UM, NECESSARILY REFLECTING THE NOTIONS OF THE GROUP, BUT THEY'RE BASICALLY GONNA HAVE PEOPLE PREPAY.

UM, YOU KNOW, AND THEN, THEN IT'S GONNA BE TRUED UP OVER SOME DIFFERENT PERIODS OF TIME.

SO, YOU KNOW, THE CURRENT SYSTEM HAS ITS DISADVANTAGES, BUT ITS ADVANTAGE IS YOUR COLLATERAL POSTINGS FOLLOW YOUR ECONOMIC ACTIVITY VERSUS HERE THEY'RE GONNA HAVE SOME KIND OF ESTIMATE, WHICH, YOU KNOW, I HAVE NO IDEA HOW THEY'RE GONNA DO THAT.

AND THEN YOU'RE GONNA TRUE, UH, WHICH MAY NOT BE AT A TIME WHERE YOU'RE GETTING PAID FOR EVERYTHING THAT YOU'RE DOING.

UM, SO YEAH, THAT, THAT'S MY BIG CONCERN.

OKAY.

I THINK THAT MAKES SENSE.

IT MIGHT BE GOOD TO FIGURE OUT A WAY, UM, YOU KNOW, I, I KNOW THAT'S A REALLY HIGH IMPORTANCE TOPIC, SO THERE MIGHT BE MORE PEOPLE INTERESTED IN THAT PARTICULAR DISCUSSION THAN WHO REGULARLY GOES TO THE CREDIT FINANCE SUBGROUP.

SO I, I THINK IT WOULD BE, YOU KNOW, I, I TOTALLY UNDERSTAND AND APPRECIATE THAT DIRECTION AND DISCUSSION, BUT I, I THINK IT MIGHT BE GOOD IF IN THE FUTURE WE COULD LET TAC MAYBE KNOW, SO, SO PEOPLE COULD ATTEND THOSE DISCUSSIONS AND, AND HAVE THEIR INTERNAL SUBJECT MATTER EXPERTS ATTEND AS WELL.

YEAH, NO, DEFINITELY WE ENCOURAGE PEOPLE TO ATTEND AND WE'LL, WE'LL BE TALKING ABOUT IT CERTAINLY NEXT TIME.

OKAY.

AUSTIN.

YEAH, SO I SEE MATT IS AFTER ME, SO HOPEFULLY I'M NOT STEALING TOO MUCH OF HIS THUNDER.

HOPEFULLY HE DOESN'T COME IN AND JUST CORRECT EVERYTHING I SAY.

BUT I POSTED, I PASTED THE, UH, WHAT MATT BROUGHT UP, UM, WHAT ERIC WAS TALKING ABOUT, ABOUT THE, UH, GUARDRAIL, UM, THAT WAS ADDED TO, TO PIRA.

I PASTED IT IN THE CHAT IF THAT'S HELPFUL, THAT GUARDRAIL.

UM, AS FAR AS I KNOW, WE DON'T HAVE A GUARDRAIL LIKE THAT FOR OUR CURRENT COLLATERAL PRACTICES, SO THAT'S SOMETHING WE'RE LOOKING AT AND THINKING ABOUT HOW THAT, UM, COULD REQUIRE POSSIBLY MORE STRINGENT, UH, COLLATERAL REQUIREMENTS THAN WHAT WE DO TODAY.

SO I JUST WANTED TO MENTION THAT TO YOU ALL, 'CAUSE I KNOW YOU'RE GETTING COMMENTS AND, AND STUFF TOGETHER.

UM, AND ALSO I KNOW THE NEXT HAPPY TO KEEP DISCUSSING THIS, BUT I KNOW THE NEXT, UH, CREDIT FINANCE SUBGROUP MEETING IS LIKE THE DAY BEFORE, UH, ANSWERS ARE DUE TO THE PUC.

UM, SO YEAH, AND I ACTUALLY KIND OF FLOATED TRYING TO GET SOMETHING , YOU KNOW, GET SOMETHING VOTED OUT OF OUR GROUP THAT, YOU KNOW, WE DON'T LOVE THIS IDEA, BUT, UM, UH, THE GROUP DECIDED NOT TO DO THAT.

I, I THINK MAYBE VOTES, YOU KNOW, I DON'T WANNA SPEAK OUT ATTORNEY THERE, BUT I THINK WE SHOULD MAYBE WAIT ON POLICY DECISIONS ON THIS UN UNTIL WE HAVE MORE INFORMATION FROM THE, THE COMMISSION.

WELL, BUT THAT, LIKE, LIKE HE WAS SAYING, IT WAS JUST DRIVEN BY, THIS IS GOING BEFORE THE PC, LIKE, YOU KNOW, BEFORE WE'LL HAVE A CHANCE TO DO ANYTHING WITH IT, YOU KNOW, SO JUST WANTED TO MEMORIALIZE SOME OF OUR CONCERNS IN SOME WAY.

BUT PS POC ACTUALLY WAS THERE AT THE MEETING, SO, UM, THEY DEFINITELY HAVE HEARD THE DISCUSSION AND, AND, UH, SO THAT'S WORTH, CAN I WEIGH IN ON THIS? IT PLEASE DO IT.

I'M, UH, PRETTY NERVOUS ABOUT THIS GROUP, POTENTIALLY FRONT RUNNING THE COMMENT PROCESS AT THE COMMISSION.

YEAH, ME, ME TOO.

OKAY.

I, I THINK IT'S INDIVIDUAL STAKEHOLDERS WILL COMMENT AT THE COMMISSION.

SO I, I, YOU KNOW, I, I THINK THAT WOULD BE UP TO MEMBERS OF THIS GROUP, BUT IT SEEMS LIKE THAT WOULD BE A TRICKY BALANCE TO HAVE MEMBERS OF THIS GROUP VOTE ON THINGS AND THEN THEIR INDIVIDUAL COMPANIES BE TRYING TO IN, YOU KNOW, STILL ADVOCATE ON THEIR OWN POSITIONS.

GO, SORRY, GO AHEAD, ERIC.

YEAH, I, I APPRECIATE THAT.

I, I AGREE.

I, I DON'T KNOW THAT,

[02:45:01]

UM, WELL, LET ME SAY THIS A DIFFERENT WAY.

WHILE IT'S UP TO THE COMMISSION TO INTERPRET AND ENFORCE THIS GUARDRAIL HB 1500, UM, WE HAVE TO, YOU KNOW, FOLLOW, YOU KNOW, THE MEANING OF THESE WORDS.

AND SO I APPRECIATE THAT AUSTIN PASTED THEM INTO THE, INTO THE, UH, CHAT.

AND, UM, IF IT ENDS UP DRIVING, YOU KNOW, MORE COLLATERAL THAN WE HAVE IN OUR EXISTING MARKET, UM, THEN THAT'S SOMETHING THAT THE COMMISSION WILL HAVE TO CONSIDER, YOU KNOW, AND MAKING DETERMINATIONS AROUND THE PCM.

BUT, UM, WE HAVE TO FOLLOW WHATEVER THE INTERPRETATION OF THE LAW IS AND NOT, AND NOT, NOT DO THAT.

OKAY.

MAYOR A, DID YOU WANNA WEIGH IN? UM, I WAS MOSTLY JUST GONNA ADD THAT WE APPRECIATE THE DISCUSSION AT CFSG, AND I THINK THAT THAT WAS INTENDED AS, UM, EDUC AN EDUCATIONAL OPPORTUNITY TO LEARN ABOUT HOW THE VARIOUS OPTIONS FOR, UM, THE PCMS COLLATERAL MECHANISM ARE, UM, BEING CONSIDERED.

BUT YEAH, DEFINITELY I THINK THAT THE ANTICIPATION IS, IS THAT, UH, ANY STAKEHOLDERS WHO HAVE THOUGHTS ABOUT WHICH OPTIONS SHOULD BE DONE OR, OR THE RAMIFICATIONS OF ANY OF THOSE OPTIONS WOULD BE HEAVILY ENCOURAGED TO FILE COMMENTS WITH THE PUBLIC UTILITY COMMISSION IN PROJECT 5 5 0 0 0, WHICH THE COMMISSION'S GOING TO CONSIDER STAFF'S QUESTIONS FOR COMMENT AT TOMORROW'S OPEN MEETING.

AND ASSUMING, ASSUMING THAT THE COMMISSION ADOPTS THOSE QUESTIONS FOR COMMENT RESPONSES WOULD BE DUE ON JUNE THE 20TH.

AND I THINK THAT IT'S QUESTION NUMBER NINE THAT ASKS ABOUT THE COLLATERAL DESIGN.

UM, SO YEAH, WE JUST, UH, ENCOURAGE FOLKS TO, UH, FILE THEIR COMMENTS THERE.

OKAY.

I, I DON'T KNOW TO WHAT EXTENT WE COULD INFORM THE AGENDA, BUT IS THAT SORT OF A REQUEST TO MAYBE NOT FORM AN OPINION WHILE WE HAVE PENDING COMMENTS AT THE, AT THIS, UH, CFSG? SO, YEAH, WE, WE DIDN'T TAKE ANY ACTION OR ANYTHING.

WE JUST, UH, HAD A PRESENTATION AND A DISCUSSION, SO WE'RE NOT REALLY CONTEMPLATING DOING ANYTHING RIGHT NOW.

I JUST THREW IT OUT THERE.

IT'S A, OKAY.

THANKS BRENDAN.

THANK YOU.

OKAY, WE ARE ONTO

[13. ERCOT Reports]

OUR ERCOT REPORTS.

UM, THE, THE FIRST ONE IS PROPOSED REVISIONS TO BOARD POLICIES AND PROCEDURES.

WE'VE HAD THIS HERE A COUPLE OF TIMES.

IS THIS KIM OR JOHN PRESENTING? I SEE KIM COMING TO THE FRONT.

THANK YOU.

GOOD AFTERNOON.

THIS IS KIM RAINWATER FOR ERCOT LEGAL.

SO VARIOUS UPDATES ARE PROPOSED TO THE BOARD POLICIES AND PROCEDURES DOCUMENT, AND AT THE APRIL TAC MEETING, WE GATHERED FEEDBACK ON REDLINE, SPECIFICALLY REGARDING THE BOARD'S PROCESS TO REVIEW REVISION, UH, TO CONSIDER REVISION REQUESTS.

TAC ENDORSEMENT ISN'T REQUIRED, BUT TAC ASKED THAT WE COME BACK AFTER APPLYING SOME FEEDBACK.

SO THE NEXT SLIDE THAT WE HAVE KIND OF GIVES GIVES SOME INSIGHT INTO HOW WE APPLIED FEEDBACK THAT WE HEARD AT THE TAC MEETING.

AND SUBSEQUENT TO THAT, SO IN THE FIRST COLUMN, YOU SEE THAT THE SECTIONS THAT WE REVISED AND 1.3 THERE WAS FEEDBACK, LUMINANT AND TEAK, ESSENTIALLY WANTING TO CLARIFY THAT THERE'S NOT A POLICY OF DISCRETIONARY EXCLUSION OF COMMENTS AT PUBLIC MEETINGS OF THE BOARD OR BOARD COMMITTEES.

SO WE CAN LOOK AT THOSE RED LINES AND YOU'LL SEE THAT WRITTEN OR IN-PERSON COMMENTS, UM, ARE PERMITTED.

AND THESE RED LINES REALLY INTEGRATE POLICIES THAT ARE ALREADY IN EFFECT AND MEMORIALIZES THEM.

SO WE HAVE A SHARED EXPECTATIONS ABOUT THE BOARD'S PROCESSES.

UM, IN SECTION 1.3 0.1, YOU'LL SEE SOME FEEDBACK THAT BAKER BOTS GAVE FOR EOAN ANTIQUE, RECOGNIZING THAT WRITTEN COM COMMENTS CAN ALWAYS BE SUBMITTED TO THE BOARD IN SECTION 8.3, THERE WAS REFERENCE TO THE BOARD, UM, HAVING THE ABILITY TO DISCOUNT

[02:50:02]

COMMENTS THAT ARE OUT OF TIME OR PRESENT NEW OR CHANGED INFORMATION THAN WHAT WAS PRESENTED TO TAC FOR THE TAC VOTE.

AND SO WE REFLECTED ON RELIANCE COMMENTS AND REMOVED THE OUT OF TIME LANGUAGE CONSIDERING THESE REQUESTS ARE MOVING FORWARD.

AFTER THE BOARD, THEY DO GO TO THE COMMISSION.

SO WE JUST STRUCK THAT LANGUAGE REGARDING 8.4 AND 8.5.

UH, ANJI AND JUPITER POWER DID WANT SOME TYPE OF RECOGNITION THAT THE RELIABILITY AND MARKETS COMMITTEE WAS FORMED TO FACILITATE, UM, CERTAIN ENTITIES PERSPECTIVES BEING CONVEYED TO THE BOARD, AND AT THE SAME TIME WANTING TO RECOGNIZE THERE ARE OTHER, OTHER PARTIES.

UH, SO WE ADOPTED SOME LANGUAGE SUCH AS FROM THE TEXAS ADMINISTRATIVE CODE, WHICH IS INTERESTED PARTIES.

CAITLIN, DID YOU WANNA PAUSE HERE? YEAH, SO I, I DON'T KNOW WHERE THIS IS GOING, BUT THAT JUST DOES NOT ACCURATELY REFLECT WHAT MY CONCERN WAS.

I, I BELIEVE WE RESOLVED IT, BUT IF THIS IS GOING SOMEWHERE SAYING THAT WAS JUPITER POWER'S CONCERN, THAT THAT WASN'T A, THAT'S NOT AN ACCURATE REPRESENTATION.

OKAY.

I, I MEAN, I, I FIGURED THERE MIGHT BE SOME TAKING ISSUE WITH THIS IS THE, THE SUMMARY THAT I HAVE BASED ON THE NOTES THAT I TOOK DURING THE MEETING.

BUT WHEN WE LOOK AT THE RED LINES, YOU'LL SEE THOSE NAMED PARTIES.

AND I THINK THAT IN OUR FOLLOW UP FOLLOW UP CONVERSATIONS, YOU WERE SPECIFICALLY TALKING ABOUT ENTITIES LIKE ERCOT, IMM, BASICALLY SECTION 21 ENTITIES.

UM, SOME OF THOSE ENTITIES ARE ALSO NAMED IN THE TEXAS ADMINISTRATIVE CODE.

SO WHEN WE GO TO THE RED LINES, UM, WE COULD FURTHER CONSIDER IF IT, IF IT IMPLEMENTS WHAT YOU ARE CONVEYING.

SO MY CONCERN HAD BEEN THAT FOR NON ERCOT ENTITIES, FOR, FOR A MARKET PARTICIPANT, WE ARE REMOVING THE ABILITY TO THE EQUIVALENT OF AN APPEAL, BUT HAVE, YOU KNOW, A, A, I FORGOT WHAT THE WORD IS NOW, BUT, BUT TO HAVE AN OPPOSITION TO A UP VOTE.

AND WE BROUGHT UP THE OTHER PARTIES LIKE ERCOT IN THE IMM IN THAT CONTEXT, BECAUSE THEY SEEM TO HAVE AND HAVE OTHER SECTIONS IN LANGUAGE WHERE THEY HAVE ABILITY TO PUT THINGS ON THE, THE BOARD AGENDA.

AND SO THE, THE ISSUE THERE WAS REALLY STAKEHOLDERS MAKING SURE THAT WE'RE PRESERVING THE RIGHT TO HAVE THE EQUIVALENT OF WHAT'S NOW THE OPPOSITION TO A YES VOTE.

OKAY.

UH, I HEAR WHAT YOU'RE SAYING.

I THINK THAT REGARDS, AS YOU CAN SEE, THE, THE NEXT LINE ALSO HAS 8.4 AND 8.5 LISTED.

AND SO THE SENTIMENT THAT YOU'RE EXPRESSING, I THINK IS MORE ON THAT LINE.

AND THAT WAS THE CONCERN.

AND, AND, UM, YOU KNOW, IT SHOULD SAY JUPITER POWER UNDER BAKER BOTTS FOR EO.

AND BASED ON THE FEEDBACK YOU'RE GIVING RIGHT NOW, UM, A CONCERN THAT THE BOARD IS PROVIDED WITH ALL THE NECESSARY INFORMATION TO MAKE A REASONABLE DETERMINATION ON REVISION REQUEST AND CREATE AN ADEQUATE RECORD, SHOULD THERE BE A LATER APPEAL TO THE COMMISSIONER COURT.

SO THERE IS A, UM, PROCESS CALLED ATTACK RECOMMENDATION OPPOSITION.

IT APPLIES TO THINGS THAT ARE NOT REVISION REQUESTS FOR ATTACK RECOMMENDATION IS REQUIRED, AND THEN SOMEBODY WANTS TO OPPOSE THAT THEY FILE COMMENTS TO THAT EFFECT FOR REVISION REQUESTS.

WHAT WE'RE DOING IS, UH, MEMORIALIZING IN TWO NEW SECTIONS DEVOTED SPECIFICALLY TO REVISION REQUESTS.

SO WE'RE ADDING MORE PROCESS, UM, NOT SO MUCH TAKING AWAY, UM, WE'RE NOT CALLING IT ATTACK RECOMMENDATION OPPOSITION, BUT WE'RE ADDING 8.4 AND 8.5, WHICH ALLOWS A FORMAL PROCESS FOR WRITTEN COMMENTS AND IN-PERSON COMMENTS.

AND IN ADDITION, AS YOU'RE AWARE, UH, STAKEHOLDER SERVICES PREPARES A BOARD REPORT FOLLOWING THE BOARD'S DECISION, WHICH HAS THE REVISION REQUEST, LA LANGUAGE SUMMARIES OF ALL THE STAKEHOLDER DISCUSSIONS.

UM, IT HAS COMMENTS FILED BEFORE ATTACK, AND THEN ON TOP OF THAT, YOU WOULD HAVE THE MINUTES OF THE MEETING REGARDING IN-PERSON COMMENTS, AND THEN YOU WOULD HAVE ANY COMMENTS THAT WERE FILED TO THE BOARD.

SO ADDING THESE NEW PROVISIONS, I THINK DOES ADDRESS, UH, THE CONCERN FOR AMPLE RECORD.

AND THEN IN THE APPENDIX B, WE DID ADD, UM, WE FURTHER IDENTIFIED SOME REGULATIONS, UH, MADE MORE CLEAR REFERENCES TO P 39, 1 51, UH, G SIX, UH, 1 5 1, 1 B.

AND THEN, UH, AS I MENTIONED, THE TEXAS ADMINISTRATIVE CODE OR PUCT SUBSTANTIVE RULES

[02:55:01]

25 360 2, C ONE AND TWO.

SO WE CAN TAKE A LOOK AT THE RED LINES.

THE BEST WAY TO SCROLL THROUGH THESE, JUST KIND OF, OKAY, SO I WANNA FOCUS ON WHAT WE FOCUSED ON LAST, LAST TIME WAS, UM, SECTION ONE AND SECTION EIGHT.

THERE ARE SOME OTHER RED LINES THAT DON'T REGARD THE REVISION REQUEST PROCESS, AND THOSE ARE AVAILABLE IN THE MEETING MATERIALS.

UM, PROVISION 1.2, JUST REGARDS, UM, ACCESS TO PUBLIC PORTIONS OF THE MEETING.

IT FOLLOWS THE PROCESS THAT'S CURRENTLY IN PLACE.

AND SECTION 1.3, THIS, THIS MAIN PORTION AT THE TOP HERE IS JUST DESCRIBING THAT, UH, THE AGENDAS FOR BOARD MEETINGS INCLUDE INSTRUCTIONS FOR PUBLIC COMMENTS AND 1.3 0.1, UH, THIS IS THE LANGUAGE THAT WE ADDED.

SPECIFYING COMMENTS IN WRITING CAN ALWAYS BE SUBMITTED.

1.3 0.2 TWO'S CLARIFYING THAT WHEN WE DO HAVE PUBLIC COMMENTS, UM, AS IS ALREADY THE CASE, THE BOARD CHAIR OR THE COMMITTEE CHAIR CAN ALLOCATE THAT TIME, UM, AS NEEDED FOR THE OPERATION OF THE MEETING.

AND 1.3 0.3, CLARIFYING THAT FOR URGENT MEETINGS CONDUCTED VIA TELECONFERENCE, UH, COMMENTS MAY BE REQUIRED TO BE IN WRITING AND, UM, OR URGENT MEETINGS ARE ALREADY DEFINED IN THE, UH, ERCOT BYLAWS.

LET ME SEE IF I CAN MAKE THIS A LITTLE FASTER INSTEAD OF SCROLLING.

OKAY.

NEW SECTION EIGHT 8.2 JUST MEMORIALIZES THE CURRENT PROCESS FOR THE CONSENT.

CONSENT AGENDA.

MOST REVISION REQUESTS FALL THERE MOST ARE UNANIMOUSLY RECOMMENDED BY TAC IN 8.3.

THIS IS THE PROCESS YOU HAVE SEEN A LOT AT THE R AND M COMMITTEE, UM, SINCE ITS FORMATION, ESPECIALLY LAST YEAR SO FAR THIS YEAR, APPLYING LESSONS LEARNED.

AND IN THIS PROCESS, UH, THE BOARD COMMITTEE CAN, UH, SHARE A REPORT WITH THE BOARD ABOUT THE DELIBERATIONS, CONVEY THE COMMITTEE'S RECOMMENDATION ON THE REVISION REQUEST, UH, FOLLOWED BY ANY ADDED TIME ALLOCATED BY THE BOARD CHAIR, VICE CHAIR, UM, ALLOCATED EQUALLY BY POSITION.

SO YOU MAY HAVE SEEN THAT WITH NORE 2 45 AT THE BOARD.

UM, ERCOT SPOKE TAC, I THINK THE TAC CHAIR, TAC REPRESENTATIVE SPOKE, ERCOT SPOKE, AND THEN WE HAD SEVERAL COMMENTERS WHO SPOKE CAITLIN.

SURE.

UM, SO THERE, THAT WAS A SET OF JOINT COMMENTERS.

IF YOU HAD TWO PARTIES THAT, YOU KNOW, HAD THE SAME VOTING POSITION, MM-HMM, , BUT SLIGHTLY DIFFERENT, YOU KNOW, DIFFERENT REASONING AND DIFFERENT POSITIONING, WOULD THAT BE AGGREGATED AS WELL? OR COULD IT BE AGGREGATED AS WELL? UH, THIS, THE LANGUAGE, YOU KNOW, BASED ON ALL THE FEEDBACK THAT WE GOT WAS TIME MAYBE AGGREGATED FOR MULTIPLE PARTIES FOR A POSITION.

SO, YOU KNOW, THE TIME, IF TWO ENTITIES HAD A DIFFERENT POSITION, THEN THE TIME WOULD BE, THAT WOULD AFFECT THE ALLOCATION.

NOT THAT IT WOULDN'T BE EQUAL, BUT THEY MIGHT NOT BE LUMPED TOGETHER.

AND SO, UM, THAT THAT'S THE DISCRETION OF THE BOARD.

THEY'RE GONNA HAVE TO ANALYZE THE NUANCE OF THAT SITUATION.

BUT I DO THINK THAT AS YOU SAW WITH NOGA 2 45, 45 AT THE BOARD LAST TIME, MOST OF THE COMMENTERS WERE IN LINE AND THEY SHARED THAT TIME.

IT WOULD BE DIFFERENT IF PERHAPS THERE WAS DISTINCTION THERE.

OKAY.

SO WE'RE NOT DEFINING POSITION HERE AS THE SAME VOTE ON A RR RIGHT, TO BE, SO LIKE ON, ON 1224, IF NED HAD VOTED NO BECAUSE THE FLOOR WASN'T HIGH ENOUGH AND THAT CONSUMER HAD VOTED NO BECAUSE IT WAS TOO HIGH, THAT TIME WOULDN'T BE AGGREGATED.

UH, IT'S LEFT AS POSITION THERE.

I THINK THAT, YOU KNOW, WE CAN ANTICIPATE THE, THE BOARD CHAIR, VICE CHAIR WILL TAKE A REASONABLE APPROACH TO THAT AND, YOU KNOW, WANT TO HEAR IF THERE'S A DISTINCTION.

UM, OKAY, SO, UH, IN 8.4, THIS IS GETTING TO THE,

[03:00:01]

OKAY, 8.8 0.4, AND 8.5 IS GETTING TO THE NAMED PARTIES VERSUS INTERESTED PARTIES.

SO 8.4 REGARDS, UH, WRITTEN COMMENTS.

AND IT BASICALLY TAKES FROM SECTION 21 AND THE ADMINISTRATIVE CODE, CERTAIN ENTITIES, UM, ABOUT THREE OF THESE ENTITIES ARE IN THE ADMINISTRATIVE CODE, THINK ERCOT, IMM AND RELIABILITY MONITOR, MONITOR.

BUT WE'VE ALSO NAMED OTHER ENTITIES THAT ARE IN SECTION 21.

WE'VE LISTED THEM, UM, AS THEY ARE LISTED IN SECTION NINE, UM, REGARDING OTHER MATTERS, AND BASICALLY MEMORIALIZE THE PROCESS THAT EXISTS TODAY WHERE IF ONE OF THOSE ENTITIES WANTS TO SUBMIT WRITTEN COMMENTS, THEY SUBMIT THEM TO REVISION REQUESTS@ERCOT.COM.

IF THERE'S ANOTHER INTERESTED PARTY SUCH AS THE PUBLIC, THEY WANNA SUBMIT COMMENTS, THEY GO BACK TO THE WHAT, UH, THE INSTRUCTIONS ON THE AGENDA, WHICH IS DESCRIBED IN 1.3 0.1.

ERIC, JUST OUTTA CURIOSITY, AND I, I DON'T NECESSARILY NEED THE ANSWER TODAY, BUT, UM, WOULD, HOW, HOW WOULD ERCOT IDENTIFY ITSELF AS THE RELIABILITY MONITOR AND COMMENTS? I KNOW THE RELIABILITY MONITORS CALLED OUT, BUT I'M JUST CURIOUS IS, IS THERE A PROCESS IN PLACE FOR THAT? OR, AND IF THERE'S NOT, THAT'S OKAY FOR, FOR ERCOT TO SUBMIT COMMENTS SINCE FOR THE RELIABILITY MONITOR TO SUBMIT COMMENTS SINCE ERCOT, I THINK IS THE RELIABILITY MONITOR.

UM, ERIC, THIS IS CHAD.

YEAH, WE WOULD JUST SUBMIT COMMENTS SAYING THAT THE, THOSE INDIVIDUALS THAT ARE DESIGNATED AS RELIABILITY MONITOR EMPLOYEES ARE SUBMITTING THOSE COMMENTS ON BEHALF OF THE RELIABILITY MONITOR.

THAT MAKES SENSE.

ALL RIGHT.

8.5, THIS IS THE IN-PERSON COMMENTS PIECE.

AGAIN, NAMED PARTIES, IT'S A LITTLE BIT SHORTER THERE BECAUSE WE'RE NOT REDEFINING THEM.

UM, THEY CAN COMMENT IN PERSON ON REVISION REQUESTS BY BASICALLY SPEAKING WITH THE SECRETARY OR ASSISTANT SECRETARY.

THAT'S USUALLY HOW IT'S ARRANGED.

AND ANY OTHER INTERESTED PARTY, LIKE THE PUBLIC CAN REFER TO SECTION 1.32 ABOVE THE INSTRUCTIONS WILL BE ON THE AGENDA.

I THINK USUALLY THAT'S SIGNING UP OUTSIDE OF THE BOARD MEETING OR COMMITTEE MEETING.

AND IF WE CA, CAITLIN, CAN I ASK A QUESTION ON EIGHT FOUR? YES, PLEASE DO.

GO AHEAD, CHRIS.

SO ON EIGHT FOUR FOR TRADE ASSOCIATIONS, WOULD THEY BE PUSHED TO 1.3 0.1? I HAVEN'T REFLECTED ON THAT SPECIFICALLY, BUT I THINK YES, THEY'RE, THEY ARE NOT NAMED A TRADE ASSOCIATION WOULD, WOULD FOLLOW THE PROCESS IN 1.3 0.1.

SO YOU WOULD, YOU WOULD GO TO THE AGENDA FOR THE MEETING, YOU WOULD READ THOSE PROVISIONS FOR SUBMITTING COMMENTS AND FOLLOW THAT.

ALRIGHT.

AND THEN THE, I GUESS SIMILAR, I THINK THIS IS A WAY TO READ IT, IS IF YOU'RE A REP BUT, AND A LICENSED REP, BUT YOU'RE NOT A MEMBER OF ERCOT, YOU WOULD THEN ALSO BE 1.3 0.1.

IF YOU'RE NOT A A, A CORPORATE MEMBER, YOU COULD STILL, IF YOU'RE A MARKET PARTICIPANT, AND YOU KNOW, THERE'S A, THERE'S A LIST ON THE ERCOT WEBSITE LIST OF MARKET PARTICIPANTS IN THE ERCOT REGION.

IF YOU FIND YOURSELF ON THERE, YOU WOULD FOLLOW, UM, YEAH, THE, THE FIRST SENTENCE.

AND IF YOU'RE NOWHERE ON, YOU'RE NOT LISTED, MARK COULD PARTICIPANT, YOU'RE NOT A CORPORATE MEMBER.

GO TO 1.1.

ONE MORE QUESTION THERE FOR THE ERCOT MEMBER.

SO IS THERE A DEFINITE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN A CORPORATE MEMBER, AN ASSOCIATE MEMBER, AND A CON COMMERCIAL CONSUMER MEMBER? WE HAVE DIFFERENT TYPES OF MEMBERS, BUT THEY'RE ALL MEMBERS.

GOTCHA.

SO IF WE GO, I THINK NED HAS A QUESTION.

YEAH.

THANKS.

UM, FIR FIRST OF ALL, COMMENT IN GENERAL, UM, THANK YOU KIM FOR, YOU KNOW, TAKING THE, THE COMMENTS BACK AND, AND, AND WORKING ON THIS.

I THINK, UH, BY AND LARGE WHAT I'VE SEEN ADDRESSES MOST OF THE, THE, THE QUESTIONS THAT I'D HAD AT OUR LAST MEETING.

BUT CHRIS, UH, YOUR QUESTION ABOUT A TRADE ASSOCIATION GOT ME, GOT ME THINKING, UM, YOU KNOW, UNDER THIS FRAMEWORK, KIM COULD A, COULD A MEMBER, YOU KNOW, REQUEST TIME OR, YOU KNOW, SUBMIT COMMENTS THROUGH THE 8.4 OR THE 8.3 PROCESS? SORRY, I'M GETTING MY SEGMENTS WRITTEN.

YOU, YOU'RE TALKING ABOUT WRITTEN OR IN PERSON COMMENTS BY TRADE? YEAH.

WRITTEN OR IN PERSON.

MM-HMM.

.

BUT, BUT ESSENTIALLY, YOU KNOW, YIELD TIME OR, OR, YOU KNOW, INCORPORATE THE TRADE ASSOCIATION AS A MATTER OF EFFICIENCY OR AGGREGATING VOICES, YOU KNOW, THE, THE MEMBER CAN CARRY IT, BUT IF THERE'S OTHERS THAT ARE, UH, WANT TO SHOW SUPPORT, THAT MAY BE AN EFFICIENT WAY TO, TO BRIDGE

[03:05:01]

THAT GAP.

SO YOU'RE TALKING ABOUT SPEAKING ON BEHALF OF, OF OTHERS OR, YOU KNOW, REPRESENTING A GROUP.

I THINK WE, WE HAD THAT EVEN LAST TIME, LIKE WITH GER 2 45, I THINK, UM, GOLF POLICY HAD SOME COMMENTS AND THEY SPOKE AND THEY, THEY SAID WHO THEY, UM, WERE ALIGNED WITH.

YEAH.

SO I, I THINK THAT THAT MAY ADDRESS OR MAYBE AN AVENUE, I JUST WANTED TO CONFIRM THAT THAT WAS, UH, THAT WOULD STILL BE AN AVAILABLE VENUE IF WE WANTED TO SAY, GET A TRADE ASSOCIATION'S INPUT.

UM, YES.

I MEAN, IT, IT'S DIFFICULT TO ANTICIPATE EVERY SINGLE SITUATION AND COMBINATION THAT COULD EXIST, BUT I THINK GENERALLY WHAT WE HAVE HERE ALLOWS AN AVENUE FOR ALL, ALL OF THESE ENTITIES TO COMMENT WITH, UM, YOU KNOW, SOME DISCRETION ALLOWED FOR AGGREGATING.

UM, SOMETIMES, YOU KNOW, THE, THE BOARD CHAIR OR VICE CHAIR MAY HAVE A WAY THAT THEY RECOMMEND AGGREGATING AND SOMETIMES THE COMMENTERS, LIKE YOU'RE SAYING, WILL.

YEAH.

AND, AND THE THOUGHT IS THAT IT'S ACTUALLY MORE EFFICIENT TO, YOU KNOW, HAVE MORE FOLKS REPRESENTED BY A SINGLE TRADE GROUP AS OPPOSED TO HAVING, YOU KNOW, LOTS OF FOLKS COME UP AND SAY SIMILAR, BUT, UH, SUBSTANTIVELY THE SAME THING.

SO IT'S A WAY TO SPEAK WITH ONE VOICE AND BE EFFICIENT WITH EVERYONE'S TIME.

SOUNDS REASONABLE.

ARE THERE OTHER COMMENTS ON SECTION EIGHT? WHAT, WHAT REMAINS, UM, REGARDING THE REVISION RE REQUEST PROCESS IS, UM, BASICALLY JUST WE'VE ADDED THIS APPENDIX.

IT'S, IT'S A LITTLE DIFFICULT TO READ ON HERE, BUT IT'S JUST A TABLE.

AND, UM, IT SUMMARIZES ALL THE, THE RED LINES REGARDING REVISION REQUESTS ABOVE, WHICH IS, I'D LIKE TO MAKE THIS A LITTLE BIT, UM, SMALLER.

OKAY.

SO, YOU KNOW, THERE ARE STILL TAC APPEALS.

THAT'S THE FIRST, THE FIRST LINE.

IT KIND OF OUTLINES HOW PAST, UH, COMMITTEE AND BOARD AGENDAS, UM, THE ORDER OF PRESENTATIONS AND LIST AUTHORITIES THAT RELATE TO THAT TOPIC.

UM, REFLECTING THE USE OF CONSENT AGENDAS ABOVE.

THAT'S THE, THE SECOND ROW, THE THIRD ROW REGARDS, UH, WHEN A PARTY, UNNAMED PARTY WANTS TO SPEAK IN PERSON OR SUBMIT COMMENTS, AND THEN THE LAST ROW REPRESENTS WHEN INTERESTED NINE, YOU KNOW, SOMEONE MAY NEED TO MUTE ON THE PHONE.

UM, AND THEN THE LAST ROW WAS WHEN ANY OTHER INTERESTED PERSON WANTS TO COMMENT IN PERSON OR SUBMIT COMMENTS.

AND THESE ARE JUST THE ORDER OF PRESENTATIONS.

THIS IS NON-BINDING.

IT'S JUST A QUICK VISUAL SO THAT WE CAN BE ON THE SAME PAGE ABOUT WHERE WE MAY, WHAT WE MAY SEE ON AN AGENDA ITEM.

SO THERE ARE ANY OTHER QUESTIONS? I DON'T SEE ANY QUESTIONS IN THE QUEUE.

THANK YOU.

I MAKE ONE LAST COMMENT BEFORE WE WRAP UP.

JUST FOR TRANSPARENCY.

I WANTED TO LET, UH, LET IT BE, KNOW THAT THERE ARE SOME OTHER PROVISIONS IN THE BOARD POLICIES AND PROCEDURES THAT WE'RE LOOKING AT AMENDING.

WE'VE TALKED TO THE HR AND G COMMITTEE CHAIR ABOUT IT.

THEY DON'T IMPACT TAC OR MEMBERSHIP.

SO WE, WE DIDN'T BRING THEM HERE, BUT THOSE ARE STILL UNDER DISCUSSION.

SO WHEN WE GET TO THE HR AND G COMMITTEE DISCUSSION OF THE BOARD POLICIES AND PROCEDURES, YOU MAY SEE MORE REDLINING THAN YOU'RE SEEING TODAY, BUT IT'S, IT'S NOT GONNA INVOLVE TACKER MEMBERSHIP.

OKAY.

THANKS.

THANK YOU.

ALL RIGHT.

I THINK PROBABLY WAS UP THE ENCORE WEST TEXAS 3 45 KV INFRASTRUCTURE REBUILD PROJECT.

THIS IS A VOTING ITEM.

YEAH.

GOOD AFTERNOON, .

SO I'M HERE TO PRESENT THE ENCORE WEST TEXAS 3 45 KB INFRASTRUCTURE REBUILD PROJECT, UH, THAT WAS SUBMITTED TO RPG IN NOVEMBER OF THIS YEAR OR LAST YEAR.

SO THIS IS AN OVERVIEW OF THE PROJECT.

UM, THIS IS A TIER ONE PROJECT WITH A TOTAL ESTIMATED COST OF ONE POINT, UH, ONE $2 BILLION.

AND, UH, THIS IS PRIMARILY TO ADDRESS THE THERMAL OVERLOAD ISSUES AND LOAD GROWTH ISSUES IN SEVERAL COUNTIES IN THE WESTERN FOREST.

UM, JUST TO GIVE YOU A BACKGROUND, THIS PROJECT WAS, OR, OR ALL THE ASPECTS OF, YOU KNOW, SUBMITTED IN THIS PROJECT WAS IDENTIFIED AS PREFERRED PROJECTS.

UH, WITH THIS IDS HERE, 1, 2, 3, AND 25, IF YOU GO LOOK BACK AT THE, UH, 2021 PERMIAN BASIN

[03:10:01]

LOAD STUDY THAT WAS COMPLETED BASED ON THE, UH, S AND P FORECAST AND OTHER FORECAST FOR THE LOAD GROWTH PER PARTICULARLY FOR THE OIL AND NATURAL GAS LOAD FORECAST.

SO THAT STUDY WAS COMPLETED IN, UH, END OF 2021.

AND THIS PROJECT LINES WITH THOSE PROJECT IDENTIFIED THERE.

SO, UH, LITTLE BIT, UM, BACKGROUND TIER ONE PROJECT, FALSE, UH, YEAH, OF A HUNDRED MILLION DOLLARS OR MORE.

THIS WOULD RE, UH, REQUIRE A BOARD ENDORSEMENT.

SO AS PER THE PROTOCOL REQUIREMENTS, WE ARE REQUIRED TO, YOU KNOW, SEEK, UH, TAX COMMENTS AND ANYTHING, UH, YOU WANT TO ADD TO THE BOARD ENDORSEMENT, WE CAN DO THAT.

SO THIS IS THE PROJECT NEED, UH, THAT WAS IDENTIFIED FOR THIS AREA FOR THIS, UH, PROJECT.

UM, IF YOU LOOK AT THE TABLE HERE, IT'S PRIMARILY OVERLOADS, UM, ANYWHERE FROM 58 MILES TO A HUNDRED, ALMOST 200 MILES OF OVERLOAD OF EXISTING 3 45 KB LINES.

SO THAT'S WHAT THIS PROJECT IS TRYING TO ADDRESS.

WHAT WE DID IS, UM, WE LOOKED AT THE PROJECTS IDENTIFIED AND OR SUBMITTED BY ENCORE AND SAW WHETHER IT ALIGNS WITH WHAT WAS PREVIOUSLY IDENTIFIED.

AND, UH, WE CONCLUDED THIS, YES, THE NEEDS STILL EXIST AND THE PROJECTS SUBMITTED BY ENCORE WITH CERTAIN VARIATIONS, ALIGNS WITH WHAT WAS IDENTIFIED IN THE PER PERMANENT STUDY.

SO, OTHER THINGS, AS, AS PART OF THE PROJECT ANALYSIS, WE LOOK AT THE SUB SYNCHRONOUS RESIDENT RESONANCE ISSUE, UM, AND WE CONCLUDED THAT WITH THE ADDITION OF OUR, OF THIS NEW UPGRADES, WE, WE DO NOT SEE ANY ISSUES OR SIGNIFICANT ISSUES WITH THE SSR IMPACT.

AGAIN, UH, ALSO LOOKING AT THE CONGESTION ANALYSIS AND SENSITIVITY ANALYSIS FOR BOTH GENERATION AND LOAD, UH, WE CONCLUDED THAT THE PROPOSED PROJECT DOES NOT HAVE A IMPACT ON EXISTING CONGESTION OR INTRODUCE NEW CONGESTION.

AND ALSO IT DOESN'T AFFECT THE, UH, LOAD SENSITIVITY AND THE GENERATOR SENSITIVITIES THAT WAS, UH, USED IN THE CASE.

SO IN TO CONCLUDE HERE, UM, WE RECOMMEND THE WEST TEXAS INFRASTRUCTURE PROJECT, UH, TO ADDRESS THE NEED BOTH THE RELIABILITY NEED AND THE GROWTH IN OIL AND NATURAL GAS, UH, LOAD IN THE WEST, WESTERN AND FOREST AREA.

UM, I SEE ALREADY A SLIDE THERE.

I'LL JUST UH, CONCLUDE HERE AND GET BACK TO THE QUESTIONS.

SO, UM, OUR RECOMMENDATION TO THE JUNE BOARD WILL BE TO, UH, ENDORSE THIS OR, OR ENDORSE THIS WEST TEXAS INFRASTRUCTURE PROJECT, UH, WITH THE EXPECTED INSERVICE DATE OF, UH, SUMMER OF 2028.

UH, THERE IS A LOT OF NEED FOR COORDINATION OF OUTAGES WITH ERCOT.

UM, SO THE, THE EXPECTED, UH, OR IN-SERVICE DATE IS SUMMER OF 2028.

AND, UH, AGAIN, THE ESTIMATED COST IS $1.12 BILLION.

SO THE NEXT THREE SLIDES, UM, PROVIDES THE DETAILS OF THE PROJECT.

IT'S FAIRLY LENGTHY, SO I'M GONNA SKIP IT.

AND I'M GONNA GO TO THIS LAST SLIDE HERE JUST TO GIVE YOU A HIGH LEVEL OVERVIEW OF WHAT THIS PROJECT IS.

SO WHAT YOU SEE ON THE SCREEN IS THE HIGHLIGHTED PORTION WHERE, UM, WE HIGHLIGHTED THE REBUILT OF EXISTING 3 45 KV LINES AND THE DOTTED LINES ADD A NEW 3 45 KV PATH OR SECOND CIRCUIT, AND WHERE YOU SEE THE STARS OR THE NEW SUBSTATIONS.

UH, SOMETHING TO NOTE RIGHT NEXT TO MORGAN CREEK, THERE ARE NEW, TWO NEW SUBSTATIONS, RANGER CAP AND CATTLEMEN.

ALL THE SUBSTATIONS WILL BE TIED.

AND, UM, ALSO AS PART OF THAT, YOU SEE A COUPLE OF OTHER SUBSTATIONS, PRONG MOSS AND, UH, RIDER SUBSTATIONS.

THOSE ARE NEW SUBSTATIONS THAT 3 45 KIWI SUBSTATIONS.

SO, WITH THAT, I'LL STOP AND SEE IF, UH, THERE ARE ANY QUESTIONS.

GATEWAY.

ERIC GOFF WAS FIRST, I THINK SO.

UM, WE APPRECIATE THE WORK ON THIS PROJECT, UH, NAVARRA AND I WOULD LIKE TO ADD THAT WE THINK ERCOT SHOULD IDENTIFY ECONOMIC ADD-ONS, UH, TO THIS REBUILD PROCESS AND THE RTP DUE IN DECEMBER OF THIS YEAR.

THIS COULD INCLUDE RECONDUCTORING, ADDITIONAL CIRCUITS, DYNAMIC LINE RATING EQUIPMENT, AND OTHER ITEMS WHERE THE INCREMENTAL COST OF THE ADD-ON MIGHT PASS THE ECONOMIC BENEFIT TEST REBUILDING AGING INFRASTRUCTURE AS A PERFECT TIME FOR ERCOT TO STUDY THE INCREMENTAL COSTS OF UPGRADES.

AND ERCOT SHOULD HAVE ENOUGH ADVANCED KNOWLEDGE OF REBUILD PROJECTS TO PLAN AROUND THEM.

SO IF YOU CAN'T DO IT IN, IN THIS RTP IN THE NEXT RTP, WE'VE GOT SOME TIME, BUT WE THINK THIS IS A GREAT OPPORTUNITY TO LOOK FOR ECONOMIC ADD-ONS TO THIS PROJECT, ESPECIALLY GIVEN THE COST.

THANKS.

YEAH, THANK, THANK YOU FOR THE COMMENT, KEVIN HANSON.

YEAH.

UM, JUST QUICK QUESTIONS, CLARITY.

SO THIS PROJECT WAS APPROVED WITH THE OLDER LOAD FORECAST, NOT THE NEW LOAD FORECAST WE'VE BEEN TALKING ABOUT AT OTHER MEETINGS, CORRECT? YEAH.

SO THIS, THIS PROJECT WAS ORIGINALLY STUDIED AS PART OF THE PERMIAN

[03:15:01]

STUDY THAT WAS, THAT WE DID IN 2021.

AND WE IDENTIFIED THE NEED.

SO WHAT WE DID HERE IS USING THE CURRENT MODELS, WE VALIDATED THE NEED OF THE PROJECT.

YES.

SO THIS IS NEEDED BASED ON THE NEW FORECAST TOO? YEAH, THIS ISN'T, SO THIS HAS THE 162 GIGAWATT LOAD FORECAST IMPACTED BY 2030 IN HERE.

NOT, NOT QUITE THE 160 GIGAWATT FORECAST.

THAT'S SOMETHING WE ARE STUDYING NOW, BUT WE INCORPORATED THE ALREADY KNOWN PERMIAN BASIN LOAD FORECAST.

OKAY, GREAT.

THANK YOU.

YEAH, THANK YOU.

IT LOOKS CLEAR.

I SAW A SUGGESTION FROM BOB HILTON TO PUT THIS ON THE COMBO BALLOT.

ARE WE OKAY WITH THAT? YEP.

ALRIGHT, THANK YOU.

THANK YOU.

WE ARE ON TO THE 2023 MAXIMUM DAILY RESOURCE PLANNED OUTAGE CAPACITY, PERFORMANCE, AND METHODOLOGY REVIEW.

THANKS.

HEY, GOOD AFTERNOON.

UM, LUKE BUTLER ERCOT RESOURCE FORECASTING AND ANALYSIS.

UH, SO IF YOU REMEMBER, UH, LAST MONTH, WE, UH, I STOPPED BY AND GAVE A QUICK OVERVIEW OF REALLY JUST THE TIMELINE, UH, THIS'S BASED OFF A REQUIREMENT IN THE M-D-R-P-O-C METHODOLOGY THAT SAYS, EVERY YEAR, LET ME GO TO THE NEXT SLIDE.

UH, ERCOT WILL REVIEW THE CURRENT METHODOLOGY AND THE CALCULATED M-D-R-P-O-C AND REPORT ITS FINDINGS TO TAC AND THE FINDINGS WILL INCLUDE BUT NOT BE LIMITED TO.

AND THESE, THESE TWO BULLET POINTS HERE, WHICH ARE KIND OF BASIC LEVEL FACTS ABOUT M-D-R-P-O-C, SO THE, THE AGGREGATED HOURS OF RESOURCE OUTAGES, INCLUDING PLANNED OUTAGES, MAINTENANCE OUTAGES, AND FOREST OUTAGES IN THE PROCEEDING CALENDAR YEAR.

SO RIGHT NOW WE'RE LOOKING BACK AT CALENDAR YEAR 2023, AND THEN COMPARISON OF THE CALCULATED M-D-R-P-O-C AND THE AGGREGATED HOURS OF THERMAL RESOURCE PLANNED OUTAGES IN THE PROCEEDING CALENDAR YEAR.

SO HOW DID THERMAL OUTAGES ACTUALLY STACK UP TO THE M-D-R-P-O-C THAT WAS POSTED? UH, SO THOSE ARE THE TWO POINTS THAT ARE CALLED OUT SPECIFICALLY IN THE METHODOLOGY.

AND LAST MONTH WHEN WE STOPPED BY, UH, ATTACK, WE HAD THE REQUEST TO PLEASE SEND US ADDITIONAL COMMENTS OR REQUESTS TO INCLUDE IN THIS PERFORMANCE REVIEW.

UM, WHAT WE ENDED UP RECEIVING WAS KIND OF A BULK OF METHODOLOGY COMMENTS RATHER THAN KIND OF PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS PIECES.

AND I'LL, I'LL GO INTO THAT NEXT.

BUT THE ONE REQUEST THAT WE DID RECEIVE THAT WAS FOCUSED ON PERFORMANCE WAS THIS THIRD BULLET POINT.

UM, AND, AND THE REQUEST WAS WHEN REVIEWING M-D-R-P-O-C EFFECTIVENESS, ERCOT SHOULD CONSIDER SENSITIVITIES TO LOAD GROWTH AND GENERATION RETIREMENTS ON THE DECREASING PLANNED OUTAGE AVAILABILITY AND HOW THAT DECREASED PLANNED OUTAGE ABILITY TRANSLATES TO RELIABILITY OUTCOMES.

SO REALLY JUST KIND OF HOLISTICALLY LOOKING AT, YOU KNOW, IF WE'RE WE'RE LOSING, UM, DISPATCHABLE GENERATION OR THERMAL GENERATION, UM, AND LOOKING OUT AT M-D-R-P-O-C, WE KIND OF HAD THIS COMMENT THAT YOU GO OUT THREE REALLY ANYTIME IN THE FUTURE YOU SEE THE TRENDS DECREASING, AND IF WE KNOW WE'RE HAVING MORE RETIREMENTS COMING, UM, AND SIGNIFICANT LOAD GROWTH, POTENTIALLY THIS IS SOMETHING WE SHOULD ANALYZE TO SEE HOW THAT MAY AFFECT ALSO KIND OF PLANNED OUTAGES, BUT UP AGAINST M-D-R-P-O-C.

SO WE DO PLAN TO INCLUDE THIS IN, UM, OUR PERFORMANCE REVIEW THAT, THAT WE WILL PRESENT.

UM, AND THAT'S THE LAST BULLET POINT HERE.

THAT'S, UH, WE'LL COME BACK TO TAC BEFORE THE END OF THIS YEAR TO PRESENT THESE THREE BULLET POINTS ALSO.

SO THAT WAS ONE COMMENT WE WE RECEIVED, AND I DID WANNA JUST MENTION IF ANYONE, ANY OF THE COMMENTERS WANT TO ADD FURTHER CLARIFICATION OR COMMENTS TO THESE BULLET POINTS, FEEL FREE TO JUMP IN ANYTIME, JUST LET ME KNOW.

YOU WANNA GO AHEAD? SURE.

UH, THANK YOU LUKE, FOR, FOR TAKING, UH, THE FEEDBACK FROM THE, THE VARIOUS STAKEHOLDERS.

I KNOW, I KNOW WE SENT SOME IN TO YOU AS, AS WELL AS OTHERS AND, AND REALLY APPRECIATE YOUR, YOUR REFLECT ON THOSE IN THIS PRESENTATION.

UM, ONE, ONE THING THAT, UH, WE'VE SEEN RECENTLY AND, UM, SO I APOLOGIZE FOR NOT PUTTING IT IN THERE EARLIER, BUT, UM, WE HAVE NOTICED THERE ARE TIMES WHEN THE M-D-R-P-O-C AMOUNT WILL, WILL KIND OF JUMP AROUND AS IT GETS UPDATED.

AND I'M THINKING ON THE FLY, UH, IF THERE IS A WAY TO CHARACTERIZE, YOU KNOW, THE CHANGES IN HOW FREQUENCY THE M-D-R-P-O-C OUTLOOK CHANGES, THAT MAY BE ANOTHER METRIC THAT WOULD BE HELPFUL IN, IN JUST EVALUATING, UM, YOU KNOW, IS IT CHANGING EVERY DAY? IS IT CHANGING, YOU KNOW, KIND OF BLOCKY IN A WEEK OR EVERY OTHER WEEK OR MONTH? SURE.

MONTH TIME FRAMEWORK.

OKAY.

OKAY.

UM, ONE REQUEST.

WOULD YOU MIND SUBMITTING THAT KIND OF IN A YEAH.

HAPPY TO SUMMARY FORM? SURE.

UM, I THINK THAT'S A GOOD POINT TOO.

WE CAN DO THAT.

OKAY.

SO NOW GETTING INTO THE COMMENTS THAT WERE REALLY FOCUSED ON, THE METHODOLOGY ITSELF, AND WHAT I'VE DONE

[03:20:01]

IS SUMMARIZE THESE, UM, KIND OF TO THE BEST OF MY ABILITY, BUT THAT'S WHERE IF YOU FEEL YOU WANT TO ADD SOME MORE COMMENTS, UH, BETWEEN THE COMMENTERS, PLEASE JUMP IN, LET ME KNOW.

UM, DO YOU WANNA GO AHEAD AND ASK ERIC? NO, THAT'S FINE.

OKAY.

SO FIRST BULLET POINT CONSIDERATION OF BATTERY CONTRIBUTION SHOULD BE REVIEWED, UH, RIGHT NOW AN M-D-R-P-O-C, UH, BATTERY CONTRIBUTION ZERO IN THE METHODOLOGY.

UM, SO SOMETHING TO CONSIDER SHOULD THAT BE SOMETHING ELSE.

UM, LOOKING AT SOMETHING LIKE MOURA AND WHAT THEY CONSIDER MAYBE AS A STARTING PLACE, BUT SOMETHING TO CONSIDER.

UH, SECOND ONE, CONSIDERATION OF NEW GENERATION BEYOND PLANNING GUIDE 6.9 SHOULD BE REVIEWED DUE TO SIGNIFICANT LOW GROWTH.

SO RIGHT NOW THE METHODOLOGY IS VERY CLEAR OF WHAT, WHAT CAN BE CONSIDERED FOR FUTURE GENERATION SHOULD THIS BE REVISED.

UH, THIRD BULLET POINT, THE CURRENT CONTRACT PERIOD FOR A FIRM FUEL SUPPLY SERVICE F-F-F-F-S-S RUNS FROM NOVEMBER 15TH THROUGH MARCH 15TH OF THE FOLLOWING YEAR.

TO ENSURE THESE RESOURCES HAVE COMPLETED NECESSARY MAINTENANCE PRIOR TO THE CONTRACT PERIOD, START DATE PLAN OUTAGE REQUESTS FROM THESE UNITS SHOULD BE PRIORITIZED IN THE PLANNING OUTAGE QUEUE.

UM, SO SOMETHING TO CONSIDER.

UM, NEXT BULLET POINT, PRIORITIZE PLAN RESOURCE OUTAGES FOR MAJOR TURBINE INSPECTIONS AND MAINTENANCE.

UH, SO I THINK THE, THE WAY THIS WAS KIND OF SUBMITTED WAS THERE'S, THERE'S DEFINITELY, UM, SUBSETS OF OUTAGE REQUESTS THAT REQUIRE, UM, GREATER KIND OF, UM, INSPECTION PERIOD AND KIND OF COMMITMENT TO THOSE OUTAGES AND SCHEDULING.

THOSE ARE SEEM TO BE MORE, MORE DIFFICULT, WHICH IS UNDERSTAND UNDERSTANDABLE.

SO IF THERE'S A WAY TO PRIORITIZE THOSE OR LUMP THOSE INTO A DIFFERENT CATEGORY, MAYBE THAT'S SOMETHING WE SHOULD CONSIDER.

AND THEN ALLOW ERCOT FLEXIBILITY TO APPROVE OUTAGES THAT MAY EXTEND A DAY BEYOND AVAILABLE CAPACITY.

SO IF IT JUST HAPPENS TO BE THAT THE LAST TAIL END OF THE OUTAGE IS CAUSING AN AN ISSUE, MAYBE THAT'S, THERE'S SOME WIGGLE ROOM THERE THAT WE COULD BUILD INTO THE METHODOLOGY.

DID YOU WANT SOME? YEAH, I THINK, UH, MANY OF THESE COMMENTS WERE THINGS THAT WERE, UH, PREVIOUSLY RAGED BY TCPA AND ITS MEMBERS.

AND I JUST WANTED TO POINT OUT AS WE'RE WORKING THROUGH DEVELOPING THIS PROCESS, THAT WE THINK MOST OF THOSE COMMENTS MAKE SENSE.

WE'VE GOT ONE OR TWO DETAILED QUESTIONS, BUT YOU KNOW, DIRECTIONALLY, UM, WHAT TCPA IS ATTEMPTING TO ACCOMPLISH HERE MAKES SENSE TO US.

AND SO I, I HOPE WE CAN SEE SOME REFORM TO THIS PROCESS.

GO AHEAD, NED.

OH, SOMEONE ELSE? ERIC? YES.

I DON'T KNOW IF THIS IS THE FORUM TO, TO DISCUSS THIS, BUT, UH, WE'VE HAD A LOT OF, UH, LINGERING FORCED OUTAGES THIS YEAR, AND I WAS WONDERING HOW THIS IS GONNA BE REVIEWED BY ERCOT IN TERMS OF PROCESS, UH, IN TERMS OF, UM, BETTER COORDINATION.

OBVIOUSLY DRRS DOWN THE LINE MIGHT TAKE CARE OF SOME OF THAT, BUT IS THERE ANY THOUGHT GIVEN, GIVEN TO WHAT WE'VE SEEN THIS, THIS PAST YEAR OF, OF WHAT MIGHT BE DONE, FRED? YEAH.

HI, IT'S FRED FROM WORK.

I THINK IF THAT IS NOT RELATED TO M-D-R-P-O-C, BUT IT'S KIND OF VOLTAGE, UM, SORRY, OUTAGE RELATED, WE THEN MORE THAN HAPPY TO WORK WITH YOU, UH, TO SEE IF THERE ARE WAYS WE CAN, UH, BETTER ACCOMMODATE NEED TO ON THIS FRIDAY, NEXT FRIDAY.

OKAY, THANKS.

UM, SO ONCE AGAIN, THANK YOU FOR INCLUDING THESE, AND ERIC, I APPRECIATE YOUR, YOUR COMMENTS OF, OF SUPPORT FOR THE CONCEPTS.

UH, I WAS CURIOUS, YOU KNOW, THAT'S OKAY.

AS YOU, AS YOU WENT THROUGH THIS, YOU KNOW, YOU HIGHLIGHTED THAT, UH, Y'ALL'S EFFORTS ARE GONNA BE FOCUSED ON THE THINGS ON THE FIRST PAGE.

UM, SO IS THE RIGHT PATH FORWARD FOR TCPA AND ANY ANYONE ELSE THAT'S INTERESTED TO GET TOGETHER AND, AND SUBMIT AN NPRR TO, UH, TO MOVE THIS FORWARD OR MAYBE HAVE SOME OFFLINE DISCUSSIONS? YEAH, I THINK WHAT I CAN DO TOO, MAYBE FINISH THIS LAST ONE AND THEN I'LL KIND OF TALK NEXT STEPS OF, OF WHAT WE'RE CONSIDERING.

BUT I WAS LOOKING FOR FEEDBACK TOO, FROM TECH ON THAT AS WELL.

OKAY, FANTASTIC.

OKAY.

ANY OTHER QUESTIONS OR COLIN? YEAH, I WAS KIND OF FOLLOWING UP ON ERIC'S QUESTION, UH, FROM JUST A SECOND AGO.

I MEAN, SO ON THE, ON THE SCOPE FROM THE, FROM THE FIRST SLIDE, I MEAN, IT IS THE ERCOT ASSESSMENT GOING TO ASSESS THE POTENTIAL IMPACTS OF THE M-D-R-M-D-R-P-O-C TO FORCED OUTAGES THAT WE HAVE SEEN.

I THINK, UM, YOU, YOU MAY, THAT MAY BE COVERED SOMEWHAT

[03:25:01]

IN THAT THIRD POINT, BUT, UM, IT MAY BE GOOD TO CLARIFY THAT SPECIFIC POINT AS A, AS A FORMAL REQUEST AS WELL.

UM, AND SOMETHING THAT WE PLAN TO PRESENT, I THINK THAT'S KIND OF GENERALLY, LIKE FRED WAS POINTING TO A, AN OUTAGE, NOT NECESSARILY JUST M-D-R-P-O-C, ALTHOUGH IT DOES SEEM LIKE IT COULD BE RELATED.

BUT, UM, RIGHT NOW WE'RE FOCUSING ON KIND OF THIS SPECIFIC POINT, BUT I THINK WE